THE EXPOSURE
Tom's arrangement with the detective
agency was that Baxter and Foley were to
be watched day and night, and that he
was to have as frequent reports as it was
possible to give. Just before six o'clock that same
afternoon he called at the office for his first report.
It was ready—a minute account of the movements
of the two men between one and five. There was
absolutely nothing in it of value to him, except that
its apparent completeness was a guarantee that if
anything was to be found the men on the case would
find it.
Never before in Tom's life had there been as many
hours between an evening and a morning. He dared
not lessen his suspense and the hours by discussing his
present move with friends; they could not help him,
and, if he told them, there was the possibility that
some word might slip to Foley which would rouse
suspicion and destroy the thousandth chance. But at
length morning came, and at ten o'clock Tom was at
the detective agency. Again there was a minute report,
the sum of whose worth to him was—nothing.
He went into the street and walked, fear and suspense
mounting higher and higher. In ten hours the
union would meet to decide, and as yet he had no bit
of evidence. At twelve o'clock he was at the office
again. There was nothing for him. Eight more
hours. At two o'clock, dizzy and shaking from suspense,
he came into the office for the third time that
day. A report was waiting.
He glanced it through, then trying to speak calmly,
said to the manager: "Send anything else to my
house."
Tom had said to himself that he had one chance in
a thousand. But this was a miscalculation. His
chance had been better than that, and had been made
so by Mr. Baxter's shrewd arrangement for his dealings
with Foley, based upon his theory that one of the
surest ways of avoiding suspicion is to do naturally
and openly the thing you would conceal. Mr. Baxter's
theory overlooked the possibility that suspicion
might already be roused and on watch.
Tom did not look at the sheet of paper in the hallway
or in the street; with three thousand union men in
the street, all of whom knew him, one was likely to
pounce upon him at any minute and gain his secret
prematurely. With elation hammering against his
ribs, he hurried through a cross street toward the
little park, which in the last five months had come to
be his study. The sheet of paper was buttoned
tightly in his coat, but all the time his brain was reading
a few jerky phrases in the detail-packed report.
In the park, and on a bench having the seclusion of
a corner, he drew the report from his pocket and read
it eagerly, several times. Here was as much as he
had hoped for—evidence that what he had suspected
was true. With the few relevant facts of the report
as a basis he began to reconstruct the secret proceedings
of the last three weeks. At each step he tested
conjectures till he found the only one that perfectly
fitted all the known circumstances. Progress from
the known backward to the unknown was not difficult,
and by five o'clock the reconstruction was complete.
He then began to lay his plans for the evening.
Tom preferred not to face Maggie, with her demands
certain to be repeated, so he had his dinner in a
restaurant whose only virtue was its cheapness. At
half past seven he arrived at Potomac Hall, looking
as much his usual self as he could. He passed with
short nods the groups of men who stood before the
building—some of whom had once been his supporters,
but who now nodded negligently—and
entered the big bar-room. There were perhaps a
hundred men here, all talking loudly; but comparatively
few were drinking or smoking—money was too
scarce. He paused an instant just within the door
and glanced about. The men he looked for were not
there, and he started rapidly across the room.
"Hello, Keating! How's your strike?" called
one of the crowd, a man whom, two months before, he
himself had convinced a strike should be made.
"Eat-'Em-Up Keating, who don't know when he's
had enough!" shouted another, with a jeer.
"Three cheers for Keating!" cried a third, and
led off with a groan. The three groans were given
heartily, and at their end the men broke into laughter.
Tom burned at these crude insults, but kept straight
on his way.
There were also friends in the crowd,—a few.
When the laughter died down one cried out: "What's
the matter with Keating?" The set answer came,
"He's all right!"—but very weak. It was followed
by an outburst of groans and hisses.
As Tom was almost at the door the stub of a cigar
struck smartly beneath his ear, and the warm ashes
slipped down inside his collar. There was another
explosion of laughter. Tom whirled about, and with
one blow sent to the floor the man who had thrown
the cigar. The laugh broke off, and in the sudden
quiet Tom passed out of the bar-room and joined the
stream of members going up the broad stairway and
entering the hall.
The hall was more than half filled with men—some
sitting patiently in their chairs, some standing
with one foot on chair seats, some standing in the
aisles and leaning against the walls, all discussing the
same subject, the abandonment of the strike. The
general mood of the men was one of bitter eagerness,
as it was also the mood of the men below, for all
their coarse jesting,—the bitterness of admitted defeat,
the eagerness to be back at their work without
more delay.
Tom glanced around, and immediately he saw Petersen
coming toward him, his lean brown face glowing.
