Shakespeare speaks in one of his plays of
the disastrous position of the man who is blown
up with the bomb he has himself touched off. Jacqueline
was not nearly so well acquainted with
Shakespeare as Caroline was. But one half-second
after she made her startling announcement, she
needed no poet to tell her how that poor man felt.
Aunt Martha stared for that one half-second,
and then a look of actual triumph came flooding into
her tear-stained face.
“There, Judge!” she cried, with her arms tight
about Jacqueline. “Doesn’t that prove what I kept
telling you? It’s the awful heat—and she’s worked
so hard and faithful, poor young one—and that long
walk yesterday in the sun—it’s gone to her head.
You can see for yourself she doesn’t know what she
does—or what she says.”
Jacqueline stood speechless, (“flabbergasted,”
Grandma would have called it!) while she looked
from Aunt Martha’s excited, anxious, yet beaming
face, to the Judge who sat coldly, shrewdly watching.
Crowding into her brain came memories she
had laid aside, passages and chapters in the latter
portion of that fateful volume, “The Prince and
the Pauper.”
“Oh, pluffy catamounts!” she almost shrieked in
terror. “Don’t you go acting like those silly boobs
in that beastly old book—don’t you go thinking
I’m off my head, because I’m not—I’m not! I’m
Jacqueline—and I never was anybody else! I’m Jacqueline
Gildersleeve!”
She began to cry, tears of temper and terror combined.
For this was drama, more than enough to
satisfy her. If they didn’t believe her—why, then
they must think her either crazy or an awful liar and
a thief! What did they do with crazy people—and
with thieves? The Judge had a court and a
jail—Neil had said so. And she had laughed, only
a little while ago, at the mere idea of her being
sent to jail, as Neil had said, to tease her. It was
no laughing matter now.
“Oh, dear! Oh, dear!” choked Jacqueline. “I
want my Aunt Edie—she’ll know I’m me. And my
Uncle Jimmie! Oh, oh!”
Aunt Martha was herself again. Nothing apparently
could down her, except the dreadful fear that
one of her children could be a thief and a liar. She
drew Jacqueline down on her lap, and held her
safe against her breast, and Jacqueline, for all she
was eleven next month and so big she nearly overwhelmed
Aunt Martha, clung tight to her and wept
into the hollow of her sunburnt neck.
“There, there, you poor child!” soothed Aunt
Martha. “Cry all you want to—cry it out!”
“I don’t want to!” sniffled Jacqueline, and lifted
her smeary face. “Lend me your hanky, Aunt Martha.
Nellie’s got mine.”
She dried her eyes and felt a little better, but she
didn’t offer to leave Aunt Martha’s lap, and she was
thankful that Aunt Martha still kept hold of her,
for the Judge was right there in the big rocker, and
his steely eyes, under his drawn brows never wavered
from her face.
“Well! Well!” said the Judge. “So you’re Jacqueline,
are you, and not Caroline Tait at all?”
“Now, Judge!” Aunt Martha begged. “Don’t
get her all upset again.”
“But I’m not sick,” insisted Jacqueline, “and I
won’t get upset unless you go calling me crazy like
they did in the book.”
“What book?” the Judge questioned.
“The silly old ‘Prince and the Pauper,’” Jacqueline
explained. “Judge Blair gave it to me to
read on the train, but I never want to see it again as
long as I live, because it was the book that did it.”
The Judge leaned back in his chair, and fitted his
finger tips together. Over them he watched Jacqueline.
“Go ahead,” he bade, “and tell us all about it.”
“Well, Caroline got on the train at Chicago,”
Jacqueline told her story in the intense silence,
“and she was scared to death about going to the
farm, because of the boys and the cows, and no
piano—and I didn’t want to go to Great-aunt Eunice’s
poky old house—and the two boys in the
book changed round—and Caroline and I were both
going on eleven, and had brown hair, and nobody
in Longmeadow had ever seen either of us—and I
thought it would be fun——”
Her voice began to falter, as she sensed the gravity
of both her listeners. What she and Caroline
had done, she realized now, was dangerous and
dreadful. She dropped her eyes, thoroughly
ashamed, but though she could not keep the quaver
out of her voice, she spoke the words that it was
only fair to speak.
“It was mostly me,” she confessed. “Caroline
wouldn’t have done it, not even for the piano, but
I said she was a quitter, and we changed clothes
and things, only she kept Mildred, and when she got
off the train at Baring Junction, the Gildersleeves
just grabbed her—and I went in the Lizzie with
Aunt Martha.”
“Well, I—never!” gasped Aunt Martha. She
was amazed, she was a little angry, perhaps. But
she wasn’t crying the way she cried when Jacqueline
said she had taken the beads. “Did you mean to
keep it up all summer, Jackie?”
