Record of a Remarkable War Pilgrimage
Told by Count Van Maurik De Beaufort
This is the remarkable story of a titled Hollander, who was
living in America at the outbreak of the War. "Europe called
me," he says. "Blood will tell. I soon found myself getting
restless. My sympathies with the Allies ... urged that I had
no right to lag behind in making sacrifices. Before starting for
the War, I applied for my first American citizenship papers. I
hope to obtain my final papers shortly, after which I shall place
my services at the disposal of the American Government." This
Hollander was educated in Germany and recalls how in his
youth he was forced to stand up in front of the class and
recite five verses, each ending with: "I am a Prussian and a
Prussian I will be." He later became a student at Bonn.
Count De Beaufort has written a book of sensational revelations
in which the German veil is lifted. With a magic passport,
nothing less than a letter to Von Hindenburg from his
nephew, he gained access to German headquarters and to the
Eastern front in Poland and East Prussia. We here record
what he thinks of Von Hindenburg from his book: "Behind
the German Veil," by permission of his publishers, Dodd, Mead
and Company: Copyright 1917.
[1]
I—GOING TO SEE VON HINDENBURG
Yes, if the truth be told, I must say that I felt just
a wee bit shaky about the knees. I wondered what view
they would take of my perseverance, worthy, I am sure,
of a kind reception.
I would wager that in the whole of Germany there
could not be found one ... whose hair would not
have stood on end at the mere suggestion of travelling
to Hindenburg's headquarters without a pass. Why,
he would sooner think of calling at the Palace "Unter
den Linden," and of asking to interview the Kaiser.
I think I must describe to you the way I appeared at
headquarters. At Allenstein I had bought, the day before,
a huge portrait of Hindenburg; it must have been
nearly thirty inches long.
Under one arm I carried the photograph, in my hand
my letter of introduction, and in my other hand a huge
umbrella, which was a local acquisition. On my face I
wore that beatific, enthusiastic and very naïve expression
of "the innocent abroad." I had blossomed out into
that modern pest—the autographic maniac.
Army corps, headquarters, strategy and tactics were
words that meant nothing to me. How could they, stupid,
unmilitary foreigner that I was! It was a pure case of
"Fools will enter where angels fear to tread." You
may be sure that my subsequent conversation with the
Staff captain confirmed the idea that I was innocent of
all military knowledge, and that I probably—so he
thought—did not know the difference between an army
corps and a section of snipers.
Why had I come to Lötzen? Why, of course, to shake
hands with the famous General, the new Napoleon; to
have a little chat with him, and—last, but not least—to
obtain his most priceless signature to my most priceless
photograph. What? Not as easy as all that, but why?
Could there be any harm in granting me those favors?
Could it by the furthest stretch of imagination be considered
as giving information to the enemy? What good
was my letter of introduction from the General's dear
nephew? Of course, I would not ask the General where
he had his guns hidden, and when he intended to take
Petrograd, Moscow or Kieff. Oh, no; I knew enough
about military matters not to ask such leading questions.
But joking apart. On showing my famous letter I
had no difficulty whatsoever in entering the buildings
of the General Staff. The first man I met was Hauptmann
Frantz. He didn't seem a bad sort at all, and appeared
rather to enjoy the joke and my "innocence,"
at imagining that I could walk up to Hindenburg's Eastern
headquarters and say "Hello!" to the General.
He thought it was most "original," and certainly exceedingly
American. Still, it got him into the right mood.
"Make people smile," might be a good motto for itinerant
journalists in the war zones. Few people, not excepting
Germans, are so mean as to bite you with a smile on their
faces. Make them laugh, and half the battle is won.
Frantz read my letter and was duly impressed. He
never asked me whether I had any passes. He advised
me to go to the General's house, shook hands, and wished
me luck.
Phew! I was glad that my first contact with the
General Staff had come off so smoothly. I had been
fully prepared for stormy weather, if not for a hurricane.
Cockily, I went off to Hindenburg's residence, a
very modest suburban village not far from the station,
and belonging to a country lawyer. There was a bit of
garden in front, and at the back; the house was new,
and the bricks still bright red. Across the road on two
poles a wide banner was stretched, with "Willkommen"
painted on it.
Two old Mecklenburger Landstrum men guarded the
little wooden gate. I told them that I came from Great
Headquarters, and once more produced the letter. They
saluted, opened the gate, and one of them ran ahead
to ring the door bell.
