Sir Isaac Brock was succeeded in his civil and military
commands in Upper Canada by Major-General Sheaffe, who was
created a baronet for the dearly bought victory of Queenstown.
After the battle, he paroled General Wadsworth and some of the
principal American officers, the remainder proceeding to Quebec.
Among the prisoners, 23 were found to be deserters from English
regiments, and British born subjects; and they were sent to
England for trial as traitors. This caused a retaliation upon
British prisoners in the United States, and an equal number were
put by the American government into close confinement as hostages
for the security of the traitors.
On the 18th of October, General Smyth assumed the command at
Niagara, and applied to the British general for an armistice; and
notwithstanding the well-known prejudicial effect of the former
one proposed by Sir George Prevost, it was agreed to by
Major-General Sheaffe![118] This unaccountable proceeding, as might
easily have been foreseen, proved of material detriment to the British on
Lake Erie, as the Americans availed themselves of so favorable an
occasion to forward their naval stores unmolested from Black Rock
to Presqu'île by water, which they could not otherwise have
effected, but with immense trouble and expense by land, and
equipped at leisure the fleet which afterwards wrested from us
the command of that lake. When the enemy was prepared for a third
invasion of Upper Canada, General Smyth did not fail to give the
thirty hours notice required for the cessation of the armistice,
which terminated on the 20th of November.
"After the surrender of Detroit," said the inhabitants of
Niagara in their spirited letter to Sir George Prevost, already
quoted (page 279), "the enemy were
suffered unmolested to concentrate a large force on the Niagara,
at Sackett's Harbour on Lake Ontario, and at Ogdensburg on the
St. Lawrence; they were not interrupted in bringing forward to
these places a large quantity of field and heavy artillery, with
the requisite supplies of ammunition, and in equipping a
flotilla, to dispute with us the superiority of the lakes. When
their preparations were complete—when our regular and
militia forces were nearly exhausted with incessant watching and
fatigue, occasioned by the movements of the enemy, which kept
them constantly on the alert by uncertainty as to the point of
attack—they at length, on the 13th of October, attacked our
line at Queenstown. The behaviour of both regulars and militia on that memorable
occasion is well known to your excellency, and added another
wreath to the laurels they had gained at Detroit: the glories of
that day were, however, obscured by the death of our beloved and
now lamented chief, whose exertions had prepared the means of
achieving this great victory. This was another triumph for the
militia; they had fairly measured their strength with the enemy,
and derived additional confidence from the glorious result. Here
was another opportunity that slipped away without being improved:
Fort Niagara was abandoned by the enemy, and might have been with
the greatest ease destroyed, and its guns brought away by a
trifling force. It is neither necessary, nor do we feel inclined
to enter into the causes why it was not done; we have, however,
the strongest reason to believe that, had General Brock survived,
it would have been attempted. In addition to this (as we consider
it) capital error, Major Mullaney, and other natural born
subjects of his majesty, actually taken in arms as commissioned
officers in the service of the United States, were released and
allowed to return on parole to that country; and a partial
armistice was agreed to, liable to be broken off at thirty hours
notice, which could be productive of no real advantage to us, nor
give any repose to our harassed and suffering militia, though it
enabled the enemy to recruit his strength and organize at will
the means of attacking us anew. He was observed busily and actively employed,
throughout a great part of the month of November, collecting
boats on the Fort Erie end of the line; and when his preparations
were complete, he gave notice of the termination of the armistice
on the 20th."
"When General Wilkinson complains," observes the British
historian James, "that the executive has not rendered 'common
justice to the principal actors in this gallant scene,'—not
exhibited it to the country 'in its true light, and shewn what
deeds Americans are still capable of performing,'[119]—who among us
can retain his gravity? 'It is true,' says the general, 'complete
success did not ultimately crown this enterprise; but two great
ends were obtained for the country: it re-established the
character of the American arms;'—it did indeed!—'and
deprived the enemy, by the death of General Brock, of the best
officer that has headed their troops in Canada throughout the
war;'—truth undeniable!—'and, with his loss, put an
end to their then brilliant career;'—yet the capture of
General Wadsworth took place in less than five hours
afterwards.
"The instant we know what the Americans expected to gain, a
tolerable idea may be formed of what they actually lost by the
attack upon Queenstown. General Van Rensselaer, in a letter to
Major-General Dearborn, written five days previously, says thus:
'Should we succeed, we shall effect a great discomfiture of the enemy, by
breaking their line of communication, driving their shipping from
the mouth of this river, leaving them no rallying point in this
part of the country, appalling the minds of the Canadians, and
opening a wide and safe communication for our supplies; we shall
save our own land,—wipe away part of the score of our past
disgrace,—get excellent barracks and winter quarters, and
at least be prepared for an early campaign another year.'
"It is often said, that we throw away by the pen what we gain
by the sword. Had General Brock been less prodigal of his
valuable life, and survived the Queenstown battle, he would have
made the 13th of October a still more 'memorable' day, by
crossing the river and carrying Fort Niagara, which, at that
precise time, was nearly stripped of its garrison. Instead of
doing this, and thus putting an end to the campaign upon the
Niagara frontier, Major-General Sheaffe, General Brock's
successor, allowed himself to be persuaded to sign an
armistice."
In November, the Americans were already in command of Lake
Ontario,[120] and their fleet, after chasing the Royal
George into Kingston, captured on the 12th the transport sloop
Elizabeth, on board of which
was Mr. Brock, paymaster of the 49th. He was paroled by Commodore
Chauncey, who, to his credit be it said, immediately restored
"the plate and effects belonging to his late illustrious
relative," which he was conveying from Fort George to Kingston.
