NOTES TO THE LEGENDS
The Confederation of the Iroquois, Page 23.—When the
Europeans discovered North America they found that portion of the
continent lying east of a line about as far west as the city of
Cleveland, Ohio, and from the great lakes on the north to the
Chesapeake Bay on the south, practically under the control of a
confederacy of tribes, to which the French in after years applied the
term Iroquois, and which the English called the Five Nations.
This confederacy was composed of the Senecas, Mohawks, Onondagas,
Oneidas and Cayugas. In the year 1712 the Tuscaroras, a
tribe previously located in North Carolina, were defeated in a war
with their white neighbors, and about one thousand eight hundred
of them fled to what is now New York State, then the actual
dwelling-place of most of the Iroquois, and were adopted into the
confederacy. The new tribe did not possess the energy and courage
of their associates, and for several years after their coming the
men wore the tobacco pouches of the women, thus acknowledging
upon all occasions that they were inferior to the other five nations
comprising the union which had become their protectors. After
the coming of the Tuscaroras the confederacy was known as the
Six Nations of Indians—a designation which is often used at the
present time in law in matters pertaining to the Indians of New
York State.
The date of the formation of this confederacy has never been
settled with any degree of certainty, and all attempts have ended
in mere conjecture and speculation. The most authentic tradition
heretofore published places the date about the year 1589, but there
is no positive proof that this date is accurate. The legend of its
formation here published is not only based upon what was considered
reliable authority by Cornplanter, but has also the sanction
of that other noted Seneca chief, Governor Blacksnake (the Nephew),
who was contemporaneous with Cornplanter, and who was probably
born about the year 1736 and died in 1859, at the supposed
age of one hundred and twenty-three years. These chiefs both
claimed to have seen a string of wampum in their early years that
placed the formation of the confederacy at a time when there
occurred a total eclipse of the sun—"a darkening of the Great
Spirit's smiling face"—that took place when the corn was receiving
its last tillage, long before events that could be reliably ascribed to
the year 1540.
At this point it will be well to say that the Indians possessed
strings of wampum which actually recorded historical events. They
were made upon the skins of some animal and were formed of
small pieces of bone, variously shaped and colored, small stones,
and a variety of small shells, quills and sometimes the teeth or
claws of animals. These were strung upon the tanned skin by
piercing holes through them and tying them securely with sinews.
Certain ones in the tribe were selected as keepers of the wampum
and it was their duty to store all necessary facts in their memory
and associate with them the successive lines and arrangement of the
stones, shells, quills, etc., so that they could be readily called to
mind. At general councils these records were brought before the
people and solemnly expounded. As these people possessed remarkable
memories, the meaning of the wampum string was
accurately carried down from generation to generation.
The place of holding the council that formed the confederacy has
also been the subject of some dispute, but it is pretty certain that
it was near the northern end of either Seneca or Cayuga Lake, and
that it took place in that year previous to 1540 in which occurred
an eclipse of the sun in the month when the corn receives its last
tilling.
Professor Lewis Swift, of the Warner Observatory, Rochester,
kindly furnished the following table of dates:
| Annular Eclipse |
October 11, 1520 |
| Annular Eclipse |
May 8, 1491 |
| Total Eclipse |
July 29, 1478 |
| Total Eclipse |
June 28, 1451 |
| Annular Eclipse |
April 26, 1427 |
The first given, October, 1520, is out of the question, as the
corn would have been harvested at that time of year.
The second, May, 1491, would have been too early in the season
to comply with the conditions of the wampum record, for the corn
would hardly have made its appearance above the ground as early
as the 8th of May.
The third, the last of July, 1478, will not answer the account
given, for the ears of the maize would have been forming at that
time and the plant would have passed its period of tillage.
The fourth date, June 28, 1451, must, therefore, have been the
one upon which the confederation took place, as at that time of
the year the corn in Central New York Is about ready for its final
tilling.
Upon the authority of these two chiefs it is not difficult to believe
that this date is historically correct and that the incident related in
the legend was the occasion upon which this wonderful union of
republics was formed. Considered as a government formed by a
savage people, the confederation of the Iroquois certainly was a
wonderful union. Had it not been broken and destroyed by the
whites after a series of wars extending over two centuries and culminating
in the great village-burning expedition of Sullivan in
1779, this confederacy would have made rapid progress in
civilization.