II—HE ENTERS THE STRANGE HOUSE
I walked up the little gravel path with here and there
a patch of green dilapidated grass on either side. I
remember the window curtains were of yellow plush. In
the window seat stood a tall vase with artificial flowers
flanked by a birdcage with two canaries. It was all
very suburban, and did not look at all like the residence
of such a famous man. An orderly, with his left arm
thrust into a top-boot, opened the door. In a tone of
voice that left no chance for the familiar War-Office
question: "Have you an appointment, sir?" I inquired
whether the Field-Marshal was at home, at the same
time giving him my letter. The orderly peeled off his
top-boot, unfastened his overalls, and slipped on his coat.
Then he carefully took my letter, holding it gingerly
between thumb and third finger, so as not to leave any
marks on it, and ushered me into the "Wohnzimmer,"
a sort of living- and dining-room combined. It was the
usual German affair. A couch, a table, a huge porcelain
stove, were the prominent pieces of furniture. All
three were ranged against the long wall. The straight-backed
chairs were covered with red plush. On the
walls hung several monstrosities, near-etchings representing
the effigies of the Kaiser, the Kaiserin, and, of
course, of "Our" Hindenburg. There was the usual overabundance
of artificial flowers and ferns so dear to the
heart of every German Hausfrau.
The two canaries lived in the most elaborate homemade
cage. (I understand they were the property of
the "Hausfrau," not of Hindenburg!) On the table,
covered with a check tablecloth, stood a bowl containing
three goldfish. The floor was covered with a bright carpet,
and in front of one of the doors lay a mat with
"Salve" on it. Over the couch hung a photographic enlargement
of a middle-aged soldier leaning nonchalantly
against a door on which was chalked "Kriegsjahr, 1914."
Over the frame hung a wreath with a black and white ribbon,
inscribed "In Memoriam," telling its eloquent story.
Behind me was a map of the Eastern front, and pinned
alongside of it a caricature of a British Tommy sitting
astride of a pyramid and pulling a number of strings
fastened to the legs, arms and head of the Sultan, who
was apparently dancing a jig.
That room impressed itself upon my memory for all
time. I often dream of it.
I had waited only a few minutes when a young officer
came in, who, bowing obsequiously, wished me a very
formal good-morning. I took my cue from the way he
bowed. He explained that the General was out in the
car but was expected back before noon. Would I condescend
to wait? Needless to say, I did "condescend."
I forgot to mention one point in my meditations. When
I took the chance of continuing East instead of returning
to Berlin, I thought there might just be a possibility that
the Adjutant or Staff Officer who had spoken with von
Schlieffen had entirely taken it upon himself to say "No,"
and that it was not unlikely that the General knew nothing
whatever about my letter or my contemplated visit.
If my surmise was correct, I would stand a sporting
chance, because it was hardly to be expected that out of
the thirty-odd officers comprising the Staff, I should run
bang into the very man who had telephoned.
I soon knew that the officer in immediate attendance
on Hindenburg was not aware of my contretempts at
Allenstein on the previous day. Neither did he inquire
after my passes. You see, they take these things for
granted. Would I prefer to wait here or come in his
office, where the stove was lit? Of course, I thought
that would be more pleasant. I thought, and am glad
to say was not mistaken, that probably the young officer
felt he needed some mental relaxation. This will sound
strange, but I have found during my travels through
Germany, that in spite of the many warnings not to talk
shop, every soldier, from the humblest private to the highest
General—I am sure not excepting the War Lord himself—dearly
loves to expatiate on matters military, his
ambitions and hopes. This one was no exception. He
chatted away very merrily, and more than once I recognized
points and arguments which I had read weeks ago
in interviews granted by General Hindenburg to Austrian
journalists. He quite imagined himself an embryo
Field-Marshal.
He showed me several excellent maps, which gave every
railroad line on both sides of the Polish frontier. They
certainly emphasized the enormous difference and the
many advantages of German versus Russian railroad communications.
Many of his predictions have since come
true, but most of them have not. He hinted very mysteriously,
but quite unmistakably, at a prospective Russian
débâcle, and predicted a separate peace with Russia before
the end of 1915! "And then," he added, "we will
shake up the old women at the Western front a bit and
show them the 'Hindenburg method.'"
The room we were in was fitted up as an emergency
staff office. There were several large tables, maps galore,
a safe, a number of books that looked like ledgers
and journals, six telephones and a telegraph instrument.