The box of letters and other papers from which this little work
has been principally compiled, was, we believe, among these
effects; and we gladly seize this opportunity to express the
obligation of Sir Isaac Brock's family to the commodore for his
generosity on this occasion.
On the 27th April, 1813, York was captured by Major-General
Dearborn, with 1,800 American troops, embarked in fourteen sail
of armed vessels, that post being occupied by 700 regulars and
militia, with from 40 to 50 Indians, the whole under the
immediate command of Sir Roger Sheaffe. In resisting the enemy,
the grenadier company of the 8th (the king's) regiment greatly
distinguished themselves, losing their captain, M'Neal, and being
nearly annihilated. By an explosion of the powder magazine, to
which a train had been laid, 260 of the Americans were killed or
wounded, including Brigadier Pike among the former; and they were
thrown into such confusion, that an immediate and resolute attack
would probably have sent them back to their ships.[121] The British
general "drew off his regulars and left the rest to capitulate within
the town, wherein considerable public stores were lost;"[122] and the Americans,
having secured their booty, re-embarked and sailed on the 2d of
May for Niagara. The inhabitants of York do not appear to have
been satisfied with the conduct of Major-General Sheaffe in this
affair; and, although it was not ascertained whether his removal
was the result of the displeasure of the Commander-in-chief, he
was replaced early in July by Major-General de Rottenburg, and on
his arrival in the Lower Province he assumed the command of the
troops in the district of Montreal. A few months after, the Baron
de Rottenburg was in his turn succeeded by Lieut.-General Gordon
Drummond, who commanded in Upper Canada to the end of the
war.
We have alluded (page 278) to the
discomfiture of Sir George Prevost before Sackett's Harbour, that
naval arsenal whose destruction Major-General Brock was so
unfortunately prevented from undertaking. The governor-general
having proceeded in May from Montreal to Kingston with Sir James
Yeo, who had just arrived from England to command the British
naval forces on the lakes—the squadron on Lake Ontario now
consisting of two ships, a brig, and two schooners—the
public was on the tiptoe of expectation for some decisive dash on
the enemy's flotilla on that lake. An attack upon Sackett's
Harbour, in the absence of their fleet at Niagara, was resolved upon, so as to destroy "the
forts, the arsenals, and the dock-yard, where the Americans had a
frigate almost ready for launching, and several other vessels;
but when this wavering and spiritless general reconnoitred the
place, he would not venture an attack, and returned across the
water towards Kingston. Then he changed his mind and went back to
Sackett's Harbour; and (but not without more wavering and loss of
time) our troops, about 750 strong, were landed. The Americans
were presently driven at the bayonet's point into some loop-holed
barracks and forts; and so panic-stricken were they that they
immediately set fire to their new frigate, their naval barracks
and arsenal, and destroyed a gun-brig and all the stores which
had so recently been captured at York. While the arsenal was in
flames, while the Americans were flying through the village, and
when the complete success of the assailants was certain, Sir
George Prevost sent a precipitate order for retreat, merely
because a momentary resistance was offered by a party of
Americans who had taken refuge in the log-barracks! The British
troops reluctantly obeyed their general's order and returned to
their boats, men and officers being acutely sensible to his
folly, and wondering by what means so incompetent a commander had
been placed over them. If Sir George Prevost had studied the
history of the war of the American revolution, it could only have
been with an eye to copy all the indecisions and blunders of the formalising, badly
instructed English generals of that period. But the Howes,
Clintons, and Burgoynes, were at least always ready to fight. As
soon as the Americans could believe that the English were really
abandoning their enterprize at the moment that it was all but
completed, they rushed back to stop the conflagration: they were
too late to save the stores which had been brought from York, the
navy barracks, or the brig, but the frigate on the stocks, being
built of green wood, would not easily burn, and was found but
little injured. If the destruction at Sackett's Harbour had been
completed, we should have deprived the Americans of every
prospect of obtaining the ascendancy on the lake."[123] And, as if to
crown this miserable failure, the details were narrated by the
adjutant-general, in a dispatch to Sir George Prevost, as if
Colonel Baynes had commanded in chief, and the governor-general
had been present as a mere spectator![124]
From these humiliating occurrences on Lake Ontario, we turn to
the captured post of Detroit, which, it will be remembered, was
left by Major-General Brock in charge of Colonel Proctor. No
sooner had intelligence of the surrender of Hull reached Washington, than the renewal of
the North-Western army for the recovery of the Michigan territory
became the anxious object of the American government. That army,
which eventually outnumbered the former one, was placed under the
command of Major-General Harrison, (who died a few years since
while president of the United States,) and in September was in
full march for the Miami rapids, the spot assigned as the general
rendezvous. In January, 1813, Colonel Proctor received
information that a brigade of that army, under Brigadier
Winchester, was encamped at Frenchtown, on the river Raisin, 40
miles south of Detroit. The British commander, although he had
orders not to act on the offensive, promptly determined to attack
this brigade before it was reinforced by the main body, a few
days march in the rear; and with his disposable force, consisting
of 500 regulars, militia, and seamen, he made a resolute assault,
at dawn on the 22d, on the enemy's camp, which was completely
successful. In this affair the Americans lost between 3 and 400
men killed; and Brigadier Winchester, 3 field officers, 9
captains, 20 subalterns, and upwards of 500 men, in prisoners.
