The sound, spelling, and even the meaning of a word are
often perverted by influences to which the collective name
of folk-etymology has been given. I here use the term
to include all phenomena which are due to any kind of
misunderstanding of a word. A word beginning with
n sometimes loses this sound through its being confused
with the n of the indefinite article an. Thus an adder
and an auger are for a nadder (cf. Ger. Natter) and a
nauger, Mid. Eng. navegor, properly an instrument for
piercing the nave of a wheel. Apron was in Mid. English
naprun, from Old Fr. naperon, a derivative of nappe, cloth.
The aitch-bone was formerly the nache-bone, from Old Fr.
nache, buttock, Vulgar Lat. *natica for nates. Nache is
still used by French butchers. Humble-pie is a popular
perversion of umble-pie, i.e., a pie made from the umbles,
or inferior parts of the stag. But umble is for earlier
numble, Old Fr. nomble, formed, with dissimilation, from
Lat. lumbulus, diminutive of lumbus, loin; cf. niveau
(p. 58). Thus humble-pie has etymologically no connection
with humility. Umpire represents Old Fr. non per
(pair), not equal, the umpire being a third person called
in when arbitrators could not agree. This appears
clearly in the following extract from a medieval letter—
"And if so be that the said arbitrators may not accord
before the said feast of Allhalowes, then the said parties be
the advise abovesaid are agreed to abide the award and ordinance
of an noumper to be chosen be the said arbitrators."
(Plumpton Correspondence, 1431.)
For the sense we may compare Span. tercero, "the
third, a broaker, a mediator" (Percyvall). An eyas
falcon is for a neyas falcon, Fr. niais, foolish, lit. nestling,
related to nid, nest. Rosenkrantz uses it in the literal
sense—
"But there is, sir, an aiery of children, little eyases, that cry
out on the top of question, and are most tyranically clapped for't."
(Hamlet, ii. 2.)
Somewhat similar is the loss in French of initial a in
la boutique for l'aboutique, Greco-Lat. apotheca, and la
Pouille for l'Apouille, Apulia, or of the initial l in ounce,
a kind of tiger-cat, from Fr. once, earlier lonce, "the
ounce, a ravenous beast" (Cotgrave), taken as l'once.
It is almost a doublet of lynx.
The opposite has happened in the case of a newt
for an ewt and a nick-name for an eke-name. Eke, also,
occurs in the first stanza of John Gilpin. It is cognate
with Ger. auch, also, and Lat. augere, to increase. Nuncle,
the customary address of a court fool to his superiors—
"How now, nuncle! Would I had two coxcombs and two
daughters."
(Lear, i. 4.)
is for mine uncle. We also find naunt. Nonce occurs
properly only in the phrase for the nonce, which is for
earlier for then ones, where then is the dative of the
definite article. Family names like Nash, Nokes are
aphetic for atten ash, at the ash, atten oakes, at the oaks.
The creation of such forms was perhaps helped by our
tendency to use initial n in Christian names, e.g., Ned
for Edward, Noll for Oliver, Nell for Ellen.
AGGLUTINATION OF THE ARTICLE
Agglutination of the definite article is common in
French, e.g., lingot, ingot, lierre, ivy, for l'ierre, Lat.
hedera, and the dialect lévier, sink, for évier, Lat.
aquarium, whence Eng. ewer. The derivation of Fr.
landier, andiron, is unknown, but the iron of the
English word is due to folk-etymology. Such agglutination
occurs often in family names such as Langlois, lit.
the Englishman, Lhuissier, the usher (see p. 90), and
some of these have passed into English, e.g., Levick for
l'évêque, the bishop.
The two words alarm and alert include the Italian
definite article. The first is Ital. all'arme, to arms, for
a le arme, and the second is all'erta for alla (a la) erta,
the last word representing Lat. erecta. With rolled r,
alarm becomes alarum, whence the aphetic larum—
"Then we shall hear their larum, and they ours."
(Coriolanus, i. 4.)
Ger. Lärm, noise, is the same word. In Luther's time
we also find Allerm.
We have the Arabic definite article in a great
many words borrowed from Spanish. Alcalde, or
alcade, and alguazil, common in Elizabethan literature,
are two old friends from the Arabian Nights, the cadi
and the wazir, or vizier. The Arabic article also occurs
in acton, Old Fr. auqueton, now hoqueton, for al qutn
(cotton), because originally used of a wadded coat—
"But Cranstoun's lance, of more avail,
Pierced through, like silk, the Borderer's mail;
Through shield, and jack, and acton past,
Deep in his bosom broke at last."
(Scott, Lay, iii. 6.)
In alligator, Span. el lagarto, the lizard, from Lat.
lacertus, we have the Spanish definite article. See also
lariat, p. 24.
A foreign word ending in a sibilant is sometimes mistaken
for a plural. Thus Old Fr. assets (assez), enough,
Lat. ad satis, has given Eng. assets, plural, with a
barbarous, but useful, singular asset. Cherry is for cheris,
from a dialect form of Fr. cerise, and sherry for
sherris, from Xeres in Spain (see p. 51). Falstaff opines
that—
"A good sherris-sack[89] hath a twofold operation in it."