Two non-commissioned officers were writing in a corner.
In case anything important happens at night, such as an
urgent despatch that demands immediate attention, everything
was at hand to enable the General to issue new
orders. A staff-officer and a clerk are always on duty.
I learned later on, though, that a position in that
auxiliary staff-office at Hindenburg's residence is more
or less of a sinecure. All despatches go first to Ludendorff,
Hindenburg's Chief-of-Staff, who, in ninety-nine
cases out of a hundred, issues orders without consulting
his Chief.
III—HE STANDS BEFORE VON HINDENBURG
In the midst of a long explanation of the Russian
plight, the voluble subaltern suddenly stopped short. I
heard a car halt in front of the house, and a minute
or two later the door of the office opened and Germany's
giant idol entered. I rose and bowed. The officer and
the two sergeants clicked their heels audibly, and replied
to the stentorian "Morgen, meine Herren," with a brisk
"Morgen, Excellence."
Hindenburg looked questions at me, but I thought I
would let my young friend do the talking and act as
master of ceremonies. He handed Hindenburg my letter,
and introduced me as "Herr 'von' Beaufort, who has
just arrived from Rome." (I had left Rome nearly three
months before!) The General read his nephew's letter
and then shook hands with me, assuring me of the pleasure
it gave him to meet me. Of course, I was glad that
he was glad, and expressed reciprocity of sentiments.
I looked at him—well, for lack of a better word, I will
say, with affection; you know the kind of childlike, simple
admiration which expresses so much. I tried to look
at him as a certain little girl would have done, who wrote:
"You are like my governess: she, too, knows everything."
I felt sure that that attitude was a better one than to
pretend that I was overawed. That sort of homage he
must receive every day. Besides, as soon as I realized
that he knew nothing of the telephone message from and
to Allenstein, my old self-assurance had returned.
Now for my impressions of Germany's—and, as some
people try to make us believe, the world's—greatest military
genius. They might be summed up in two words:
"Strength and cruelty." Hindenburg stands over six feet
high. His whole personality radiates strength, brute, animal
strength. He was, when I met him, sixty-nine years
of age, but looked very much younger. His hair and
moustache were still pepper and salt color. His face and
forehead are deeply furrowed, which adds to his forbidding
appearance. His nose and chin are prominent,
but the most striking feature of the man's whole appearance
are his eyes. They are steel-blue and very small,
much too small for his head, which, in turn, is much too
small compared with his large body. But what the eyes
lacked in size they fully made up for in intensity and
penetrating powers. Until I met Hindenburg I always
thought that the eyes of the Mexican rebel Villa were the
worst and most cruel I had ever seen. They are mild
compared with those of Hindenburg. Never in all my
life have I seen such hard, cruel, nay, such utterly brutal
eyes as those of Hindenburg. The moment I looked at
him I believed every story of refined (and unrefined)
cruelty I had ever heard about him.
He has the disagreeable habit of looking at you as if
he did not believe a word you said. Frequently in conversation
he closes his eyes, but even then it seemed as
if their steel-like sharpness pierced his eyelids. Instead
of deep circles, such as, for instance, I have noticed on
the Kaiser, he has big fat cushions of flesh under his
eyes, which accentuate their smallness. When he closes
his eyes, these cushions almost touch his bushy eyebrows
and give his face a somewhat prehistoric appearance.
His hair, about an inch long I should judge, was
brushed straight up—what the French call en brosse. The
general contour of his head seemed that of a square,
rounded off at the corners.
Speaking about the stories of cruelty, one or two of
them may bear re-telling.
When during the heavy fighting, early in 1915, General
Rennenkampf was forced to evacuate Insterburg
somewhat hastily, he was unable to find transport for
about fifty thousand loaves of bread. Not feeling inclined
to make a present of them to the Germans, he
ordered paraffin to be poured over them. When the
Germans found that bread and discovered its condition,
Hindenburg is reported to have been frantic with rage.
The next day, after he had calmed down, he said to one
of his aides: "Well, it seems to be a matter of taste.
If the Russians like their bread that way, very well.
Give it to the Russian prisoners."
You may feel certain that his orders were scrupulously
carried out.
Another incident which they are very fond of relating
in Germany is more amusing, though it also plays on
their idol's cruelty.
It is a fact that both officers and men are deadly
afraid of him. It is said that the great General has a
special predilection for bringing the tip of his riding boots
into contact with certain parts of the human anatomy.