Among the Five Nations alone can be found the Indian of the
novelist and poet. The Iroquois stand out and above all other
aboriginal inhabitants in their intelligence, their oratory, their friendship
and their character. Had they been treated with fairness;
had they not been made the subjects of the most cruel wrongs and
deceptions; had they not been driven to retaliation and finally to
relentless slaughter, the pages of our histories would doubtless have
recorded of this people achievements of which any nation might be
proud.
A Legend of the River, Page 47.—This story was told of the
Genesee River and Falls, and is occasionally heard among the older
Senecas at the present time. It is said that one family of the Senecas
were very much opposed to signing the treaty that surrendered
the territory surrounding the scene of this legend. They claimed
to be descendants of Tonadahwa and her brave rescuer, and believed
that the spirits of their dead ancestors often visited the scene
of their adventure and upon this spot plighted anew their troth.
There is little doubt that this story, in the main, is true, and that a
young Indian and a maiden, whom he was trying to rescue from a
warrior of another tribe, were almost miraculously preserved alive
after being carried over the Genesee Falls in a canoe. This legend
has been put forth in various ways, one of which was that the
Indians living near Niagara Falls were accustomed to sacrifice annually
to the spirit of the Falls by sending the fairest maiden of the
tribe over the precipice in a white birch canoe, decked with fruits
and flowers. Frequently male relatives or lovers are said to have
accompanied or followed victims who were set apart for this sacrifice.
If this is so it must have been a practice of some other tribe
than those composing the Iroquois, for the Iroquoian tribes did not
practice customs which called for the sacrifice of human life, unless
the sacrifice was self-imposed.
Legends of the Corn, Page 51.—Corn, or maize, was the
chief food of the Indians and consequently there were many legends
concerning its origin. The two here given were looked upon as the
oldest. The Indians had a firm belief that it was possible to change
one's form, unless the one desiring the change was unfortunate
enough to be under the influence of some evil spirit that out of
malice prevented the transformation. The Indian women were
especially proud of the legend attributing the origin of the maize to
the frightened maiden fleeing from her lover, and it was told to
their daughters very often and with many extravagant embellishments.
The First Winter, Page 55.—The Indians were taught never
to speak ill of any of the celestial bodies or of the works of nature.
They must never complain of the glare and heat of the sun, lest
they be stricken blind; nor must they complain of the clouds for
fear that they might be shut up in caves in the mountains where no
light could enter. The moon must be treated with the same respect
and consideration, for those who said aught against her were
in imminent danger of death by a fall of rocks from the sky. The
most severe storms of wind, snow, frost or hail must be treated
only with great respect. Those who complained about them were
by this act unarmed and could not resist their attacks and rigors.
In fact, they were taught to "take the bitter with the sweet"
without making wry faces. This training through long generations
rendered the race cold and stoical, apparently indifferent to suffering.
They probably suffered the same as others, but they bore it
without a sign. This legend was a very common one and was
frequently told the young in order that the lesson might be deeply
impressed upon them that they should never set themselves up in
opposition to the Great Spirit or complain of the enforcement of
his laws.
The Story of Oniata, Page 63.—Cornplanter held that there
were many traditions among the Indians that in one way or another
mentioned persons who were described as white; and this, too,
long before the coming of the Europeans. One tradition was to
the effect that thousands of years ago, away off to the southwest,
there was a tribe of Indians in which were born several children
who were made "like the Great Spirit, with faces as the sun."
They were said to be very proud of the distinction and also to have
been great warriors. They were believed to have wandered to the
south and finally to have been lost in the mountains. After the
coming of the Europeans this tradition was revived, and the ever-ready
imagination of the Indians added a sequel to the disappearance
of the "white Indians." They said the whites had gone
across the bitter lake (the ocean) and founded the nations of the
palefaces and were now returning to conquer and subdue their
forefathers. It was Cornplanter's belief that this was the older
continent and that the Indian was nearest the original creation. He
did not believe these traditional white people were as white as the
English. They possessed all the Indian features, he said, but had
light-colored skins and light hair.
Since this volume was made ready for publication the author
found in a Western newspaper an account of the return from New
Mexico of a Mr. Williamson, who had been spending some months
in an out-of-the-way place in that territory among the Moqui
Indians. Mr. Williamson told an interesting story about a family
of that tribe the members of which are white. He saw these
people and asserts there is no doubt as to their color. He also says
they are without doubt pure Indians and that they have none of
the characteristics of the Albinos often seen among the Negroes.