(2 Henry IV., iv. 3.)
Pea is a false singular from older pease, Lat. pisum.
Perhaps the frequent occurrence of pease-soup, not to
be distinguished from pea-soup, is partly responsible
for this mistake. Marquee, a large tent, is from Fr.
marquise. With this we may class the heathen Chinee
and the Portugee. Milton wrote correctly of—
"The barren plains
Of Sericana, where Chineses drive
With sails and wind their cany waggons light."
(Paradise Lost, iii. 438.)
It has been ingeniously suggested that Yankee has
been derived in the same way from Du. Jan Kees, John
Cornelius, supposed to have been a nickname for early
Dutch colonists. It is more probably the Dutch dim.
Janke, i.e. Johnny. The vulgarism shay for chaise[90] is of
similar formation. Corp, for corpse, is also used provincially.
Kickshaws is really a singular from Fr. quelque
chose—
"Art thou good at these kickshawses, knight?"
(Twelfth Night, i. 3.)
Cotgrave spells it quelkchoses (s.v. fricandeau).
FALSE SINGULARS AND DOUBLE PLURALS
Skate has a curious history. It is a false singular
from Du. schaats. This is from escache, an Old French
dialect form of échasse, stilt, which was used in the
Middle Ages for a wooden leg. It is of German origin,
and is related to shank. Cf., for the sense development,
Eng. patten, from Fr. patin, a derivative of patte,
foot, cognate with paw. Skates are still called pattens
by the fenmen of Cambridgeshire. We also had
formerly a doublet from Old Fr. escache directly, but
in the older sense, for Cotgrave has eschasses (échasses),
"stilts, or scatches to go on." Row, a disturbance,
belongs to rouse, a jollification—
"The king doth wake to-night and takes his rouse."
(Hamlet, i. 4.)
of uncertain origin, but probably aphetic for carouse,
drink carouse being wrongly separated as drink a rouse.
The bird called a wheatear was formerly called
wheatears, a corruption of a name best explained
by its French equivalent cul blanc, "the bird called
a whittaile" (Cotgrave). We may compare the bird-name
redstart, where start means rump.
Conversely a word used in the plural is sometimes
regarded as a singular, the result being a double
plural. Many Latin neuter plurals were adopted into
French as feminine singulars, e.g., cornua, corne, horn;
labra, lèvre, lip; vela, voile, sail. It is obvious that this
is most likely to occur in the case of plurals which are
used for a pair, or set, of things, and thus have a kind
of collective sense. Breeches or breeks is a double plural,
Anglo-Sax. brēc being already the plural of brōc. In
Mid. English we still find breche or breke used of this
garment. Trousers was earlier trouses, plural of trouse,
now trews, and was used especially of Irish native
costume. The latest researches throw doubt on the
identity of these words with Fr. trousse, a page's short
breeches. The etymology which now finds most favour
is Irish and Gaelic triubhas, from Late Lat. tubracci or
tribracci, which is supposed to be a corrupted compound
from tibia, leg, shank, and braccæ, breeches. Bodice is
for bodies, as pence is for pennies. Cotgrave explains
corset by "a paire of bodies for a woman," and the plural
sense occurs as late as Harrison Ainsworth—
"A pair of bodice of the cumbrous form in vogue at the
beginning of the last century."
(Jack Sheppard, Ch. 1.)
Trace, of a horse, is the Old Fr. plural trais[91] (traits)
of trait, "a teame-trace" (Cotgrave). Apprentice is
the plural of Fr. apprenti, formerly apprentif, a derivative
of apprendre, to learn, hence a disciple. Invoice
is the plural of the obsolete invoy, from Fr. envoi, sending.
In the Grecian steps, at Lincoln, we have a popular
corruption of the common Mid. Eng. and Tudor grece,
grese, plural of Old Fr. gré, step, from Lat. gradus.
Shakespeare spells it grize—
"Let me speak like yourself; and lay a sentence,
Which, as a grize, or step, may help these lovers
Into your favour."
(Othello, i. 3.)
SINGULARS FROM PLURALS
Scot. brose, or brewis, was in Mid. Eng. browes, from
Old Fr. brouez, plural of brouet, a word cognate with
our broth. From this association comes perhaps the
use of broth as a plural in some of our dialects. Porridge,
not originally limited to oatmeal, seems to be combined
from pottage and Mid. Eng. porrets, plural of porret, leek,
a diminutive from Lat. porrum. Porridge is sometimes
used as a plural in Scottish—
"They're fine, halesome food, they're grand food, parritch."
(Kidnapped, Ch. 3.)
and in the northern counties of England people speak of
taking "a few" porridge, or broth. Baize, now generally
green, is for earlier bayes, the plural of the adjective bay,
now used only of horses; cf. Du. baai, baize. The origin of
the adjective bay, Fr. bai, forms of which occur in all the
Romance languages, is Lat. badius, "of bay colour,
bayarde" (Cooper). Hence the name Bayard, applied
to FitzJames' horse in The Lady of the Lake (v. 18), and
earlier to the steed that carried the four sons of Aymon.
Quince is the plural of quin, from the Norman form of
Old Fr. coin (coing), which is derived from Gk. κυδώνιον.