This gallant exploit secured Detroit from any immediate danger,
but the day after it was sadly tarnished by the straggling
Indians, who massacred such wounded prisoners as were unable to
walk, the guard left for their protection deserting their charge
on a false alarm of General Harrison's approach. This success, for which Colonel Proctor
was immediately promoted to the rank of Brigadier, together with
the spoil obtained at Frenchtown, brought down several warlike
tribes of Indians from the river Wabash, and even from the more
distant Mississippi, to join the British standard. Towards the
end of March, Proctor learnt that General Harrison intended to
commence active operations for the recovery of the Michigan
territory, on the arrival of considerable reinforcements which he
was expecting. Resolved to try the issue of another attack before
the enemy, already much superior in numbers, gained a fresh
acquisition of strength, Proctor embarked at Amherstburg with 520
regulars and 460 militia, and made for the mouth of the Miami,
which falls into Lake Erie. He ascended that river, about 1,200
Indians co-operating with him, and landed his troops, stores, and
ordnance, on the 28th of April, near Fort Meigs, mounting
eighteen guns, which he cannonaded from both banks of the Miami,
On the 5th of May the enemy's long-expected reinforcements, under
Major-General Clay, came suddenly down the river; they were 1,300
strong, but newly-raised militia; and as the boats drew near,
Harrison ordered Clay to storm the British batteries on the
opposite or north side of the river, while a sortie was made from
the fort for the purpose of capturing the three British guns on
the southern bank. For a short period the British batteries on
both sides were in the hands of the enemy, but they were quickly regained by bayonet
charges; and on the north bank Colonel Dudley, after spiking the
captured guns, having marched with 400 men to attack the British
camp, was drawn into an ambuscade by the Indians, and himself and
about half his men were slain. Of the Americans, about 550 men
were made prisoners, and their killed and wounded were estimated
at nearly as many more. The far-famed Tecumseh buried his
tomahawk in the head of a Chippewa chief, whom he found actively
engaged in massacring some of the prisoners. But as the Indians
retired, as is their wont after success, to enjoy their plunder;
and as many of the militia were also returning to their homes,
Proctor was compelled to raise the siege of Fort Meigs. Having
re-embarked his small force of regulars, chiefly of the 41st, and
the whole of his ordnance and stores, he proceeded to Sandwich;
while General Harrison abandoned all intention of advancing
against Detroit until the American squadron had gained the
command of Lake Erie.
Major-General Proctor having determined to recommence his
attacks against the American North-Western army, whose head
quarters were then in the neighbourhood of Sandusky Bay, on Lake
Erie, he landed on the 1st of August near the Sandusky river, and
soon after invested with 400 regulars and between 3 and 400
Indians, Fort Stephenson, about 20 miles from its mouth. On the
2d, a fire was opened from two 6-pounders and two 5½-inch howitzers against the fort,
which appears to have possessed only one masked 6-pounder, and to
have been garrisoned by about 180 men, under Major Croghan, but
as the fire produced no impression, the place was ordered to be
stormed. The assailants reached the ditch which was raked by the
masked gun, and sustained in consequence so severe a loss, that
they retreated precipitately, having their leader, Brevet
Lieut-Colonel Short, of the 41st, with 3 officers and 52 men,
killed or missing, besides 3 officers and 38 men wounded; while
the Americans had only 1 killed and 7 slightly wounded. The
Indians did not assist in the assault, withdrawing to a ravine
out of gun shot. Thus foiled, Proctor retired on the 3d, and
after abandoning "considerable baggage and a gun-boat laden with
cannon ball," he returned to Amherstburg. The attack is said to
have been "ill digested," and the expedition to have ended with
"some disgrace."
Towards the end of August, (1813,) the American squadron,
under Commodore Perry, became too powerful for the British, under
Captain Barclay, who now remained at Amherstburg to await the
equipment of the Detroit, recently launched. The British forces
in the neighbourhood falling short of various supplies, for which
they depended chiefly upon the fleet, Captain Barclay had no
other alternative than to risk a general engagement. With this
purpose he sailed on the 9th of September, with his small
squadron wretchedly manned,
and the next day encountered the enemy. For some time the fate of
the battle poised in favor of the British, as the principal
American ship, the Lawrence, struck her colours; but a sudden
breeze turned the scale against them, and the whole of their
squadron was compelled to surrender, after a desperate engagement
of upwards of three hours. Captain Barclay was dangerously
wounded; Captain Finnis, of the Queen Charlotte, killed; and
every commander and officer second in command was either killed
or wounded.
Major-General Proctor's army was deprived, by this disastrous
defeat, of every prospect of obtaining its necessary supplies
through Lake Erie, and a speedy retreat towards the head of Lake
Ontario became inevitable. Stung with grief and indignation,
Tecumseh at first refused to agree to the measure, and in a
council of war held at Amherstburg on the 18th of September, he
thus delivered his sentiments against it:
Father, listen to your children! You have them now all
before you.
The war before this, our British father gave the hatchet to
his red children, when our old chiefs were alive. They are now
dead. In that war our father was thrown on his back by the
Americans, and our father took them by the hand without our
knowledge; and we are afraid that our father will do so again
at this time.
The summer before last, when I came forward with my red
brethren, and was ready to take up the hatchet in favor of our
British father, we were told not to be in a hurry,—that
he had not yet determined to fight the Americans.
Listen! When war was
declared, our father stood up and gave us the tomahawk, and
told us that he was then ready to strike the Americans; that he
wanted our assistance; and that he would certainly get us hack
our lands, which the Americans had taken from us.