"Hello, Petersen. I was looking for you," he said
in a whisper when the Swede had gained his side.
"I want you by me to-night."
"Yah."
Petersen's manner announced that he wanted to
speak, and Tom now remembered, what he had forgotten
in his two days' absorption, the circumstances
under which he had last seen the Swede. "How are
things at home?" he asked.
"Ve be goin' to move. A better house." After
this bit of loquacity Petersen smiled blissfully—and
said no more.
Tom told Petersen to join him later, and then
hurried over to Barry and Jackson, whom he saw
talking with a couple other of his friends in the
front of the hall. "Boys, I want to tell you something
in a minute," he whispered. "Where's Pete?"
"The committee's havin' a meetin' in Connelly's
office," answered Barry.
Tom hurried to Connelly's office and knocked.
"Come in," a voice called, and he opened the door.
The five men were just leaving their chairs.
"Hello, Pete. Can I see you as soon's you're
through?" Tom asked.
"Sure. Right now."
Connelly improved the opportunity by offering
Tom some advice, emphasized in the customary manner,
and ended with the request: "Now for God's
sake, keep your wind-hole plugged up to-night!"
Tom did not reply, but as he was starting away
with Pete he heard Foley say to the secretary:
"Youse can't blame him, Connelly. Some o' the
rest of us know it ain't so easy to give up a fight."
Tom found Barry, Petersen and the three others
waiting, and with them was Johnson, who having
noticed Tom whispering to them had carelessly joined
the group during his absence. "If you fellows'll step
back here I'll finish that little thing I was telling," he
said, and led the way to a rear corner, a dozen yards
away from the nearest group.
When he turned to face the six, he found there
were seven. Johnson had followed. Tom hesitated.
He did not care to speak before Johnson; he had
always held that person in light esteem because of his
variable opinions. And he did not care to ask Johnson
to leave; that course might beget a scene which in
turn would beget suspicion. It would be better to
speak before him, and then see that he remained with
the group.
"Don't show the least surprise while I'm talking;
act like it was nothing at all," he began in a whisper.
And then he told them in a few sentences what he
had discovered, and what he planned to do.
They stared at him in astonishment. "Don't look
like that or you'll give away that we've got a scheme
up our sleeves," he warned them. "Now I want you
fellows to stand by me. There may be trouble.
Come on, let's get our seats. The meeting will open
pretty soon."
He had already picked out a spot, at the front end
on the right side, the corner formed by the wall and
the grand piano. He now led the way toward this.
Half-way up the aisle he chanced to look behind him.
There were only six men. Johnson was gone.
"Take the seats up there," he whispered, and
hurried out of the hall, with a fear that Johnson at
that minute might be revealing what he had heard to
Foley. But when he reached the head of the stairway
he saw at its foot Foley, Hogan, and Brown
starting slowly up. With sudden relief he turned
back and joined his party. A little later Connelly
mounted the platform and gave a few preliminary
raps on his table, and Johnson was forgotten.
The men standing about the hall found seats.
Word was sent to the members loitering below that
the meeting was beginning, and they came up in a
straggling body, two hundred strong. Every chair
was filled; men had to stand in the aisles, and along
the walls, and in the rear where there were no seats.
It was the largest gathering of the union there had
been in three years. Tom noted this, and was glad.
All the windows were open, but yet the hall was
suffocatingly close. Hundreds of cigars were momently
making it closer, and giving the upper stratum
of the room's atmosphere more and more the appearance
of a solid. Few coats were on; they hung over
the arms of those standing, and lay in the laps of
those who sat. Connelly, putting down his gavel,
took off his collar and tie and laid them on his table,
an example that was given the approval of general
imitation. Everywhere faces were being mopped.
Connelly rapped again, and stood waiting till quiet
had spread among the fifteen hundred men. "I
guess you all know what we're here for," he began.
"If there's no objection I guess we can drop the regular
order o' business and get right to the strike."
There was a general cry of "consent."
"Very well. Then first we'll hear from the strike
committee."
Foley, as chairman of the strike committee, should
have spoken for it; but the committee, being aware
of the severe humiliation he was suffering, and to
save him what public pain it could, had sympathetically
decided that some other member should deliver
its report. And Foley, with his cunning that extended
even to the smallest details, had suggested Pete, and
Pete had been selected.
Pete now rose, and with hands on Tom's shoulders,
calmly spoke what the committee had ordered. The
committee's report was that it had nothing new to
report. After carefully considering every circumstance
it saw no possible way of winning the strike.
It strongly advised the union to yield at once, as
further fighting meant only further loss of wages.