A private would far rather face day and night the Russian
guns than be orderly to Hindenburg.
But one day a man came up and offered himself for
the job.
"And what are you in private life?" the General
snorted at him.
"At your orders, sir, I am a wild animal trainer."
IV—"WHAT VON HINDENBURG TOLD ME"
Hindenburg and I talked for about twenty minutes on
various subjects—Holland, Italy, America, and, of course,
the campaign.
When he tried to point out to me how all-important
it was for Holland that Germany should crush England's
"world-domination," I mentioned the Dutch Colonies.
That really set him going. "Colonies," he shouted.
"Pah! I am sick of all this talk about colonies. It would
be better for people, and I am not referring to our enemies
alone, to pay more attention to events in Europe. I say
'to the devil' (zum Teufel) with the colonies. Let us
first safeguard our own country; the colonies will follow.
It is here," and he went up to a large map of Poland
hanging on the wall, and laid a hand almost as large as
a medium-sized breakfast tray over the center of it—"It
is here," he continued, "that European and colonial affairs
will be settled and nowhere else. As far as the colonies
are concerned, it will be a matter of a foot for a mile, as
long as we hold large slices of enemy territory."
He spoke with great respect of the Russian soldier, but
maintained that they lacked proper leaders. "It takes
more than ten years to reform the morale of an officers'
corps. From what I have learned, the morale of the Russian
officer is to this day much the same as it was in the
Russo-Japanese war. We will show you one of their ambulance
trains captured near Kirbaty. It is the last word
in luxury. By all means give your wounded all the comfort,
all the attention you can; but I do not think that
car-loads of champagne, oysters, caviare and the finest
French liqueurs are necessary adjuncts to an ambulance
train. The Russian soldier is splendid, but his discipline
is not of the same quality as that of our men. In our
armies discipline is the result of spiritual and moral training;
in the Russian armies discipline stands for dumb
obedience. The Russian soldier remains at his post because
he has been ordered to stay there, and he stands
as if nailed to the spot. What Napoleon I. said still applies
to-day: 'It is not sufficient to kill a Russian, you
have to throw him over as well.'
"It is absurd," the General continued, "for the enemy
Press to compare this campaign with that of Napoleon
in 1812." Again he got up, and pointing to another map,
he said: "This is what will win the war for us." The
map showed the close railroad net of Eastern Germany
and the paucity of permanent roads in Russia. Hindenburg
is almost a crank on the subject of railroads in connection
with strategy. In the early days of the war he
shuffled his army corps about from one corner of Poland
to the other. It is said that he transferred four army
corps (160,000 men—about 600 trains) in two days from
Kalish, in Western Poland, to Tannenberg, a distance of
nearly two hundred miles. On some tracks the trains
followed each other at intervals of six minutes.
"Our enemies reckon without two great factors unknown
in Napoleon's time: railroads and German organization.
Next to artillery this war means railroads, railroads,
and then still more railroads. The Russians built
forts; we built railroads. They would have spent their
millions better if they had emulated our policy instead
of spending millions on forts. For the present fortresses
are of no value against modern siege guns—at least, not
until another military genius such as Vauban, Brialmont,
Montalembert, Coehoorn, springs up, who will be able
to invent proper defensive measures against heavy howitzers.
"Another delusion under which our enemies are laboring
is that of Russia's colossal supply of men. He
who fights with Russia must always expect superiority
in numbers; but in this age of science, strategy and organization,
numbers are only decisive, 'all else being
equal.' The Russian forces opposed to us on this front
have always been far superior in numbers to ours, but
we are not afraid of that. A crowd of men fully armed
and equipped does not make an army in these days."
This brought him to the subject of the British forces,
more especially to Kitchener's army. "It is a great mistake
to underestimate your enemy," said Hindenburg, referring
to the continual slights and attacks appearing in
the German Press. "I by no means underrate the thoroughness,
the fighting qualities of the British soldier.
England is a fighting nation, and has won her spurs on
many battlefields. But to-day they are up against a different
problem. Even supposing that Kitchener should
be able to raise his army of several millions, where is he
going to get his officers and his non-commissioned officers
from? How is he going to train them, so to speak, overnight,
when it has taken us several generations of uninterrupted
instruction, study and work to create an efficient
staff? Let me emphasize, and with all the force I
can: 'Efficiency and training are everything.' There lies
their difficulty. I have many officers here with me who
have fought opposite the English, and all are united in
their opinion that they are brave and worthy opponents;
but one criticism was also unanimously made: 'Their officers
often lead their men needlessly to death, either from
sheer foolhardiness, but more often through inefficiency.'"