Listen! You told us, at that time, to bring forward our
families to this place, and we did so; and you promised to take
care of them, and that they should want for nothing, while the
men would go and fight the enemy; that we need not trouble
ourselves about the enemy's garrisons; that we knew nothing
about them, and that our father would attend to that part of
the contest. You also told your red children that you would
take good care of your garrison here, which made our hearts
glad.
Listen! When we were last at the Rapids, it is true we gave
you little assistance. It is hard to fight people who live like
ground hogs.
Father, listen! Our fleet has gone out; we know they have
fought; we have heard the great guns; but we know nothing of
what has happened to our father with that arm. Our ships have
gone one way, and we are much astonished to see our father
tying up every thing and preparing to run away the other,
without letting his red children know what his intentions are.
You always told us to remain here and take care of our lands;
it made our hearts glad to hear that was your wish. Our great
father, the king, is the head, and you represent him. You
always told us that you would never draw your foot off British
ground; but now, father, we see you are drawing back, and we
are sorry to observe our father doing so without seeing the
enemy. We must compare our father's conduct to a fat dog, that
carries its tail upon its back, but when affrighted, it drops
it between its legs and runs off.
Father, listen! The Americans have not yet defeated us by
land; neither are we sure that they have done so by water:
we therefore wish to remain here and fight our enemy, should they make their
appearance. If they defeat us, we will then retreat
with our father.
At the battle of the Rapids, last war, the Americans
certainly defeated us; and, when we retreated to our father's
fort in the neighbourhood, the gates were shut against us. We
were afraid that it would again be the case; but, instead of
closing the gates, we now see our British father preparing to
march out of his garrison.
Father! You have got the arms and ammunition which our great
father sent for his red children. If you intend to retreat,
give them to us, and you may go, and welcome for us. Our lives
are in the hands of the Great Spirit. We are determined to
defend our lands, and if it be His will, we wish to leave our
bones upon them.
General Harrison's troops were soon transported by the
American squadron to Put-in-Bay, and they occupied
Amherstburg on the 23d of September, Proctor having previously
fallen back upon Sandwich, after setting fire to the navy yard,
barracks, and public stores at the former place. The British
general, seeing the enemy determined to follow up his first
success by an immediate attack upon Detroit, and being unable
with his very inferior numbers to dispute the occupancy of that
post, evacuated it and Sandwich on the 26th, also destroying the
public property at both posts; and commenced his retreat along
the river Thames, with between 900 and 1,000 regulars, chiefly of
the 41st regiment. In this reverse of fortune, Tecumseh still
adhered to the British standard with unswerving fidelity, and
with the Indians covered the retreat. On the 2d of October,
General Harrison marched in pursuit with rather above 3,000 men, escorted by three
gun-boats and a number of bateaux. On the 4th, he came up with
the rear guard, and not only made some prisoners, but succeeded
in capturing a great part of the ammunition and stores. By this
second reverse, the British were left destitute of the means of
subsistence and protracted defence; and their commander being
thus compelled to stake the fate of his small army on a general
engagement, he took up an excellent position on the right bank of
the Thames at the Moravian town, an Indian village 80 miles from
Sandwich, his entire force now mustering barely 900 regulars and
about 600 Indians. The former were posted in single files in two
lines, their left resting on the river, their right on a narrow
swamp, beyond which were the Indians, reaching obliquely
backwards to a second and much broader swamp, so that neither
flank of the allies could be easily turned. The enemy commenced
the attack with a regiment of mounted riflemen, the
élite of their army, formed into two divisions of
500 men each, one of which charged the regulars with great
impetuosity, while the other advanced with a company of foot
against the Indians. The regulars, dissatisfied by fancied or
real neglect, and dispirited by long continued exposure and
privation, made but a very feeble resistance; their ranks were
pierced and broken, and being placed between two fires, they
immediately surrendered, with the trifling loss of 12 killed and
22 wounded, the British general and a part of the troops seeking safety in flight. But
the Indians carried on the contest with the left of the American
line with great determination, and did not retreat until the day
was irretrievably lost and 33 of their numbers had been slain,
including the noble Tecumseh—a warrior not less celebrated
for his courage than for his humanity, his eloquence, and his
influence over the different tribes. The Americans returned to
Sandwich immediately after the action. Proctor is accused of
leaving entire the bridges and roads in the rear of his
retreating army, and of encumbering it with an unnecessary
quantity of his own personal baggage; and certain it is that his
defeat led to the harshest recrimination between Sir George
Prevost and himself. The general order of the former on the
subject was of unparalleled severity, as he said: "On this
disgraceful day upwards of 600 officers and soldiers were taken
prisoners almost without a struggle, of whom but very few
appeared to have been rescued by an honorable death from the
ignominy of passing under the American yoke; nor are there many
whose wounds plead in mitigation of this reproach." The fugitives
made the best of their way to Ancaster, at the head of Lake
Ontario; and on the 17th of October they numbered there 240,
including the general and 17 officers. The consequence of these
disasters was the relinquishment, by the British, of the Michigan
territory, with the exception of Michilimakinack; the abandonment
of the posts in Upper Canada to the westward of the Grand River, or Ouse; and the loss
of the services of the whole of the north-western Indians, with
the exception of 2 or 300, who subsequently joined the centre
division of the army.[125]
Fort George was taken in May, 1813, by a large American force,
under General Dearborn, which compelled Major-General Vincent to
withdraw his troops from Fort Erie and Chippewa, and to retreat
to Burlington Heights, at the head of Lake Ontario, the British
losing 52 killed, besides upwards of 300 wounded and missing.