Truce is the plural of Mid. Eng. trewe (lit. truth, faith)
with the same meaning. Already in Anglo-Saxon it
is found in the plural, probably as rendering Lat.
induciæ. Lettuce, Mid. Eng. letows, seems also to be
a plural, from Fr. laitue, Lat. lactuca.
Earnest in the sense of pledge—
"And, for an earnest of a greater honour,
He bade me, from him, call thee Thane of Cawdor."
(Macbeth, i. 3.)
has nothing to do with the adjective earnest. It is the
Mid. Eng. ernes, earlier erles, which survives as arles
in some of our dialects. The verb to earl is still
used in Cumberland of "enlisting" a servant with a
shilling in the open market. The Old French word
was arres or erres, now written learnedly arrhes, a
plural from Lat. arrha, "an earnest penny, earnest
money" (Cooper). The existence of Mid. Eng. erles
shows that there must have been also an Old French
diminutive form. For the apparently arbitrary change
of l to n we may compare banister for baluster
(see p. 60).
The jesses of a hawk—
"If I do prove her haggard,[92]
Though that her jesses were my dear heart-strings,
I'd whistle her off, and let her down the wind,
To prey at fortune."
(Othello, iii. 3.)
were the thongs by which it was held or "thrown" into
the air. Jess is the Old Fr. jes, the plural of jet, from
jeter, to throw. In Colman's Elder Brother we read of
a gentleman who lounged and chatted, "not minding
time a souse," where souse is the plural of Fr. sou, halfpenny.
From Fr. muer, to moult, Lat. mutare, we get
Fr. mue, moulting, later applied to the coop or pen in
which moulting falcons were confined, whence the phrase
"to mew (up)"—
"More pity, that the eagles should be mew'd,
While kites and buzzards prey at liberty."
(Richard III., i. 1.)
When, in 1534, the royal mews, or hawk-houses, near
Charing Cross were rebuilt as stables, the word acquired
its present meaning.
Chess, Old Fr. esches (échecs), is the plural of check,
Fr. échec, from Persian shāh, king. By analogy with
the "game of kings," the name jeu des dames was given
in French to draughts, still called dams in Scotland.
Draught, from draw, meant in Mid. English a "move"
at chess. The etymology of tweezers can best be
made clear by starting from French étui, a case, of
doubtful origin. This became in English etwee, or
twee, e.g., Cotgrave explains estui (étui) as "a sheath,
case, or box to put things in; and (more particularly)
a case of little instruments, as sizzars, bodkin, penknife,
etc., now commonly termed an ettwee." Such a case
generally opens book-fashion, each half being fitted
with instruments. Accordingly we find it called a
surgeon's "pair of twees," or simply tweese, and later a
"pair of tweeses." The implement was named from
the case (cf. Fr. boussole, p. 127), and became tweezers
by association with pincers (Fr. pinces), scissors, etc.
ANALOGY
The form of a word is often affected by association
with some other word with which it is instinctively
coupled. Thus larboard, for Mid. Eng. ladeboard, i.e.
loading side, is due to starboard, steering side. Bridal,
for bride-ale, from the liquid consumed at marriage
festivities, is due to analogy with betrothal, espousal,
etc. A 16th-century Puritan records with satisfaction
the disappearance of—
"Church-ales, helpe-ales, and soule-ales, called also dirge-ales,
and heathenish rioting at bride-ales."
(Harrison, Description of England, 1577.)
Rampart is from Old Fr. rempar, a verbal noun
from remparer, to repair; cf. Ital. riparo, "a rampire,
a fort, a banke" (Florio). By analogy with Old Fr.
boulevart (boulevard), of German origin and identical
with our bulwark,[93] rempar became rempart. The older
English form occurs in the obsolete rampier or rampire,
which survive in the dialect ramper, embankment,
causeway. For the spelling rampire we may compare
umpire (p. 113). The apple called a jenneting, sometimes
"explained" as for June-eating, was once spelt geniton,
no doubt for Fr. jeanneton, a diminutive of Jean. It
is called in French pomme de Saint-Jean, and in German
Johannisapfel, because ripe about St John's Day (June 24).
The modern form is due to such apple names as golding,
sweeting, codlin, pippin.
In the records of medieval London we frequently
come across the distinction made between people who
lived "in the city," Anglo-Fr. deinz (dans) la cité, and
"outside the city," Anglo-Fr. fors (hors) la cité. The
former were called deinzein, whence our denizen, and
the latter forein.[94] The Anglo-French form of modern
Fr. citoyen was citein, which became citizen by analogy
with denizen. The following passage from a medieval
London by-law shows how rigid was the division
between "denizen" and "foreign" traders—
"Item, qe nulle pulletere deinzeyn n'estoise a Carfeux del
Ledenhalle deins mesoun ne dehors, ove conilles, volatilie, n'autre
pulletrie pur vendre ... issint qe les forreins pulleters, ove lour
pulletrie, estoisent par eux mesmes, et vendent lour pulletrie sur
le cornere de Ledenhalle, sanz ceo qe ascuns pulletere deinzein
viegne ou medle en vent ou en achate ove eux, ne entre eux."[95]
(Liber Albus.)