Pete was hardly back in his seat when it was moved
and seconded that the union give up the strike. A
great stamping and cries of "That's right!" "Give
it up!" "Let's get back to work!" joined to give
the motion a tremendous uproar of approval.
"You have heard the motion," said Connelly.
"Any remarks?"
Men sprang up in all parts of the crowd, and for
over an hour there were brief speeches, every one in
favor of yielding. In substance they were the same:
"Since the strike's lost, let's get back to work and not
lose any more wages." Every speaker was applauded
with hand-clapping, stamps, and shouts; an enthusiasm
for retreat had seized the crowd. Foley was
called for, but did not respond. Other speakers did,
however, and the enthusiasm developed to the spirit
of a panic. Through speeches, shouts, and stamping
Tom sat quietly, biding his time.
Several of the speakers made bitter flings at the
leadership that had involved them in this disastrous
strike. Finally one man, spurred to abandon by applause,
ended his hoarse invective by moving the expulsion
of the members who had led the union into
the present predicament. So far Foley had sat with
face down, without a word, in obvious dejection.
But when this last speaker was through he rose slowly
to his feet. At sight of him an eager quiet possessed
the meeting.
"I can't say's I blame youse very much for what
youse've said," he began, in a voice that was almost
humble, looking toward the man who had just sat
down. "I helped get the union into the strike, yes,
an' I want youse boys"—his eyes moved over the
crowd—"to give me all the blame that's comin' to
me."
A pause. "But I ain't the only one. I didn't do
as much to bring on the strike as some others." His
glance rested on Tom. "The fact is, I really didn't
go in for the strike till I saw all o' youse seemed to
be in for it. Then o' course I did, for I'm always
with youse. An' I fought hard, so long's there was a
chance. Mebbe there's a few"—another glance at
Tom—"that'd like to have us keep on fightin'—an'
starve. Blame me all youse want to, boys—but
Buck Foley don't want none o' youse to starve."
He sank slowly back into his chair. "You did
your best, Buck!" a voice shouted, and a roar of
cheers went up. To those near him he seemed to
brighten somewhat at this encouragement.
"Three cheers for Keating!" cried the man who
had raised this shout in the bar-room, springing to his
feet. And again he led off with three groans, which
the crowd swelled to a volume matching the cheers
for Foley. Connelly, in deference to his office,
pounded with his gavel and called for silence—but
weakly.
Tom flushed and his jaw tightened, but he kept his
seat.
The crowd began once more to demand Foley's
views on the question before the house. He shook
his head at Connelly, as he had repeatedly done before.
But the meeting would not accept his negative.
They added the clapping of hands and the stamping
of feet to their cries. Foley came up a second time,
with most obvious reluctance.
"I feel sorter like the man that was run over by
a train an' had his tongue cut out," he began, making
what the union saw was a hard effort to smile. "I
don't feel like sayin' much.
"It seems to me that everything worth sayin' has
been said already," he went on in his previous humble,
almost apologetic, tone. "What I've got to say
I'll say in the shadow of a minute. I size up the
whole thing like this: We went into this strike thinkin'
we'd win, an' because we needed more money. An'
boys, we ought to have it! But we made a mistake
somewhere. I guess youse've found out that in
a fight it ain't always the man that's right that wins.
It's the strongest man. The same in a strike. We're
right, and we've fought our best, but the other fellows
are settin' on our chests. I guess our mistake was,
we wasn't as strong when we went into the fight as
we thought we was.
"Now the question, as I see it, is: Do we want
to keep the other fellow on our chests, we all fagged
out, with him mebbe punchin' our faces whenever he
feels like it?—keep us there till we're done up forever?
Or do we want to give in an' say we've had
enough? He'll let us up, we'll take a rest, we'll get
back our wind an' strength, an' when we're good an'
ready, why, another fight, an' better luck! I know
which is my style, an' from what youse boys've said
here to-night, I can make a pretty good guess as to
what's your style."
He paused for a moment, and when he began
again his voice was lower and there was a deep sadness
in it that he could not hide. "Boys, this is the
hardest hour o' my life. I ain't very used to losin'
fights. I think youse can count in a couple o' days
all the fights I lost for youse. [A cry, "Never a
one, Buck!"] An' it comes mighty hard for me to
begin to lose now. If I was to do what I want to
do, I'd say, 'Let's never give in.' But I know what's
best for the union, boys ... an' so I lose my first
strike."
He sank back into his seat, and his head fell
forward upon his breast. There was a moment of
sympathetic silence, then an outburst of shouts: "It
ain't your fault!" "You've done your best!"
"You take your lickin' like a man!" But these
individual shouts were straightway lost in cries of
"Foley!" "Foley!" and in a mighty cheer that
thundered through the hall. Next to a game fighter
men admire a game loser.