Immediately after the capture of Fort George, General Dearborn
pushed forward a body of 3,000 infantry, with nine field pieces
and 250 cavalry, for the purpose of dislodging Major-General
Vincent from his position. Lieut.-Colonel Harvey,[126] deputy
adjutant-general, proposed a night attack on this body, which was
approved, and with the 49th, under Major Plenderleath, and five
companies of the 8th, under Major Ogilvie, (the whole only 704
firelocks,) he led the attack in gallant style, and completely
succeeded in surprising the enemy, who evinced a highly
creditable state of order and discipline in repeatedly forming,
though compelled as often to disperse before the resistless energy of the British
bayonet. Two brigadiers, (Chandler and Winder,) 7 other officers
and 116 men, with three guns and one brass howitzer, were taken
in this intrepid attack, which, as it reduced the Americans from
offensive to defensive operations, was of the greatest importance
to the salvation of the Upper Province. The enemy, however,
occupied Fort George till the month of December, when they were
compelled to evacuate it and retreat across the Niagara.[127] In that month,
Colonel Murray surprised, and very gallantly captured by a night
assault, Fort Niagara, which was retained by the British till the
end of the war.
The recovery of Michilimakinack had long been seriously
contemplated by the American government, and would have been
attempted in the fall of 1813, but for the lateness of the
season, when the expulsion of the British from the banks of the
Detroit had opened the passage into Lake Huron. On the other
hand, the necessity of retaining a post so favorably situated, if
in the hands of an enemy, for annoying the British north-western
trade, pressed itself on Sir George Prevost; and in April, 1814,
a reinforcement of about 90 men, under an active and zealous
officer, Lieut.-Colonel M'Douall, was forwarded with military
stores and provisions, by a back route to Michilimakinack. They
embarked in twenty-four bateaux from Nottawassega Bay on Lake Huron, distant 260
miles from Michilimakinack, and, after a very tempestuous passage
of twenty-five days, reached the fort on the 18th of May. On the
26th July, an American expedition from Lake Erie, consisting of
three brigs and two schooners of war, under Captain Sinclair,
with nearly 800 troops on board, appeared off Michilimakinack,
and a landing was effected by them on the 4th of August. The
British force on the island amounted to only 190 men, including
regulars, militia, and Indians, with which Lieut.-Colonel
M'Donall repulsed every effort of the Americans to approach the
fort; so that they were glad, to re-embark the same evening in
the utmost haste and confusion, leaving 17 dead on the ground,
while the garrison had only one Indian killed. Captain Sinclair
stated what does not appear to have been known to Lieutenant
Hanks, when he surrendered the island in 1812 to Captain
Roberts,[128] "that Michilimakinack is by nature a perfect
Gibraltar, being a high inaccessible rock on every side,[129] except the west,
from which to the heights you have nearly two miles to pass
through a wood so thick, that our men were shot in every direction, and within a
few yards of them, without being able to see the Indians who did
it." Michilimakinack remained unmolested to the end of the war,
when it was restored, by the treaty of peace, to its former
possessors.
It has already been mentioned, that among the prisoners taken
at the battle of Queenstown, 23 were sent to England for trial as
British born subjects and deserters, and that the American
government had placed an equal number of British soldiers into
close confinement as hostages. In consequence, Sir George
Prevost, by a general order of the 27th October, 1813, made known
that he had received the commands of the prince regent to put 46
American officers and non-commissioned officers into close
confinement as hostages for the 23 soldiers confined by the
American government. He at the same time apprized that
government, that if any of the British soldiers should suffer
death by reason of the guilt and execution of the traitors taken
in arms against their country, he was instructed to select out of
the American hostages double the number of the British soldiers
who might be so unwarrantably put to death, and to cause them to
suffer death immediately. The governor-general also notified to
the American government, that in the event of their carrying
their murderous threat into execution, the commanders of the
British forces, by sea and land, were instructed to prosecute the
war with unmitigated
severity against all the territory and inhabitants of the United
States.
On the 10th of December, Sir George Prevost received a
communication from Major-General Wilkinson by a flag of truce,
stating that the American government, adhering unalterably to
their previously declared purpose, had placed 46 British officers
into close confinement, there to remain until the same number of
American officers and non-commissioned officers were released. In
consequence, the governor-general ordered all the American
officers, prisoners of war, without exception of rank, to be
placed into close confinement as hostages, until the number of 46
was completed over and above those already in confinement. In
pursuance of this order, Generals Winder, Chandler, and
Winchester, were confined in a private house at Quebec, with as
little inconvenience as their security would admit.
On the 15th April, 1814, after some negotiation, opened at the
solicitation of the American government, a convention was entered
into at Montreal, by which it was agreed to release the hostages
and to make an exchange of prisoners, the American government
relinquishing its pretensions to retaliate for the prisoners sent
to England for legal trial as traitors to their country. This
convention was ratified in July, at Champlain, near the lines;
but, whether by previous agreement or tacit understanding, the
traitors, we believe, escaped the just punishment of their
crime.
The remaining events of
the war in Canada during the campaigns of 1812, 13 and 14, do not
fall within the scope of this memoir. Some we might chronicle
with pride, but a few we could not record without shame; and, on
the whole, we cannot but think that the same withering influence,
which bound the hands and repressed the energies of "him who
undoubtedly was the best officer that headed our troops
throughout the war,"[130] was visible to the termination of the
contest—a contest in which we are satisfied the result
would have been very different, "if a man of military genius,
courage, quickness, and decision, had held the supreme
command."[131] Indeed, when we reflect upon the management
of that eventful war, we are often forcibly reminded, in the
fatal loss of Sir Isaac Brock, of the pathetic lament of the
gallant highlander, who, contrasting the irresolution of his
present general with the deeds of his former chief, the renowned
Grahame,[132] Viscount Dundee, mournfully exclaimed:
Oh! for one hour of
Dundee!