Even words which have opposite meanings may
affect each other by association. Thus Lat. reddere, to
give back, became Vulgar Lat. *rendere by analogy
with prendere (prehendere), to take away; hence Fr.
rendre. Our word grief, from Fr. grief, is derived
from a Vulgar Lat. *grĕvis, heavy (for grăvis), which
is due to lĕvis, light.
TITMOUSE—PURLIEU
The plural of titmouse is now usually titmice, by
analogy with mouse, mice, with which it has no connection.
The second part of the word is Anglo-Sax. māse,
used of several small birds. It is cognate with Ger.
Meise, titmouse, and Fr. mésange, "a titmouse, or
tittling" (Cotgrave). Tit, of Norse origin, is applied to
various small animals, and occurs also as a prefix in
titbit or tidbit. Cf. tomtit (p. 37).
The Spanish word salva, "a taste, a salutation"
(Percyvall), was used of the pregustation of a great
man's food or drink. We have given the name to the
tray or dish from which the "assay" was made, but, by
analogy with platter, trencher, we spell it salver. In
another sense, that of a "salutation" in the form of a
volley of shot, we have corrupted it into salvo. With
the use of Span. salva we may compare that of Ital.
credenza, lit. faith, "the taste or assaie of a princes
meate and drinke" (Florio), whence Fr. crédence, side-board,
used in English only in the ecclesiastical compound
credence table, and Ger. credenzen, to pour out.
In spoken English the ending -ew, -ue, of French
origin, has been often changed to -ee, -ey. Thus pedigree
was formerly pedigrew (see p. 77). The fencing term
veney—
"I bruised my shin the other day with playing at sword and
dagger with a master of fence—three veneys for a dish of stewed
prunes."
(Merry Wives, i. 1.)
also spelt venew, is from Fr. venue, "a venny in fencing"
(Cotgrave). Carew has become Carey, and Beaulieu, in
Hampshire, is called Bewley. Under the influence of
these double forms we sometimes get the opposite
change, e.g., purlieu, now generally used of the outskirts
of a town, is for purley, a strip of disforested woodland.
This is a contraction of Anglo-Fr. pour-allée, used to
translate the legal Lat. perambulatio, a going through.
A change of venue[96] is sometimes made when it seems
likely that an accused person, or a football team, will
not get justice from a local jury. This venue is in law
Latin vicinetum, neighbourhood, which gave Anglo-Fr.
visné, and this, perhaps by confusion with the venire
facias, or jury summons, became venew, venue.
In the preceding examples the form has been chiefly
affected. In the word luncheon both form and meaning
have been influenced by the obsolete nuncheon, a meal at
noon, Mid. Eng. none-chenche, for *none-schenche, noon
draught, from Anglo-Sax. scencan,[97] to pour. Drinking
seems to have been regarded as more important than
eating, for in some counties we find this nuncheon
replaced by bever, the Anglo-French infinitive from Lat.
bibere, to drink. Lunch, a piece or hunk, especially of
bread, also used in the sense of a "snack" (cf. Scot.
"piece"), was extended to luncheon by analogy with
nuncheon, which it has now replaced—
"So munch on, crunch on, take your nuncheon,
Breakfast, supper, dinner, luncheon."
(Browning, Pied Piper of Hamelin.)
WRONG ASSOCIATION
The term folk-etymology is often applied in a
narrower sense to the corruption of words through a
mistaken idea of their etymology or origin. The
tendency of the uneducated is to distort an unfamiliar
or unintelligible word into some form which suggests
a meaning. Some cases may have originated in a kind
of heavy jocularity, as in sparrow-grass for asparagus
or sparagus (see p. 66), or Rogue Riderhood's Alfred
David for affidavit—
"'Is that your name?' asked Lightwood. 'My name?'
returned the man. 'No; I want to take a Alfred David.'"
(Our Mutual Friend, Ch. 12.)
In others there has been a wrong association of ideas,
e.g., the primrose, rosemary, and tuberose have none of
them originally any connection with the rose. Primrose
was earlier primerole, an Old French derivative of Latin
primula; rosemary, French romarin, is from Lat. ros
marinus, sea-dew; tuberose is the Latin adjective
tuberosus, bulbous, tuberous. Or attempts are made at
translation, such as Sam Weller's Have his carcase for
Habeas Corpus, or the curious names which country folk
give to such complaints as bronchitis, erysipelas, etc.
To this class belongs Private Mulvaney's perversion of
locomotor ataxy—
"'They call ut Locomotus attacks us,' he sez, 'bekaze,' sez he,
'it attacks us like a locomotive.'"
(Love o' Women.)
Our language is, owing to our borrowing habits,
particularly rich in these gems. Examples familiar to
everybody are crayfish from Fr. écrevisse, gilly-flower
from Fr. giroflée, shame-faced for shamefast. Other
words in which the second element has been altered
are causeway, earlier causey, from the Picard form of
Fr. chaussée, Lat. (via) calciata, i.e., made with lime,
calx; penthouse, for pentice, Fr. appentis, "the penthouse
of a house" (Cotgrave), a derivative of Old Fr. appendre,
to hang to. Fr. hangar, a shed, now introduced into
English by aviators as unnecessarily as garage by motorists,
may also contain the same idea of "hanging."