The family is known far and wide among the Indians themselves,
but as their place of residence is some distance from the usual routes
traveled by white men, they are rarely seen by others than the race
to which they belong. The Indians look upon them as something
holier than the rest of the tribe, and hence do not talk about them
to outsiders. The narrator stated that the head man of the family
says that there is a tradition among them that they originally came
from the north and settled among the Moqui people, where they
have been so long that they have lost all knowledge of the northern
tribe and were not certain that they now spoke the language of
their progenitors. When any of the Moqui married into the family,
their children were always white. This discovery, if true and
there seems no reason for such a statement unless it be true is
interesting in this connection and may be looked upon by some
as a proof of the claim that about the year A. D. 400 a race of
white people occupied the territory bordering the southern shores
of the great lakes, and that they were driven away by red men
who came from still further north. Of course this is speculation
and will probably remain a mystery as long as the world stands.
The Buzzard's Covering, Page 77.—This legend regarding
the buzzard's plumage was often told by the Indians to illustrate
the failure of some one of their number to win success in marriage
or upon the chase. "We wear the turkey buzzard's feathers,"
said one of the Sioux chiefs a few years ago when making complaint
to a Congressional committee. Few of those who heard him understood
the metaphor and the supposition was that he referred to the
plainness of his clothing compared with that of the politicians who
met him. This expression coming from a Sioux chief proves that
at least some of the legends common among the Iroquois centuries
ago can be traced among the tribes of the West at the present
time. A white man to convey the same meaning would say, "We
have the worst end of the bargain," or, "We have only a crooked
stick at last."
Origin of the Violet, Page 81.—The Indian term for the
violet is "heads entangled." This is not one of the legends told
by Cornplanter. It was told the author by a Seneca Indian named
Simon Blackchief. Afterwards the authenticity of the legend was
confirmed by inquiries among other members of the Seneca Nation.
The Turtle Clan, Page 85.—Of the various clans existing
among the Iroquois the Turtle was probably the most respected.
The families belonging to the Turtles were in reality the Freemasons
of those days and to them were accorded the highest honors. At
the council-fires the wisdom of the Turtles was displayed in counselling
unity of action. Their opinions were almost always accepted
without discussion.
The Healing Waters, Page 89.—The Indians possessed for
many years a knowledge of the curative properties of the mineral
springs of this country and held the waters in the highest veneration.
Their faith in them was so great that some did not hesitate
to declare that the waters would cure all ills. Another spring that
they held in high reverence was an oil spring situated in Allegany
County, New York State, near the Pennsylvania line. The water
of this spring is covered with a thick substance that was formerly
collected by the Indians by conducting the water into pools and
skimming the surface with flat stones or the branches of trees. The
oil thus collected was used to mix with various substances to form
war-paint, but more especially as a healing salve for various
wounds. The Indians knew of its existence for many centuries,
and there were few days in summer when bands of Indians were
not in that vicinity gathering the oil, which they evaporated by
exposure to the sun and then stored in raw-hide or earthen vessels
for future use. Years ago the spring and a plot of ground one mile
square was set aside as a reservation, and it is still held as such. A
curious fact in this connection is that the oil from the spring was
vaseline in its crude state, and the same substance is now extensively
secured from petroleum oil wells in that vicinity.
The Message Bearers, Page 119.—The belief of the Indians
that the echoes they heard among the mountains and forests were
spirits who repeated from one to another the words spoken by the
men and women until the words reached Heaven itself, is almost
too beautiful to be destroyed by the cold facts of science. There
is something about their theory that appeals very strongly to all
and makes us wish that we, like the Indians of a thousand years
ago, could believe that our prayers, if spoken boldly, would be
caught from our lips by waiting and listening spirits and carried to
"the tent of the Great Spirit."
It was customary for them to frequent rivers with high wooded
banks, or to seek ravines with precipitous sides where reverberations
could be heard for miles, until they would die away in the
distance. Here they would stand for hours, shouting and listening
as the echoing shouts leaped from shore to shore, or from hill to
mountain and from mountain to valley—on and on into silence;
always firmly believing that the words were called from one to
another of the faithful spirits until they reached the ears of their
loved ones and finally the Great Spirit himself. This custom was
practiced among the Senecas less than one hundred years ago, and
there are now living men who have been present on occasions
when nearly the whole tribe participated in an event of this character.
This belief was doubtless the origin of the "death shout"
that Indian warriors are said to make when mortally wounded upon
the battle field. The cry is sent forth by the dying warrior to let
the friends whom he would meet in heaven know that he has
started on the long journey.