During the progress of the war, the British government made
several overtures for a reconciliation; and at length, when
Napoleon's disasters commenced, and the Eastern States were
threatening to dissolve the
union, Madison expressed a wish to treat with England, even at
the end of 1813. The negotiations were commenced in earnest at
Ghent, in August, 1814, at a time when Great Britain, being at
peace with the remainder of the world, was in a condition to
prosecute the contest with all her energies; but her people
wished for repose after the long and arduous struggle in which
they had been engaged; and a treaty of peace, signed at Ghent on
the 24th of December, was ratified by the two governments, the
plenipotentiaries on both sides waiving every question at issue
before the war, and restoring every acquisition of territory
during its progress. Thus the Americans had only the Canadian and
defenceless side of the Detroit to give in exchange for their
fortress of Niagara and their key possession of
Michilimakinack.
Early in 1815, Sir George Prevost was directed to return to
England for the purpose of meeting accusations relative to his
conduct at Plattsburg, which had been preferred by Commodore Sir
James Yeo, who, after some delay, produced his charges in legal
form; and to afford time for the arrival of the necessary
witnesses from Canada, the general court martial was postponed to
the 12th of January, 1816. In the mean time the health of the
late governor-general, naturally of a delicate cast, became
seriously affected, partly from anxiety of mind, and he died in
London on the 5th of January, exactly a week preceding the
day appointed for his trial.
Previously to his departure from Lower Canada, the commons, or
French party, voted him the sum of £5,000 for the purchase
of a service of plate, as a tribute of respect, which vote was
approved of by the prince regent; but the legislative council, or
English party, refused their assent to a bill for that
purpose.
Sir George Prevost was of slight, diminutive person, and
unsoldierlike appearance; his manners are represented as
unassuming and social, and his temper as placid and forgiving.
His public speeches or addresses are said to have partaken of
even classical elegance, and his dispatches and general orders
also afford proofs of his literary acquirements. Discredit can
only be thrown on his character as a general; and indeed his best
friends must admit that his defensive policy at the commencement
of the war, and his subsequent irresolution and infirmity of
purpose, did not tend to raise the glory of England, or to
advance his own fame, and that of every enterprizing officer who
served under him. And yet soon after his death, notwithstanding
that the lamentable failures at Sackett's Harbour and Plattsburg
were fresh in the public recollection, new and honorary armorial
bearings, with supporters, were solicited and obtained by his
family in seeming approbation of his services in Canada, the
supporters being two grenadiers of the 16th foot, of which
regiment Sir George was colonel, each bearing a flag, gules; the
dexter flag inscribed, "West Indies"—the sinister, "Canada"! If these distinctions were
conferred in honor of his civil administration, which we have
already eulogized, although Veritas, in his well-known
letters, stoutly denied him any merit even on this point, they
were, we believe, justly bestowed; but if they were intended as
an approval of his military conduct during the contest, certain
it is that his contemporaries indignantly refused to concede his
claim to them, and that no historian has as yet admitted that
claim.[133] It was unfortunate for Sir George that he
was called upon to wage war against the United States, as his
natural and excusable sympathies in favor of a people among whom
he had been born, and at
least partly educated, may have influenced his judgment without
any conscious betrayal of the great charge entrusted to him; and
this remark applies with double force to his school-fellow, Sir
Roger Sheaffe, whose entire family and connexions were American.
In any case, it was hard on Sir Isaac Brock, after being retained
in Canada by Sir James Craig, when he was so anxious to serve in
the Peninsula, because that officer could not spare him, and
after at length obtaining leave to return to Europe for that
purpose—it was hard, we repeat, when hostilities did at
last break out in America, that his energies should have been so
cramped by the passive attitude of his superior. Remembering,
however, the maxim, de mortuis nil nisi bonum, the editor
has refrained from transcribing aught reflecting on the memory of
that superior when he could do so consistently with truth,
although he feels acutely that the death of Sir Isaac
Brock—hastened as he believes it was by the defensive
policy and mistaken views of Sir George Prevost—was an
irreparable loss to his many brothers,[134] who were at that period just rising into
manhood, and in consequence required all the interest for their
advancement which their uncle would probably have possessed. One
especially, who closely resembled him both in appearance and character, and who would
have been an ornament to any service, was compelled to embrace
the profession of arms, for which he had been educated, under the
banners of a foreign and far distant country. In that country,
Chile, Colonel Tupper cruelly fell at the early age of
twenty-nine years; and if the reader will turn to the memoir of
this daring soldier in the Appendix, necessarily brief as it is,
he will probably agree with the British consul who wrote, that he
had "for many years looked upon his gallant and honorable conduct
as reflecting lustre upon the English name;" and he will think
with the French traveller, who, after highly eulogizing him,
said: "N'est-il pas déplorable que de tels hommes en
soient réduits à se consacrer à une cause
étrangère?"
As Tecumseh was so conspicuous in the annals of this war for
his fidelity and devotion to the British crown, and as his name
has occurred so often in these pages,[135] a concluding and connected notice of him
will surely be deemed but an act of justice to his memory.