In hiccough, for earlier hickup, an onomatopœic
word, the spelling, suggested by cough, has not
affected the pronunciation. Surcease is Fr. sursis,
past participle of surseoir, "to surcease, pawse, intermit,
leave off, give over, delay or stay for a time" (Cotgrave),
Lat. supersedere. Taffrail has been confused with
rail, its older form being tafferel, from Du. tafereel,
diminutive of tafel, picture, from Lat. tabula. It meant
originally the flat part of the stern of a ship ornamented
with carvings or pictures. This is called tableau in
nautical French. Fr. coutelas, an augmentative of
Old Fr. coutel (couteau), knife, gave Eng. cutlass, which
has no more etymological connection with "cutting"
than a cutler, Fr. coutelier, or a cutlet, Fr. côtelette, little
rib, Lat. costa. Cutlas was popularly corrupted into
curtal-axe, the form used by Rosalind—
"A gallant curtal-axe upon my thigh,
A boar-spear in my hand."
(As You Like It, i. 3.)
We have a similar corruption in pick-axe, Mid. Eng.
pikeys, Old Fr. piquois, picquois, "a pickax" (Cotgrave),
from the verb piquer. The word posthumous has
changed its meaning through folk-etymology. It
represents the Latin superlative postumus, latest born.
By association with humus, ground, earth, it came to be
used of a child born, or a work published, after its
author's death, a meaning which the derivatives of
postumus have in all the Romance languages.
The first part of the word has been distorted in
pursy, short-winded—
"And pursy insolence shall break his wind
With fear and horrid flight."
(Timon of Athens, v. 5.)
Fr. poussif, from Lat. pulsus, throbbing. It was
formerly used also in connection with horses—
"You must warrant this horse clear of the glanders, and
pursyness."
(The Gentleman's Dictionary, 1705.)
ARQUEBUS—JAUNTY
Arquebus, Fr. arquebuse, is a doublet of hackbut, Old
Fr. haquebute, "an haquebut, or arquebuse; a caliver"
(Cotgrave). The corruption is due to arcus, bow.
Both arquebus and hackbut are common in Scott—
"His arms were halbert, axe, or spear,
A cross-bow there, a hackbut here,
A dagger-knife, and brand."
(Marmion, v. 3.)
The origin is Du. haakbus, hook-gun, the second
element of which appears in blunderbuss. The first
part of this word has undergone so many popular
transformations that it is difficult to say which was
the original form. Ludwig has Donner-büchs, Blunder-büchs,
oder Muszketon, "a thunder-box; a blunder-buss;
a musketoon; a wide-mouthed brass-gun, carrying about
twenty pistol bullets at once." It was also called in
German Plantier-büchs, from plantieren, to plant, set up,
because fired from a rest. Du. bus, like Ger. Büchse,
means both "box" and "gun." In the bushes, or axle-boxes,
of a cart-wheel, we have the same word. The
ultimate origin is Greek πύξος, the box-tree, whence
also the learned word pyx. Fr. boîte, box, is cognate,
and Fr. boussole, mariners' compass, is from the Italian
diminutive bossola, "a boxe that mariners keepe their
compasse in. Also taken for the compasse" (Florio).
Scissors were formerly cizars (cf. Fr. ciseaux),
connected with Lat. cædere, to cut. The modern
spelling is due to association with Lat. scissor, a cutter,
tailor, from scindere, to cut. Runagate is well known
to be a corrupt doublet of renegade, one who has
"denied" his faith. Recreant, the present participle
of Old Fr. recreire, Vulgar Lat. *recredere, to change
one's faith, contains very much the same idea; cf.
miscreant, lit. unbeliever. Jaunty, spelt janty by
Wycherley and genty by Burns, is Fr. gentil, wrongly
brought into connection with jaunt.
In some cases of folk-etymology it is difficult to see
to what idea the corruption is due.[98] The mollusc called
a periwinkle was in Anglo-Saxon pinewincla, which still
survives in dialect as pennywinkle. It appears to have
been influenced by the plant-name periwinkle, which is
itself a corruption of Mid. Eng. pervenke, from Lat.
pervinca; cf. Fr. pervenche. The material called
lutestring was formerly lustring, Fr. lustrine, from its
glossiness. A wiseacre is "one that knows or tells
truth; we commonly use it in malam partem for a
fool" (Blount, Glossographia, 1674). This comes,
through Dutch, from Ger. Weissager, commonly understood
as wise-sayer, but really unconnected with sagen,
to say. The Old High Ger. wīzago, prophet, is cognate
with Eng. witty. The military and naval word ensign
is in Shakespeare corrupted, in both its meanings, into
ancient. Thus Falstaff describes his tatterdemalion
recruits as—
"Ten times more dishonourable ragged than an old-faced ancient."
(1 Henry IV., iv. 2.)
while Ancient Pistol is familiar to every reader. A
cordwainer, from Old Fr. cordouanier, "a shoomaker,
a cordwainer" (Cotgrave), worked with cordouan, "Cordovan
leather; which is properly a goat's skin tanned."