“No, Aunt Martha,” Jacqueline admitted. “The
day I broke the cups, you know, when I went up to
the village I was going to change back, but Caroline
was having a party next day—they thought
she was Jacqueline, you know—and she cried. She’d
never had a party nor nothing. So I told her we’d
let things go till Aunt Edie came in September, and
I wouldn’t have given the show away now, only I
couldn’t stand it, Aunt Martha, to have you think—what
you thought about me.”
Deplorably Aunt Martha hugged Jacqueline at
this point, instead of shaking her, as really Jacqueline
deserved to be shaken.
“There now, Judge!” Aunt Martha cried exultantly.
“It’s all true, that part about her running
off to the village, the day the cups were broken.”
The Judge shook his grizzled head, above his
finger tips.
“That may be true, Martha, but you’ll admit the
rest of the story sounds pretty queer.”
“I don’t care how queer and far-fetched it
sounds,” insisted Aunt Martha. “I’d believe any
story before I’d believe this child isn’t honest. Why,
Judge, whoever she is, she’s been round here with
me, going on nine weeks now. I tell you, she
couldn’t steal nor lie. ’Tisn’t in her.”
The Judge looked down a moment at his finger
tips.
“Remember what day it was she got here, Martha?”
he asked unexpectedly.
“Yes, Judge. The twenty-third of June. Her
mother’s cousin wrote me the day and train I was
to expect her, and ’twas the same day I had a bill
to pay in Baring.”
“Hm!” said the Judge. “Yes, that was the day
that Mrs. Gildersleeve’s little grandniece arrived
from California. I remember because Mrs. Gildersleeve
declined an invitation to dine with us that
night—on my birthday. She’d counted a lot on seeing
that child. The two girls came on the same train
from Chicago, that much is sure. And you’d never
seen this little niece of yours?”
“Judge, I wouldn’t have known her from a hole
in the ground.”
“Did you ever notice anything in her behavior different
from what you would naturally have expected
in your brother’s child? I know you want
to believe her story, Martha, but I trust you to be
careful and exact.”
“Yes, there were some queer things, now I come
to think of it,” Aunt Martha spoke eagerly, with her
arms still round Jacqueline. “Why, Judge, this
child didn’t know the look of her own trunk, nor
where to find her trunk-key. I thought ’twas just
because she was upset with the journey, but I see
now how it came about. She had a pocketful of
real expensive candy—she said it was given her by a
little girl on the train.”
“I said a little girl on the train had a boxful,”
murmured Jacqueline. “And the little girl was me!”
“And she hadn’t one single idea about the value
of money,” Aunt Martha went on joyfully. “I
thought ’twas just because they’d brought her up
foolishly, but of course the Gildersleeves don’t have
to count their pennies. Then she didn’t know how
to do one blessed thing about the house, but she
took hold nicely, and she’s been a real help to me
all summer. Why, Judge,” Aunt Martha cried in
sudden dismay, “if she’s Jacqueline Gildersleeve,
she’ll be leaving us, and I don’t know how I’ll ever
get along without her.”
Jacqueline hadn’t thought of that, when she
planned her merry trick, there on the train. She
was going to hurt Aunt Martha—Aunt Martha,
who believed in her and stood up for her to the
Judge. She began to sniffle, not for temper this
time, and buried her face in Aunt Martha’s coarse,
clean handkerchief.
“I didn’t think—’twould be like this,” she sobbed.
“Well, well!” crooned the Judge. “It doesn’t
sound very probable, but I must admit it’s not impossible—no,
not altogether impossible.”
Jacqueline lifted her face from the pocket handkerchief.
“Caroline will tell you it’s so, when she gets back
from the beach,” she hiccoughed, “and Aunt Edie
and Uncle Jimmie, when they come in September.”
“Yes, of course,” cried Aunt Martha eagerly.
“Hm!” boomed the Judge like a bee, but not a
benevolent one. “But what shall we do until they
come? This little girl is in a pretty awkward fix,
because of these beads, if she can’t prove to us that
she’s Jacqueline Gildersleeve.”
“Send for the other child,” bristled Aunt
Martha, “the real Caroline. Guess I’ve got some say in
the matter, if she’s my honest-to-goodness niece.”
The Judge shook his head.
“This one is your niece,” he said, with finality,
“until there’s proof to the contrary, and I won’t
send for the other child and have Eunice Gildersleeve
upset for what may be a cock-and-bull story.
Let’s see!” he mused. “Uncle Jimmie and Aunt
Edie are our next hope. Where can we reach these
relatives of yours?” He turned to Jacqueline.
“I don’t know where they are now,” Jacqueline
confessed mournfully. “All their letters have gone
to Caroline, of course, and they’re moving about all
the time, and changing their address.”
“Well,” said the Judge, “you must think up somebody
else who can identify you, and some way of
making the identification by telegraph. A mere description
isn’t enough. There must be some distinguishing
feature. You haven’t a strawberry
mark on your left arm, have you?”
Jacqueline laughed hysterically, and at sight of
what her parted lips disclosed, Aunt Martha gave
a cry of triumph.