This renowned aboriginal chief was a Shawanee, and was born in
1769 or 1770, about the same year as his "brave brother warrior,"
Sir Isaac Brock. He may be said to have been inured to war from
his infancy, as the Indian nations continued in hostility against
the United States after their independence was achieved, alleging that they
infringed on their territories. In 1790, about which period
Tecumseh first gave proofs of that talent and daring which so
distinguished his after-life, General Harmer was dispatched with
a competent force to punish the predatory incursions of the
Indians; but he was glad to return, with the loss of many of his
men. In the following year, General St. Clair proceeded with
another army to ravage the Miami and Shawanee settlements, and
was even more unfortunate than his predecessor, as the Indians
boldly advanced to meet him on the way, attacked his encampment,
and put his troops to a total rout, in which the greater part
were cut off and destroyed. In 1794, however, a much more
formidable expedition, under General Wayne, entered the Indian
territory; the warriors gradually retired as the Americans
advanced, but at length imprudently determined on making a stand.
In the battle which ensued, the Indians were so completely
discomfited, that, the following year, they agreed to the treaty
of Greenville, by which they were compelled to cede a large tract
of country as an indemnity for past injuries! As Tecumseh
had then scarcely completed his twenty-fifth year, and as the
Indians pay great deference to age, it is not probable that he
had any hand in this treaty, the more especially as, from that
period to 1812, he laboured incessantly to unite the numerous
aboriginal tribes of the North American continent in one grand
confederacy, for the threefold purpose of endeavouring to regain their
former possessions as far as the Ohio, of resisting the further
encroachments of the whites, and of preventing the future cession
of land by any one tribe, without the sanction of all, obtained
in a general council. With this object he visited the different
nations; and having assembled the elders, he enforced his
disinterested views in strains of such impassioned and persuasive
eloquence, that the greater part promised him their co-operation
and assistance. But, to form a general alliance of so many and
such various tribes, required a higher degree of patriotism and
civilization than the Indians had attained. From the numbers,
however, who ranged themselves with Tecumseh under the British
standard; on the breaking out of the war in 1812, it is evident
that he had acquired no little influence over them, and that his
almost incredible exertions, both of mind and body, had not been
altogether thrown away.
About the year 1804, the brother of Tecumseh proclaimed
himself a prophet, who had been commanded by the Great Spirit,
the Creator of the red, but not of the white, people, to announce
to his children, that the misfortunes by which they had been
assailed arose from their having abandoned the mode of life which
He had prescribed to them. He declared that they must return to
their primitive habits—relinquish the use of ardent
spirits—and clothe themselves in skins, and not in
woollens. His fame soon spread among the surrounding nations, and his power to perform
miracles was generally believed. He was joined by many, and not a
few came from a great distance, and cheerfully submitted to much
hardship and fatigue, that they might behold the prophet, and
then return. He first established himself at Greenville, within
the boundary of the United States; but the inhabitants of Ohio
becoming alarmed at the immense assemblage of Indians on their
frontier, the American authorities insisted on his removal.
Accordingly, he proceeded, in 1808, to the Wabash, and fixed his
residence on the northern bank of that river, near the mouth of
the Tippecanoe. Here his popularity declined, but, through the
influence of Tecumseh, he was again joined by many among the
neighbouring tribes. The prophet's temporal concerns were
conducted by Tecumseh, who adroitly availed himself of his
brother's spiritual power to promote his favourite scheme of a
general confederacy.
In 1811, Tecumseh, accompanied by several hundred warriors,
encamped near Vincennes, the capital of Indiana, and demanded an
interview with the governor of that state, Major-General
Harrison, the same officer who, in 1813, commanded the victorious
troops at the battle of the Thames, in which Tecumseh lost his
life. The interview was agreed to, and the governor inquired
whether the Indians intended to come armed to the council.
Tecumseh replied that he would be governed by the conduct of the
white people; if they came
armed, his warriors would be armed also; if not, his followers
would come unarmed. The governor informed him that he would be
attended by a troop of dragoons, dismounted, with their side arms
only, and that the Indians might bring their war clubs and
tomahawks. The meeting took place in a large arbour, on one side
of which were the dragoons, eighty in number, seated in rows; on
the other the Indians. But besides their sabres, the dragoons
were armed with pistols. The following incident is said to have
occurred at this interview. Tecumseh looked round for a seat, but
not finding one provided for him, he betrayed his surprise, and
his eyes flashed fire. The governor, perceiving the cause,
instantly ordered a chair. One of the council offered the warrior
his chair, and, bowing respectfully, said to him: "Warrior, your
father, General Harrison, offers you a seat." "My father!"
exclaimed Tecumseh, extending his hand towards the heavens, "the
sun is my father, and the earth is my mother; she gives me
nourishment, and I will repose on her bosom." He then threw
himself on the ground. When the governor, who was seated in front
of the dragoons, commenced his address, Tecumseh declared that he
could not hear him, and requested him to remove his seat to an
open space near himself, The governor complied, and in his speech
complained of the constant depredations and murders which were
committed by the Indians of Tippecanoe; of the refusal on their
part to give up the
criminals; and of the increasing accumulation of force in that
quarter, for the avowed purpose of compelling the United States
to relinquish lands, which they had fairly purchased of the
rightful owners. Tecumseh, in his answer, denied that he had
afforded protection to the guilty, but manfully admitted his
design of forming a confederacy of all the red nations of that
continent. He observed, that "the system, which the United States
pursued of purchasing lands from the Indians, he viewed as a
mighty water, ready to overflow his people, and that the
confederacy which he was forming among the tribes, to prevent any
tribe from selling land without the consent of the others, was
the dam he was erecting, to resist this mighty water." And
he added, "your great father, the president, may sit over the
mountains and drink his wine, but if he continue this policy, you
and I will have to meet on the battle field." He also admitted,
that he was then on his way to the Creek nation, for the purpose
he had just avowed, and he continued his journey two days after,
with twelve or fifteen of his warriors. Having visited the Creek
and other southern tribes, he crossed the Mississippi, and
continued a northern course as far as the river Demoins, whence
he returned to the Wabash by land. But a sad reverse of fortune
awaited his return; he found his town consumed, his bravest
warriors slain, and a large deposit of provisions destroyed. On
his departure, the settlement at Tippecanoe was left in charge of his brother, the prophet,
with strict injunctions to prevent all hostile incursions, as
they might lead to extremities before his plans were matured. The
prophet, however, wanted either the inclination or the authority
to follow these injunctions; and the Americans assert, that
murder and rapine occurred now so frequently, that they were
compelled, in their own defence, to punish the delinquents.
