There has been for many years a warm and to a certain extent undecided
discussion going on, as to whether the varnishes used by Italian
violin makers were oily and slow-drying ones or spirit varnishes. To
investigate this matter still further, and to arrive at a correct
decision, will have to be left to the future.
I am, however, of the opinion that the old masters made use of spirit
or turpentine-oil until the middle of last century, but never of
linseed-oil or turpentine-oil varnish, as has been often asserted.
My opinion is supported by the following fact. In the year 1860 I had
the good fortune to buy a real Nicolas Amati lute which, although very
much knocked about, still retained a thick varnish of a most beautiful
gold colour. For my information I took the varnish off, in order to
submit it to the analysis of a clever chemist who, being a talented
amateur violinist and also a pupil of Spohr, showed great interest in
the matter and communicated to me, as the result of his investigations,
this fact that among the quantity of varnish which I had placed at
his command, there was not a trace of evidence which could lead to
the conclusion that linseed-oil varnish had been employed. In my own
researches I found that the varnish was immediately dissolved in spirit
of only 90 per cent., while in oil of turpentine and linseed-oil it was
scarcely affected, and by boiling only a small portion was removed.
Again, it is not probable that Stradivarius, in whose workshops about
3000 violins were constructed, would have employed linseed-oil varnish,
seeing that it would have required, in each case, six months for the
violin to get thoroughly dry.
There are many resins which can be dissolved in spirit or oil of
turpentine and used as a varnish, but the preference is generally
given to spirit-varnish, as it dries more quickly. If the spirit or
turpentine-oil has evaporated, only the resin remains.
The greatest attention must be paid to the relative hardness of the
resin and the wood, for both should be of equal density. Hard resin
hinders the vibration of the wood, and consequently the quality of tone
suffers.
In my opinion shellac is quite useless for varnishing, it being much
too hard, but nevertheless it has been employed from 1770 until the
present day, in spite of the fact that the best Italian instrument
might be completely ruined by being varnished with it. In all
Italian instruments the old varnish is always very porous and soft,
and can easily be dissolved by the application of spirit, while,
on the contrary, it requires great labour to effect the same with
turpentine-oil.
Many people affirm that the art of mixing the old Italian varnish which
so charms us with its brilliancy and transparency, is no longer known,
in fact that it is for ever lost. I am, however, of a different opinion
and maintain that our modern varnishes are quite equal to the old, but
what we have until now been unable to produce scientifically, is the
golden-brown underground which the wood of older violins has acquired
through age and other influences. The proof of this I have practically
demonstrated by varnishing old instruments with new varnish, in
imitation, with such success as to arouse the wonder of connoisseurs,
the varnish being quite as transparent and brilliant-coloured as that
used for violins in the last century.
To one other point I should like to call the attention of the reader.
In repairing old instruments of the time of Stradivarius, I have found
that an extraordinary cleanliness and lustre is obtained by rubbing
them with fine glass-paper, which is not the case with Tyrolean and
German violins of the same period. At a later period this peculiarity
was not met with so frequently and from the year 1750 not at all.
This fact I primarily attribute to the action of the resin on the
wood, being also of opinion that the fine dust of the same gets firmly
embedded in the pores of the wood, and in this way, in course of time,
a more or less thick coating is formed.
For one of these practical experiments I took a violin which I had
made myself and the tone of which, through years of constant use,
was therefore quite familiar to me, and gave it a coating of melted
resin on the inside. After this was thoroughly dry and hardened, I
polished the interior and remarked the before-mentioned smoothness
and brilliancy, the obtaining of which firmly convinced me that I had
discovered the truth of the matter. Although, after the glueing-on of
the belly, all the former conditions of the violin remained unchanged,
yet I was astonished to find what a common-place squeaking tone the
instrument had acquired, thus proving to me that with the melted resin
I had obtained in the end exactly the opposite effect to that which
I had hoped for. I was obliged to rest contented with my failure for
a long time, when a lucky chance came to my help. It was this. I
received a real Caspar da Salo violoncello to repair, which had never
been opened and seemed to have been very little played upon, for on it
I found an old bridge which I kept as an ornament and curiosity, and
which, on closer examination, I found was varnished.
When I opened the cello, it was proved without a doubt that the
interior had also received a coating, probably to protect it from dust,
etc. The celebrated old violin makers, in so doing, have pursued the
right course. This discovery also corroborated my own supposition,
that the old masters varnished both the interior and bridge of the
instruments they made.
Now, in order to obtain a ground-priming, I paint the violin, when
the wood of which it is constructed is in its natural state, three
times with pyroligneous acid, with which a golden-brown underground
is obtained, then follows a single coating of spirit and balsam of
Peru in equal proportions, and after this one or two coats of a weak
solution of gamboge or anotta, and finally, over all this I lay on 20
or 30 coats of varnish, according to the thickness required, and which
I prepare as follows:—
Dissolve three parts of sandarac and one of mastic in spirit, and in
order that it may be laid on more easily, add to each half a litre[1]
of varnish, ten drops of oil of turpentine. The colouring of the
varnish I obtain from turmeric and bright red sandal-wood by means
of spirit, using more or less of it, according as to the lighter or
darker tone required; if a brown varnish is required, some soot from
turpentine-oil must be added to the spirit.
I have made innumerable experiments with other resins and colouring
matters, but in the end I always return to those mentioned above as the
best to be used. Dragon’s-blood must not be employed, the colour not
being fast.
When the varnish is dry, it must be very carefully polished with finely
powdered pumice-stone and linseed-oil, applied with a piece of felt.