“Those braces, Judge,” she cried. “The braces
on her teeth! There just couldn’t be two children
with the identical same dental work. In fact, I
don’t believe my real niece has any such.”
The Judge looked at Aunt Martha with genuine
approval.
“You always did have a good head on your
shoulders, Martha,” he said. “Dental work, eh? Come
to think of it, I know myself that the little girl at
The Chimnies has had no dentistry done in several
years. I rode into Boston one day with Penelope,
when she was taking the child to the dentist, and
she commented quite sharply on the way in which
her teeth had been neglected. So now if this little
girl will give us the address of her dentist——”
“It’s Dr. Graydon on the tenth floor of the Wouverman
Building in Los Angeles,” Jacqueline answered
readily. “Most all the girls I know go to
him.”
The Judge wrote down the address methodically,
in a little black note-book.
“I’ll wire him at once,” he said, more to Aunt
Martha than to Jacqueline. “I shall have to retain
these beads, as a matter of form, until the child’s
story is proved or disproved. Meantime it will help
to settle this affair if she returns the five dollars she
got from the little Trowbridge girl.”
Oh, dear! Here were more storm clouds gathering,
just as the sky seemed about to clear!
“I can’t return the money,” Jacqueline faltered.
“I—I spent it.”
The Judge looked grave again, but his voice was
patient, and Aunt Martha was encouraging, so Jacqueline
managed to give a full account of the act
that she now was so ashamed of—the taking of Caroline’s
precious old beads, and the pledging them
with Miss Crevey.
When Jacqueline had finished Aunt Martha
started eagerly to confirm her story about bringing
home a green-dragon cup, several weeks before,
but the Judge cut her short.
“Get the lacquer box and show us the beads,” he
bade.
Jacqueline slipped from Aunt Martha’s lap to
obey, and as she left the room heard the Judge asking
where the telephone was.
When Jacqueline came down with the box that
held the beads, she found the Judge at the wall phone
in the kitchen, and Aunt Martha by the table trying
hard not to listen, but with her ears pricked up.
“Miss Crevey,” her lips shaped the words for
Jacqueline’s comfort. She seemed to guess that
Jacqueline might uneasily be thinking of the town
constable.
The Judge turned from the telephone at last, with
a flicker of a smile.
“Well,” he nodded to Aunt Martha, “Lucretia
Crevey was a most unwilling witness, but she did
at last confirm as much of the child’s story as pertains
to her. And so these are the beads that made
the trouble, eh?” He looked at the yellow coil
that Jacqueline showed him in the lacquer box which
she uncovered. “It might have been very serious
trouble for you, little what’s-your-name,” he went
on gravely. “You realize that, don’t you?”
Jacqueline nodded, and drew a little nearer to
Aunt Martha, who put her arm quickly round her.
“Other articles, besides the string of beads you
call your own, are missing from The Chimnies,” the
Judge went on, “and you, having taken the beads
and disposed of them to the child next door, were
naturally suspected of taking them all.”
Jacqueline pressed closer to Aunt Martha’s side.
She hadn’t breath enough now even to say “Oh!”
“It was by the merest chance,” the Judge rubbed
it in, “that it wasn’t the town constable who came
here after you, instead of me, but luckily some
ladies, who know Mrs. Conway here and wanted to
spare her as much trouble as possible, heard about
the beads, and put the case up to me. That’s why
I came to call this morning.”
“I can’t ever thank you enough, Judge,” Aunt
Martha said, with a wavering sort of smile.
They followed the Judge out into the sunshine of
the side-yard, where the children still were grouped
under the shade of the trees where Jacqueline had
left them such ages ago, as it seemed to her, when
she thought of all that had happened since that
moment.
“You understand, Martha,” the Judge said, as
he settled himself in his roadster, “the little girl
is still technically under suspicion. I’ll suspend
judgment about this hocus-pocus, switched identity
business, till I hear from that Los Angeles dentist.
Meantime she’s remanded to your custody, and I’ll
trust you to produce her at my office, if she should
be needed.”
My, but that sounded as formal and dreadful as
the clatter of prison bolts! Jacqueline shivered, in
spite of the heat, and she was glad when she saw the
Judge’s car disappear in the white, powdery dust
of the highway.
Then Jacqueline turned to Aunt Martha.
“Oh,” she said and once more with weariness and
excitement and remorse, she was half-crying. “I
sure have got in awful wrong. I never thought, when
I started things, there on the train! And now I’ve
made you heaps and heaps of trouble, Aunt Martha—and
you believed me—and stood up for me
like all kinds of a brick—and you’re not my Aunt
Martha, either, and oh! I’m sorry that you
aren’t.”
Aunt Martha put her arm round Jacqueline’s
shoulders.
“You’re a naughty child, Jackie,” she said tremulously,
“to go and play such tricks on all of us—a
very naughty child. Your folks will probably
punish you.” She hugged Jacqueline close. “But I
don’t have to, because you’re not my niece—but oh,
dear me! don’t I just wish you were!”