Accordingly, General Harrison proceeded with nearly 1,000 men to
Tippecanoe, and on his approach, in November, 1811, was met by
about 600 warriors; a battle ensued, in which the Indians,
deprived by the absence of their chief of his counsel and
example, were defeated, but with nearly equal loss on both sides.
Assured by the prophet that the American bullets would not injure
them, they rushed on the bayonets with their war clubs, and
exposed their persons with a fatal fearlessness. But the prophet
himself remained during the battle in security on an adjacent
eminence; he was chaunting a war song, when information was
brought to him that his men were falling. "Let them fight on, for
my prediction will soon be verified," was the substance of his
reply, and he resumed his song in a louder key!
The hostility of Tecumseh to those whom he had ever considered
as the spoilers of his country, was, if possible, redoubled by
this severe act of retaliation. General Harrison, in particular,
incurred his personal enmity, and he declared openly that he would seek for vengeance.
Nor was he backward in putting his threats into execution. Early
in 1812, the Indians renewed their hostile incursions, but they
were now treated with unusual forbearance, in the hope that they
would remain neutral in the war with Great Britain, which the
American government well knew was near at hand. On its
declaration in June, however, Tecumseh eagerly embraced the
opportunity which it afforded, not only to promote his long
meditated public views, but to avenge his private injuries; and,
hastening with his warriors to Upper Canada, he had soon the
gratification of witnessing, at Detroit, the surrender of the 4th
U.S. infantry, (or heroes of Tippecanoe, as they were then
denominated,) which regiment claimed the principal merit of
having, the preceding year, defeated his followers and destroyed
his settlement.
Previously to the battle of the Thames, already noticed, the
position chosen to await the attack of the American army, and the
disposition of the British force, were approved of by Tecumseh,
and his last words to General Proctor were: "Father, tell your
young men to be firm, and all will be well." He then repaired to
his people, and harangued them before they occupied their post.
While the white troops were so quickly overcome, Tecumseh and his
warriors almost as rapidly repelled the enemy; and the Indians
continued to push their advantage in ignorance of the disaster of
their allies, until their heroic chief fell by a rifle bullet, while in the act of
advancing to close with Colonel Johnson, who was on horseback
commanding his regiment of mounted riflemen.
Of the many Indian chiefs who distinguished themselves in the
wars of the whites, Tecumseh was undoubtedly the greatest since
the days of Pontiac. Sir Isaac Brock has expressed his warm
admiration of him, and it is well known that the feeling was
mutual; but it is said that after the death of his friend and
patron, Tecumseh found no kindred spirit with whom to act. In
early life he was addicted to inebriety, the prevailing vice of
the Indians, but his good sense and resolution conquered the
habit, and, in his later years, he was remarkable for temperance.
Glory became his ruling passion, and in its acquisition he was
careless of wealth, as, although his presents and booty must have
been of considerable value, he preserved little or nothing for
himself. In height he was five feet ten inches, well formed, and
capable of enduring fatigue in an extraordinary degree. His
carriage was erect and commanding, and there was an air of
hauteur in his countenance, arising from an elevated pride of
soul, which did not forsake it when life was extinct. He was
habitually taciturn, but, when excited, his eloquence was
nervous, concise, and figurative. His dress was plain, and he was
never known to indulge in the gaudy decoration of his person,
which is the common practice of the Indians. On the day of his
death, he wore a dressed deer skin coat and pantaloons. He was present in almost every
action against the Americans, from the period of Harmer's defeat
to the battle of the Thames—was several times
wounded—and always sought the hottest of the fire. On the
19th July, 1812, he pursued, near Sandwich, a detachment of the
American army under Colonel M'Arthur, and fired on the rear
guard. The colonel suddenly faced about his men and gave orders
for a volley, when all the Indians fell flat on the ground with
the exception of Tecumseh, who stood firm on his feet, with
apparent unconcern! After his fall, his lifeless corpse was
viewed with great interest by the American officers, who declared
that the contour of his features was majestic even in death. And
notwithstanding, it is said by an American writer, that "some of
the Kentuckians disgraced themselves by committing indignities on
his dead body. He was scalped, and otherwise disfigured."
He left a son, who fought by his side when he fell, and was then
about seventeen years old. The prince regent, in 1814, as a mark
of respect to the memory of the father, sent a handsome sword as
a present to the son. A nephew of Tecumseh and of the prophet,
(their sister's son,) who was highly valued by the Americans, was
slain in their service, in November, 1812, on the northern bank
of the river Miami. Having been brought up by the American
general, Logan, he had adopted that officer's name. He asserted
that Tecumseh had in vain sought to engage him in the war on the
side of the British.