V—"WHEN I LEFT VON HINDENBURG"
Although he did not express this opinion to me personally,
I have it on excellent authority that Hindenburg
believes this war will last close on four years at least.
And the result—stalemate. He does not believe that the
Allies will be able to push the Germans out of Belgium,
France or Poland.
Personally, I found it impossible to get him to make
any definite statement on the probable outcome and duration
of the war. "Until we have gained an honorable
peace," was his cryptic reply. He refused to state what,
in his opinion, constituted an honorable peace. If I am
to believe several of his officers—and I discussed the subject
almost every day—then Hindenburg must by now be
a very disappointed man. I was told that he calculated
as a practical certainty on a separate peace with Russia
soon after the fall of Warsaw. (I should like to point
out here that this "separate peace with Russia" idea was
one of the most popular and most universal topics of conversation
in Germany last year.)
When Hindenburg learnt that I had come all the way
from Berlin without a pass from the General Staff, he
appeared very much amused; but in a quasi-serious manner
he said:
"Well, you know that I ought to send you back at
once, otherwise I shall risk getting the sack myself;
still, as all ordinary train-service between here and Posen
will be suspended for four days, the only way for you
to get back is by motor-car. It would be a pity to come
all the way from sunny Italy to this Siberian cold, and
not see something of the men and of the hardships of a
Russian winter campaign. Travelling by motor-car, you
will have ample opportunity to see something of the country,
and, if you feel so inclined, of the fighting as well.
And then go home and tell them abroad about the insurmountable
obstacles, the enormous difficulties the German
has to overcome."
Hindenburg does not like the Berlin General Staff
officers, and that is why he was so amused at my having
got the better of them. He describes them as "drawing-room"
officers, who remain safely in Berlin. With
their spick and span uniforms they look askance at their
mud-stained colleagues at the front. His officers, who
know Hindenburg's feelings towards these gentlemen,
play many a practical joke on their Berlin confrères. The
latter have frequently returned from a visit to some
communication trenches only to find that their car has
mysteriously retreated some two or three miles ... over
Polish roads.
Any one who can tell of such an experience befalling
a "Salon Offizier" is sure to raise a good laugh from Hindenburg.
At the conclusion of our conversation he instructed the
young A.D.C. to take me over to Headquarters and present
me to Captain Cämmerer. "Tell him," and I inscribed
the words that followed deeply on my mind, "to
be kind to Herr Beaufort."
My introduction to Cämmerer proved to be one of
those curious vagaries of fate. He was the very man
who less than twenty-four hours ago had spoken with
General von Schlieffen, and who had assured him how
impossible it was for me to continue, and that I was
to be sent back to Berlin at once!
"Beaufort, Beaufort," he sniffed once or twice before
he could place me. Then suddenly he remembered. "Ah,
yes, him! You are the man General von Schlieffen telephoned
about yesterday? But did he not instruct you to
return to Berlin?"
However, I remembered Hindenburg's injunction:
"Tell Cämmerer to be kind to him," so what did I care for
a mere captain?
Consequently, as they say in the moving pictures, I
"registered" my most angelic smile, and sweetly said:
"Ah, yes, Captain, quite so, quite so. But, you see,
I felt certain that there was some misunderstanding at
this end of the wire. Probably it was not clearly explained
to you that I had this very important letter of
introduction to General von Hindenburg from my friend
his nephew. As you see," and I waved my hand at the
A.D.C., my master of ceremonies, "I was quite right in
my surmise."
However that may be, you may be certain that I saw
to it that when we mapped out my return journey, Cämmerer
was being "kind" to me. Consequently, I spent
two most interesting weeks in the German Eastern war-zones,
much to the surprise and disgust of the "Drawing-room
Staff" in Berlin.
(Count De Beaufort's revelations form one of the most
valuable records of the war. He tells about "Spies and
Spying;" "German Women;" "When I Prayed with the
Kaiser;" "An Incognito Visit to the Fleet and German
Naval Harbors;" "Interviews with the Leading Naval,
Military and Civil Authorities in Germany"—closing with
an interview that upset Berlin, caused his arrest, and as
he describes it, "My Ultimate Escape Across the Baltic.")