The modern French form cordonnier is due to association
with cordon, a thong, bootlace, etc. Witch-elm
has nothing to do with witches. It is for older
weech-elm, wiche-elm, and belongs to Anglo-Sax. wīcan,
to bend. Service-tree is a meaningless corruption
of Mid. Eng. serves, an early loan word from Lat.
sorbus.
In the case of a double-barrelled word, folk-etymology
usually affects one half only, e.g., verdigris is
for Fr. vert-de-gris, for Old Fr. vert de Grece, Greek
green. The reason for the name is unknown. Cotgrave
calls it "Spanish green." Mid. English had the
more correct vertegresse and verte Grece (Promptorium
Parvulorum, 1440). The cavalry trumpet-call boot
and saddle is for Fr. boute-selle, lit. "put saddle."
Court card is for coat card, a name given to these
cards from the dresses depicted on them. Florio
has carta di figura, "a cote carde." The card game
called Pope Joan would appear to be in some way
corrupted from nain jaune, lit. "yellow dwarf," its
French name.
"PREPOSTEROUS" PERVERSIONS
But occasionally the results of folk-etymology are
literally preposterous.[99] The Fr. choucroute is from
sūrkrūt, a dialect pronunciation of Ger. Sauer-kraut,
sour cabbage, so that the first syllable, meaning "sour,"
has actually been corrupted so as to mean "cabbage."
Another example, which I have never seen quoted,
is the name of a beech-wood near the little town
of Remilly in Lorraine. The trees of this wood are
very old and curiously twisted, and they are called
in French les jolis fous, where fou (Lat. fagus) is
the Old French for "beech" (fouet, whip, is its
diminutive). This is rendered in German as tolle
Buchen, mad beeches, the fou having been misunderstood
as referring to the fantastic appearance of
the trees.
Forlorn hope is sometimes used metaphorically as
though the hope were of the kind that springs eternal in
the human breast. In military language it now means
the leaders of a storming party—
"The forlorn hope of each attack consisted of a sergeant and
twelve Europeans."
(Wellington's Despatches, 1799.)
but was earlier used of soldiers in any way exposed
to special danger. Cotgrave has enfans perdus, "perdus;
or the forlorne hope of a campe (are commonly gentlemen
of companies)." It is from obsolete Du. verloren hoop,
where hoop, cognate with Eng. heap, is used for a
band or company. In 16th-century German we find
ein verlorener Haufe. Both the Dutch and German
expressions are obsolete in this sense.
The military phrase to run the gauntlet has no connection
with gauntlet, glove. The older form gantlope—
"Some said he ought to be tied neck and heels; others that
he deserved to run the gantlope."
(Tom Jones, vii. 1.)
It is a punishment of Swedish origin from the period
of the Thirty Years' War. The Swedish form is gatlopp,
in which gat is cognate with Eng. gate, in its
northern sense of "street," and lopp with Eng. leap and
Ger. laufen, to run.
The press-gang had originally nothing to do with
"pressing." When soldiers or seamen were engaged,
they received earnest money called prest-money, i.e., an
advance on "loan," Old Fr. prest (prêt), and the engagement
was called presting or impresting. Florio explains
soldato (see p. 154), lit. "paid," by "prest with paie as
soldiers are." The popular corruption to press took
place naturally as the method of enlistment became
more "pressing."
The black art is a translation of Old Fr. nigromance,
"nigromancie, conjuring, the black art" (Cotgrave); but
this is folk-etymology for nécromantie, Greco-Lat. necromantia,
divination by means of the dead. The popular
form négromancie still survives in French. To curry
favour is a corruption of Mid. Eng. "to curry favel."
The expression is translated from French. Palsgrave has
curryfavell, a flatterer, "estrille faveau," estriller (étriller)
meaning "to curry (a horse)." Faveau, earlier fauvel, is
the name of a horse in the famous Roman de Fauvel, a
satirical Old French poem of the early 14th century. He
symbolises worldly vanity carefully tended by all classes
of society. The name is a diminutive of Fr. fauve, tawny,
cognate with Eng. fallow (deer). (See also p. 192, n.)
A very curious case of folk-etymology is seen in the
old superstition of the hand of glory. This is understood
to be a skeleton hand from the gallows which will point
out hidden treasure—
"Now mount who list,
And close by the wrist
Sever me quickly the Dead Man's fist."
(Ingoldsby, The Hand of Glory.)
It is simply a translation of Fr. main de gloire. But the
French expression is a popular corruption of mandragore,
from Lat. mandragora, the mandragore, or mandrake, to
the forked roots of which a similar virtue was attributed,
especially if the plant were obtained from the foot of
the gallows.
CONTAMINATION
Akin to folk-etymology is contamination, i.e., the
welding of two words into one. This can often be
noticed in children, whose linguistic instincts are those
of primitive races. I have heard a child, on her first
visit to the Zoo, express great eagerness to see the
canimals (camels × animals), which, by the way, turned
out to be the giraffes. A small boy who learnt English
and German simultaneously evolved, at the age of two,
the word spam (sponge × Ger. Schwamm). In a college
in the English midlands, a student named Constantine,
who sat next to a student named Turpin, once heard
himself startlingly addressed by a lecturer as Turpentine.