This was Tom's moment. He had been waiting
till Foley should place himself on record before the
entire union. He now stood up and raised his right
hand to gain Connelly's attention. "Mr. Chairman!"
he called.
"Question!" "Question!" shouted the crowd,
few even noticing that Tom was claiming right of
speech.
"Mr. Chairman!" Tom cried again.
Connelly's attention was caught, and for an instant
he looked irresolutely at Tom. The crowd,
following their president's eyes, saw Tom and broke
into a great hiss.
"D'you want any more speeches?" Connelly put
to the union.
"No!" "No!" "Question!" "Question!"
"All in favor of the motion——"
The desperate strait demanded an eminence to
speak from, but the way to the platform was blocked.
Tom vaulted to the top of the grand piano, and his
eyes blazed down upon the crowd.
"You shall listen to me!" he shouted, breaking
in on Connelly. His right arm pointed across the hall
to where Foley was bowed in humiliation. "Buck
Foley has sold you out!"
In the great din his voice did not carry more than
a dozen rows, but upon those rows silence fell suddenly.
"What was that?" men just behind asked
excitedly, their eyes on Tom standing on the piano,
his arm stretched toward Foley. A tide of explanation
moved backward, and the din sank before it.
Tom shouted again: "Buck Foley has sold you
out!"
This time his words reached the farthest man in
the hall. There was an instant of stupefied quiet.
Then Foley himself stood up. He seemed to have
paled a shade, but there was not a quaver in his voice
when he spoke.
"This's a nice little stage play our friend's made
up for the last minute. He's been fightin' a settlement
right along, an' this is his last trick to get youse
to put it off. He's sorter like a blind friend o' mine
who went fishin' one day. He got turned with his
back to the river, an' he fished all day in the grass.
I think Keating's got turned in the wrong direction,
too."
A few in the crowd laughed waveringly; some
began to talk excitedly; but most looked silently at
Tom, still stunned by his blow-like declaration.
Tom paid no attention to Foley's words. "Fifty
thousand dollars was what he got!" he said in his
loudest voice.
For the moment it was as if those fifteen hundred
men had been struck dumb and helpless. Again it
was Foley who broke the silence. He reared his
long body above the bewildered crowd and spoke
easily. "If youse boys don't see through that lie
youse're blind. If I was runnin' the strike alone an'
wanted to sell it out, what Keating's said might be
possible. But I ain't runnin' it. A committee is—five
men. Now how d'youse suppose I could sell out
with four men watchin' me—an' one o' them a
friend o' Keating?"
He did not wait for a response from his audience.
He turned to Connelly and went on with a provoked
air: "Mr. Chairman, youse know, an' the rest o'
the committee knows, that it was youse who suggested
we give up the strike. An' youse know I held out
again' givin' in. Now ain't we had enough o' Keating's
wind? S'pose youse put the question."
What Foley had said was convincing; and, even
at this instant, Tom himself could but admire the
self-control, the air of provoked forbearance, with
which he said it. The quiet, easy speech had given
the crowd time to recover. As Foley sat down there
was a sudden tumult of voices, and then loud cries of
"Question!" "Question!"
"Order, Mr. Chairman! I demand the right to
speak!" Tom cried.
"No one wants to hear you, and the question's
called for."
Tom turned to the crowd. "It's for you to say
whether you'll hear me or——"
"Out of order!" shouted Connelly.
"I've got facts, men! Facts! Will it hurt you
to hear me? You can vote as you please, then!"
"Question!" went up a roar, and immediately
after it a greater and increasing roar of "Keating!"
"Keating!"
Connelly could but yield. He pounded for order,
then nodded at Tom. "Well, go on."
Tom realized the theatricality of his position on
the piano, but he also realized its advantage, and did
not get down. He waited a moment to gain control
of his mind, and his eyes moved over the rows and
rows of faces that gleamed dully from sweat and
excitement through the haze of smoke.
What he had to say first was pure conjecture, but
he spoke with the convincing decision of the man
who has guessed at nothing. "You've heard the
other men speak. All I ask of you is to hear me out
the same way. And I have something far more important
to say than anything that's been said here
to-night. I am going to tell you the story of the
most scoundrelly trick that was ever played on a
trade union. For the union has been sold out, and
Buck Foley lies when he says it has not, and he knows
he lies!"
Every man was listening intently. Tom went on:
"About three weeks ago, just when negotiations were
opened again, Foley arranged with the bosses to sell
out the strike. Fifty thousand dollars was the price.