The Hunter, Page 129.—This legend is one of the many relating
the origin of the "medicine compound." When the rejoicing
over the return to life of Kanistagia had ceased, the bear and fox
took him aside and imparted the secret of the mysterious compound
which had mended his wounded head when once the scalp
had been restored. There has always been a great deal of mystery,
and something of superstition, concerning, "Indian medicines," and
quack nostrums have been eagerly sought by people of these later
years simply because they were labeled with Indian names and
ascribed to Indian origin. The fact is the Indians were poor doctors.
They knew the virtue of catnip, peppermint, pennyroyal,
and a few simple herbs of like nature. They knew that lobelia
would act as an emetic and throw poisons from the stomach.
They found that a salve made from the inner bark of the slippery
elm and elder would heal wounds. While they had an infinite
variety of so-called "medicines," their cures were generally effected
through faith and good constitutions, aided by a liberal use of cold
water. They lived out of doors during the greater part of their lives,
and to this, more than to their knowledge of cures, may be
ascribed their longevity.
The secret of their "great medicine" was imparted to but few,
and the formula here given was told the author by one of the older
Jimmersons, a resident of the Seneca Reservation: Each year before
the coming of the frosts a meeting of the chiefs was held in one of
the largest wigwams. Those entitled to attend could not enter the
wigwam before dark. Each one brought with him several of the
rarest herbs, roots, branches of trees or fruits of which he had
knowledge, and often hundreds of miles had been traversed in the
search for some particularly scarce product. These, with a few
simple, fragrant herbs and a certain proportion of dry corn and
beans, were pounded into a pulpy mass. Each one present
assumed the character of some bird or animal, and they often
masqueraded to carry out the role. No words passed between
them, but a continual din was kept up as each one sounded the
cries of the bird or animal he represented. One would bark like a
fox, another caw like a crow, a third would growl like a bear, the
fourth, fifth and sixth chatter like squirrels, raccoons or ground-hogs.
Another would scream like a hawk, while others would
imitate the wild turkey, geese, ducks, etc. They worked rapidly,
for they must complete their task before the break of day. If one
closed his eyes in sleep, it was a sure sign that the plague would
come upon the tribe. At daylight the compound was divided,
carefully bestowed in panther skin pouches, and carried away for
future use.
The manner of administering it was as curious as its manufacture.
Water was dipped from a running stream in a wooden vessel.
Care was taken to dip with the current—never against it. When
the water in the vessel had become absolutely quiet, three small
portions of the powder were carefully dropped on its surface in the
form of a triangle. If the powder spread over the surface of the
water, as dust often will, the patient hastily gulped down the dose
and got well. If the powder sank to the bottom without spreading
over the surface, the medicine man quickly departed with his
potion and no further effort was made to save the patient's life.
Hiawatha, Page 137.—This version of Hiawatha follows as
closely as it is possible to translate into English the legend as told
by Governor Blacksnake (The Nephew). This aged Seneca chief
was contemporaneous with Cornplanter, and died December 26,
1859, at the age of 117 or 120 years. He was a very intelligent
man, possessing all the nobler traits of his race and very few, if
any, of the baser ones. He possessed the confidence and esteem
of Washington, and to the day of his death wore upon a thong
around his neck a silver medal given him by Washington. He also
constantly carried a little leathern pouch containing a pass written
and signed by Washington's own hand.
It is believed that many will be pleased to read in prose the
beautiful story that Longfellow has immortalized in verse, and into
which he wove many other curious legends to make the story
complete. The form of the tradition here given is believed to be
the purest one extant. Its narrator repeated it frequently to
assemblages of the Senecas up to a few months prior to his
death, and as here given follows the story precisely as it came from
Blacksnake's own lips.
This legendary account of the formation of the confederacy of
the Iroquois differs materially from the historical account as given
by Cornplanter. The story of Hiawatha was believed by Cornplanter
as implicitly as any Christian believes the Bible. But he
said this happened so many years ago, when everything was
spiritual and supernatural, that the Five Nations in time came to
look upon it as something that was not binding upon them. By
degrees they drifted away and were estranged, and the council-fire
combined and lighted by Hiawatha at that time was permitted to
go out—that is, each tribe held its separate council. After the
second reunion of the tribes (see note and legend "The Confederation
of the Iroquois") the council was again established at Onondaga,
and the great council-fire was relighted on the spot hallowed
by the presence of their wisest leader. It is also interesting to note
that the councils of the Iroquois were held at Onondaga until January
18, 1777. In the War of the Revolution the Mohawks,
Onondagas, Senecas and Cayugas favored the English. The Mohawks
went to Canada and never returned, save as foes, till after
peace was declared, and the other tribes named lent the English
much assistance. The Oneidas and Tuscaroras remained neutral,
but really aided the Colonists. On the 19th of January, 1777, a
delegation of Oneida Indians visited Fort Stanwix (now Rome),
and told the commanding officer that the council-fire of the Iroquois
at Onondaga had the previous day been extinguished for all time.