People who inhabit the frontier of two languages, and in
fact all who are in any degree bilingual, must inevitably
form such composites occasionally. The h aspirate of
Fr. haut, Lat. altus, high, can only be explained by the
influence of Old High Ger. hōh (hoch). The poetic
word glaive cannot be derived from Lat. gladius, sword,
which has given Fr. glai, an archaic name for the
gladiolus. We must invoke the help of a Gaulish word
cladebo, sword, which is related to Gaelic clay-more, big
sword. It has been said that in this word the swords
of Cæsar and Vercingetorix still cross each other. In
Old French we find oreste, a storm, combined from orage
and tempeste (tempête). Fr. orteil, toe, represents the
mixture of Lat. articulus, a little joint, with Gaulish
ordag. A battledore was in Mid. English a washing
beetle, which is in Provençal batedor, lit. beater. Hence
it seems that this is one of the very few Provençal
words which passed directly into English during the
period of our occupation of Guienne. It has been
contaminated by the cognate beetle.
Cannibal is from Span. canibal, earlier caribal, i.e.
Carib, the n being perhaps due to contamination with
Span. canino, canine, voracious. It can hardly be doubted
that this word suggested Shakespeare's Caliban. Seraglio
is due to confusion between the Turkish word serai, a
palace, and Ital. serraglio, "an inclosure, a close, a padocke,
a parke, a cloister or secluse" (Florio), which belongs
to Lat. sera, a bolt or bar.
Anecdotage is a deliberate coinage ascribed to John
Wilkes—
"When a man fell into his anecdotage, it was a sign for him to
retire from the world."
(Disraeli, Lothair, Ch. 28.)
ARBOUR—FRET
In some cases it is impossible to estimate the
different elements in a word. Arbour certainly owes
its modern spelling to Lat. arbor, a tree, but it
represents also Mid. Eng. herbere, erbere, which comes,
through French, from Lat. *herbarium. But this can
only mean herb-garden, so that the sense development
of the word must have been affected by harbour,
properly "army-shelter," ultimately identical with Fr.
auberge (p. 164). When Dryden wrote—
"Tardy of aid, unseal thy heavy eyes,
Awake, and with the dawning day arise."
(The Cock and the Fox, 247.)
he was expressing a composite idea made up from the
verb seal, Old Fr. seeler (sceller), Lat. sigillare, and seel,
Old Fr. ciller, Vulgar Lat. *ciliare, from cilium, eye-brow.
The latter verb, meaning to sew together the
eyelids of a young falcon, was once a common word—
"Come, seeling night,
Scarf up the tender eye of pitiful day."
(Macbeth, iii. 2.)
The verb fret is Anglo-Sax. fretan, to eat away (cf. Ger.
fressen). Fret is also used of interlaced bars in heraldry,
in which sense it corresponds to Fr. frette with the same
meaning; for this word, which also means ferrule, a
Vulgar Lat. *ferritta (ferrum, iron) has been suggested.
When Hamlet speaks of—
"This majestical roof fretted with golden fire,"
(Hamlet, ii. 3.)
is he thinking of frets in heraldry, or of fretwork, or are
these two of one origin? Why should fret, in this
sense, not come from fret, to eat away, since fretwork
may be described as the "eating away" of part of the
material? Cf. etch, which comes, through Dutch, from
Ger. ätzen, the factitive of essen, to eat. But the
German for fretwork is durchbrochene Arbeit, "broken-through"
work, and Old Fr. fret or frait, Lat. fractus,
means "broken." Who shall decide how much our
fretwork owes to each of these possible etymons?
That form of taxation called excise, which dates
from the time of Charles I., has always been unpopular.
Andrew Marvell says that Excise—
"With hundred rows of teeth the shark exceeds,
And on all trades like cassowar she feeds."
Dr Johnson defines it as "a hateful tax levied upon
commodities, and adjudged not by the common judges
of property, but wretches hired by those to whom excise
is paid," an outburst which Lord Mansfield considered
"actionable." The name, like the tax, came from the
Netherlands, where it was called accijs—
"'Twere cheap living here, were it not for the monstrous excises
which are impos'd upon all sorts of commodities, both for belly
and back."
(Howell, Letter from Amsterdam, 1619.)
In modern Dutch it has become accijns, through
confusion with cijns, tax (Lat. census; cf. Ger. Zins,
interest). But the Dutch word is from Fr. accise,
which appears in medieval Latin as accisia, as though
connected with "cutting" (cf. tallage, from Fr. tailler,
to cut), or with the "incidence" of the tax. It is
perhaps a perversion of Ital. assisa, "an imposition,
or taxe, or assesment" (Torriano); but there is also
an Old Fr. aceis which must be related to Latin census.
When folk-etymology and contamination work
together, the result is sometimes bewildering. Thus
equerry represents an older querry or quirry, still usual
in the 18th century. Among my books is—
"The Compleat Horseman, or Perfect Farrier, written in
French by the Sieur de Solleysell, Querry to the Present King
of France" (1702).