The bosses were to make a million or more out of
the deal, Foley was to make fifty thousand, and we
boys were to pay for it all! Foley's work was to
fool the committee, make them lose confidence in the
strike, and they of course would make the union lose
confidence and we'd give up. That was his job, and
for it he was to have fifty thousand dollars.
"Well, he was the man for the job. He worked
the committee, and worked it so slick it never knew
it was being worked. He even made the committee
think it was urging him to give up the strike. How
he did it, it's beyond me or any other honest man
even to guess. No one could have done it but Foley.
He's the smoothest crook that ever happened. I
give you that credit, Buck Foley. You're the
smoothest crook that ever happened!"
Foley had come to his feet with a look that was
more of a glaring scowl than anything else: eyebrows
drawn down shaggily, a gully between them—nose
drawn up and nostrils flaring—jaws clenched—the
whole face clenched. "Mr. President, are youse
goin' to let that man go on with his lies?" he broke
in fiercely.
The crowd roused from its tension. "Go on,
Keating! Go on!"
"If he goes on with them lies, I for one ain't goin'
to stay to listen to 'em!" Foley grabbed his coat
from the back of his chair and started to edge through
to the aisle.
"If you leave, Buck Foley, it's the same as a confession
of guilt!" shouted Tom. "Stay here and
defend yourself like a man, if you can!"
"Against youse?" He laughed a dry cackling
laugh, and his returning self-mastery smoothed out
his face. And then his inherent bravado showed
itself. On reaching the aisle, instead of turning
toward the door, he turned toward the platform and
seated himself on its edge, directing a look of
insouciant calm upon the men.
"Whatever lies there are, are all yours, Buck
Foley," Tom went on. He looked again at the
crowd, bending toward him in attention. "The
trick worked. How well is shown by our being on
the point of voting to give up the strike. Little by
little our confidence was destroyed by doubt, and
little by little Foley got nearer to his money—till
to-day came. I'm speaking facts now, boys. I've
got evidence for everything I'm going to tell you.
I know every move Foley's made in the last thirty-six
hours.
"Well, this morning,—I'll only give the big facts,
facts that count,—this morning he went to get the
price of us—fifty thousand dollars. Where do you
suppose he met Baxter? In some hotel, or some
secret place? Not much. Cunning! That word
don't do justice to Foley. He met Baxter in Baxter's
own office!—and with the door open! Could anything
be more in harmony with the smooth scheme
by which he fooled the committee? He left the door
wide open, so everyone outside could hear that
nothing crooked was going on. He swore at Baxter.
He called him every sort of name because he would
not make us any concession. After a minute or two
he came out, still swearing mad. His coat was buttoned
up—tight. It was unbuttoned when he went
in. And the people that heard thought what an
awful calling-down Baxter had got.
"Foley went first to the Independence Bank. He
left seventeen thousand there. At the Jackson Bank
he left fifteen thousand, and at the Third National
eighteen thousand. Fifty thousand dollars, boys—his
price for selling us out! And he comes here
to-night and pretends to be broken-hearted. 'This
is the hardest hour of my life,' he says; 'and so I
lose my first strike.' Broken-hearted!—with fifty
thousand put in the bank in one day!"
There was a tense immobility through all the
crowd, and a profound stillness, quickly broken by
Foley before anyone else could forestall him. There
was a chance that Tom's words had not caught hold—his
thousandth chance.
"If that fool is through ravin', better put the
motion, Connelly," he remarked the instant Tom
ended, in an even tone that reached the farthest edge
of the hall. No one looking at him at this instant,
still sitting on the edge of the platform, would have
guessed his show of calmness was calling from him
the supreme effort of his life.
Voices buzzed, then there rose a dull roar of anger.
It had been Foley's last chance, and he had lost.
He threw off his control, and leaped to his feet, his
face twisted with vengeful rage. He tossed his hat
and coat on the platform, and without a word made
a rush through the men toward Tom.
"Let him through, boys!" Tom shouted, and
sprang from the piano. Petersen stepped quickly to
his side, but Tom pushed him away and waited in
burning eagerness in the little open space. And the
crowd, still dazed by the revelations of the last scene,
looked fascinated upon this new one.
But at this moment an interruption came from the
rear of the hall. "Letter for Foley!" shouted a
voice. "Letter for Foley!"
Foley paused in his rush, and turned his livid face
toward the cry. The sergeant-at-arms was pushing
his way through the center aisle, repeating his shout,
his right hand holding an envelope aloft. He gained
Foley's side and laid the letter in the walking delegate's
hand. "Messenger just brought it! Very
important!" he cried.
Foley glared at Tom, looked at the letter, hesitated,
then ripped open the envelope with a bony
forefinger. The crowd looked on, hardly breathing,
while he read.