What was probably the oldest confederacy in the world died in the
very infancy of American Independence.
The Peacemaker, Page 149.—The location of this "City of
Refuge" will, of course, never be known, and all that can be said
about it must be simply speculation. It seems reasonable to suppose
that it was located in a somewhat central position; where it
would be most convenient to all the tribes. From the fact that
Genetaska and her lover went southward to a river and took a
canoe to complete their wedding trip, it is believed that Kienuka
was situated in one of the three valleys in the central part of the
State of New York, drained respectively by the Tioughnioga, the
Chenango or the Unadilla rivers. The eloping couple are said to
have been the progenitors of a very intelligent tribe on Chesapeake
Bay, and probably reached their home by way of the Susquehanna
River. Elias Johnson, a Tuscarora Indian, gives a somewhat different
version of this legend, and says that Kienuka was located four
miles eastward of the inlet of the Niagara gorge at Lewiston.
Although Mr. Johnson is possessed of much information as to the
early legends of his people, it is probable that he has erred in the
location of the peace-home. The location he points out would
have been manifestly unfair to the Mohawks and Oneidas, and, indeed,
it would have been very difficult of access to all the tribes,
for even the Senecas (the westernmost tribe) would have had to
make a journey of nearly a hundred miles to have gotten within
the sacred walls.
Wherever it was, Kienuka was a veritable "City of Refuge."
Its queen was chosen as indicated in the legend and her word became
law. There was absolutely no appeal from it. With three
or four retainers, who must be old women, she was supported by
all the tribes, and great quantities of food were stored at the retreat
for the relief of those who came there in distress. This must be
ready at all times for those who might be in want. Disputes were
not tolerated in the presence of the Peacemaker and would have
been punished by death if reported to the council. Every one who
reached the charmed circle was safe from molestation until the
Peacemaker had delivered her sentence. If for some offence the
refugee should be adjudged guilty of a crime punishable by death,
he must be taken far from the peace-home before the sentence
could be executed, for the shedding of blood within its pale was
strictly forbidden. For this reason, when deserted by Genetaska,
whose vows were forgotten in the love she bore the young Oneida,
Kienuka became the scene of bloodshed, and it was afterwards
shunned, accursed and desolated.
Six hundred years elapsed after the occurrence of this romantic
incident before the office of Queen Peacemaker was again filled.
The shock the Indians felt over the betrayal of such a high trust as
that imposed in Genetaska led them to practically abolish the
venerated custom. In 1878 they bestowed the honor upon Caroline
Parker, a sister of General Eli S. Parker, a former member of
General Grant's staff. She was a resident of the Tuscarora Reservation,
and afterwards became the wife of John Mountpleasant. She
is possessed of a comfortable home and a fortune of moderate size.
She is a woman of education and refinement, and is in all respects
an ideal Peacemaker. Her home is ever open to the poor, distressed
and needy; her heart is moved by pity at every sign of
suffering; her sound judgment and fine sensibilities render her a
most valuable friend and counsellor.
An Unwelcome Visitor, Page 155.—This legend was as common
among the Indians as are the parables of the Prodigal Son or the
Good Samaritan among Christians. It was told to the young very
impressively and often, that they might learn by its teachings never
to refuse welcome and shelter to a stranger, no matter what his
condition, even though he be covered with the awful pustules of
smallpox, with which the visitor in the legend is supposed to have
been suffering. If they should refuse shelter, they might be, unawares,
turning "good medicine" from the door. This is also one
of the legends explaining the origin of the knowledge possessed by
the Indians of the curative properties of plants and roots. Unfortunately
the name of the benefactress of their race who figures in
the legend has been lost, but in all tribes and clans there have
been noted Sagawahs who were supposed to be her descendants.
As no one could enter the Happy Hunting-Grounds except through
the gate of death, the Great Spirit's messenger, who had gone
through much suffering for the welfare of the red men, brought
upon himself the "fatal disease"—consumption—for which the
Indians had no remedy.
Transcriber Notes
Presumed typos were corrected. Hyphenation was standardized. All images
were derived from The Internet Archive and are placed in the Public Domain.