The modern spelling is due to popular association with
Lat. equus. But this querry is identical with French
écurie, stable, just as in Scottish the post often means the
postman. And écurie, older escurie, is from Old High Ger.
scura[100] (Scheuer, barn). The word used in modern French
in the sense of our equerry is écuyer, older escuier, Lat.
scutarius, shield-bearer, whence our word esquire. This
écuyer is in French naturally confused with écurie, so that
Cotgrave defines escuyrie as "the stable of a prince, or
nobleman; also, a querry-ship; or the duties, or offices
belonging thereto; also (in old authors) a squire's place;
or, the dignity, title, estate of an esquire."
PLEONASM
Ignorance of the true meaning of a word often leads
to pleonasm. Thus greyhound means hound-hound, the
first syllable representing Icel. grey, a dog. Peajacket
is explanatory of Du. pij, earlier pye, "py-gown, or
rough gown, as souldiers and seamen wear" (Hexham).
On Greenhow Hill means "on green hill hill," and
Buckhurst Holt Wood means "beech wood wood wood,"
an explanatory word being added as its predecessor
became obsolete. The second part of salt-cellar is
not the same word as in wine-cellar. It comes from
Fr. salière, "a salt-seller" (Cotgrave), so that the
salt is unnecessary. We speak pleonastically of "dishevelled
hair," while Old Fr. deschevelé, lit. dis-haired,
now replaced by échevelé, can only be applied to a
person, e.g., une femme toute deschevelée, "discheveled,
with all her haire disorderly falling about her eares"
(Cotgrave). The word cheer meant in Mid. English
"face." Its French original chère scarcely survives
except in the phrase faire bonne chère, lit. "make
a good face," a meaning preserved in "to be of
good cheer." In both languages the meaning has been
transferred to the more substantial blessings which the
pleasant countenance seems to promise, and also to the
felicity resulting from good treatment. The true
meaning of the word is so lost that we can speak of a
"cheerful face," i.e., a face full of face.
UNEXPLAINED DISTORTIONS
But there are many words whose changes of form
cannot be altogether explained by any of the influences
that have been discussed in this and the preceding
chapters. Why should cervelas, "a large kind of
sausage, well season'd, and eaten cold in slices"
(Kersey's Eng. Dict., 1720), now be saveloy? We
might invoke the initial letters of sausage to account for
part of the change, but the oy remains a mystery.
Cervelas, earlier cervelat, comes through French from Ital.
cervellato, "a kinde of dry sausage" (Florio), said to have
been originally made from pig's brains. For hatchment
we find in the 16th century achement, and even achievement.
It is archaic Fr. hachement, the ornamental crest
of a helmet, etc., probably derived from Old Fr. achemer,
variant of acesmer, to adorn. Hence both the French and
English forms have an unexplained h-, the earlier achement
being nearer the original. French omelette has a bewildering
history, but we can trace it almost to its present
form. To begin with, an omelet, in spite of proverbs, is
not necessarily associated with eggs. The origin is to
be found in Lat. lamella, a thin plate,[101] which gave Old
Fr. lamelle. Then la lamelle was taken as l'alamelle, and
the new alamelle or alemelle became, with change of
suffix, alemette. By metathesis (see p. 59) this gave
amelette, still in dialect use, for which modern French has
substituted omelette. The o then remains unexplained,
unless we admit the influence of the old form œuf-mollet,
a product of folk-etymology.
Counterpane represents Old Fr. coute-pointe, now corruptly
courte-pointe, from Lat. culcita puncta, lit.
"stitched quilt"; cf. Ger. Steppdecke, counterpane, from
steppen, to stitch. In Old French we also find the corrupt
form contrepointe which gave Eng. counterpoint—
"In ivory coffers I have stuff'd my crowns;
In cypress chests my arras, counterpoints,
Costly apparel, tents and canopies."
(Taming of the Shrew, ii. 1.)
in modern English replaced by counterpane. Mid.
English has also the more correct form quilt-point, from
the Old Norman cuilte (pur)pointe, which occurs in a
12th-century poem on St Thomas of Canterbury. The
hooped petticoat called a farthingale was spelt by
Shakespeare fardingale and by Cotgrave vardingall.
This is Old Fr. verdugalle, of Spanish origin and
derived from Span. verdugo, a (green) wand, because the
circumference was stiffened with flexible switches before
the application of whalebone or steel to this purpose.
The crinoline, as its name implies, was originally
strengthened with horse-hair, Lat. crinis, hair. To
return to the farthingale, the insertion of an n before g
is common in English (see p. 84, n. 2), but the change
of the initial consonant is baffling. The modern Fr.
vertugadin is also a corrupt form. Isinglass seems
to be an arbitrary perversion of obsolete Du. huyzenblas
(huisblad), sturgeon bladder; cf. the cognate Ger.
Hausenblase.
Few words have suffered so many distortions as
liquorice. The original is Greco-Lat. glycyrrhiza,
lit. "sweet root," corrupted into late Lat. liquiritia,
whence Fr. réglisse, Ital. legorizia, regolizia, and Ger.
Lakritze. The Mid. English form licoris would appear
to have been influenced by orris, a plant which also
has a sweet root, while the modern spelling is perhaps
due to liquor.