"No, you don't!" I remarked, cheerfully,
and with the force of superior muscles I pulled
him towards me. "Come, sit down here by
me," I said. "I want to talk to you." And
somehow it came about that we subsided on
the cushioned seat together.
He had recognised me, of course, as the man
he had seen in the hotel–the man, Noel Stanton,
against whom I did not doubt his cablegram
had warned him. He was pale as death,
and I could see that this meeting, added, like
the piling of Ossa upon Pelion, on top of
all that he had already gone through, had
robbed him of the shattered remnant of his
nerve.
Still, he was ready to "bluff" and brave if
out while he could. "Confound you!" he exclaimed.
"What are you about? You must
247
be mad to attack a stranger without the slightest
provocation. Let me alone, sir, or I'll rouse
the car."
"I wouldn't, you know, if I were you," I
said coolly, for the more excited he grew the
more did my own calmness come back to me.
"You've been playing a dangerous game ever
since you took your passage in the American
liner St. Paul (or, rather, since Carson Wildred
took it for you), but you've never, perhaps,
steered so close to the wind as to-night,
when you resorted to incendiarism as a finishing
stroke."
The fellow stared at me in simulated nonchalance
and defiance, but my hand was on
his shoulder still, and I could feel the shudder
that ran through his body.
"I say you must be mad," he reiterated.
"So you observed before; but I could very
easily prove to you that I'm not, if you were
not already sure of it. You can call for assistance
if you like, but if you do the story I've
got to tell will go flashing over the wires back
to 'Frisco, and on to Denver, and you will find
248
yourself in almost as hot a place as if you had
stayed at the Santa Anna Hotel, where you
wanted the world to think that poor Harvey
Farnham had been roasted."
Once more the fit of shivering seized him.
He glanced wildly about, as though to find
some means of escape, but there was none.
"I am a bigger man and a stronger man
than you," I remarked, in a significant and reflective
manner. "Better hear the alternative
I've got to offer. I know everything, you see–that
is, everything that concerns you, and
the curious game you've been playing.
"I've been just three days behind you everywhere
since you left New York. I've got
every link in the evidence now, and what with
Bennett, of Denver, and the proprietor of the
Santa Anna Hotel, and a few others, I can
burst your wretched little soap bubble plot in
four-and-twenty hours. There's just one way
in which you can stay my hand."
"What's that?" He had spoken out impulsively,
before he had stopped to think. The
instant the words were uttered he saw all that
249
they admitted, and bit his lip. But it was too
late; he was completely trapped.
"I'll tell you," I said, keeping my hand on
his shoulder, almost caressingly. "I'd listen
attentively, if I were in your place. What you
can do is to make a clean breast of your story
from beginning to end. I'm willing to pay
you more for confessing than Wildred did for
plotting. Then you must go back to England
with me, and stand by while the thing is made
public."
As I spoke he did not once take his eyes
from me. It was remarkable even yet, now
that he was out of his disguise, how strong his
likeness was to Farnham. He might have been
a younger brother.
When I had finished he sighed and drooped
his head. His own hair, which was very closely
cut, was of a beautiful reddish golden colour,
much the shade of Karine Cunningham's, as
the light fell on it from above. I thought of
her with a great wave of passionate love, and
more of hope than I had dared to feel for
many a long day.
250Perhaps it was the recollection of her lovely
face and the wonderful halo of her hair which
caused me for an instant to relax my grasp.
I only became conscious of having done so
when the fellow twisted himself from under
my hand, and springing lithely to his feet
would have darted through the swing door had
I not leaped after him like a tiger.
We fought together as the car swayed and
bounded along its tracks. Once he dived under
my arm and was almost out of my clutches,
but I caught him by the collar with so fierce
a grip that the linen of his shirt tore, and the
garment ripped open to the waistcoat.
Something which he wore beneath snapped,
as he still struggled to escape me, and a bright
object flashed under my eyes as it fell, and
dropped with a slight metallic noise to the
floor.
Evidently it was to him an article of value.
Impulsively he stooped, forgetful for a second
of the object which had animated him, and thus
the advantage became all mine again. I had
him pinioned fast.
251At our feet, I now had time to observe, lay
a broken gold chain and a locket.
Twisting my hand firmly in his collar I bent
over and picked up the ornaments. "Allow
me," I said, smiling. And as I was about to
put the locket in his hand I could not avoid
seeing the portrait that it framed. It was an
open-faced, old-fashioned thing, set round
with a rim of pearls. The crystal had been
cracked across in the fall, but the delicately
painted ivory miniature within was intact, and
I gave a slight exclamation as I saw that it
represented Karine Cunningham.
If I had been surprised to see her picture in
the "studio" at the House by the Lock, I was
doubly surprised to see it in a locket worn by
a young desperado on the other side of the
world. Impulsively I withdrew my hand
which held the ornament, with the feeling that
the man had no right to it–that I could not
return it to him again.
"Give it back to me!" he ejaculated, forgetting
his evident fear of me for the first time,
and speaking with a certain manly fierceness
252
that thawed the chill of my contempt for him.
"If I've got a right to nothing else on earth,
I've got a right to that. It's a portrait of my
sister."
"Your sister! You swear that?"
"Of course I swear it. I don't see why
you shouldn't know it–though I haven't done
much credit to the name of Cunningham."
I could not doubt him. Not that I had not
every reason to believe that he would be willing
to lie as fast as he could speak if it happened
to suit his purpose, but the ring of sincerity in
his voice was unmistakable.
I let go my hold upon him. Such was his
astonishment at the manœuvre that he made
no attempt to take advantage of his freedom,
but simply stood still and stared at me.
"Here is the locket," I said. "I came from
England to California to serve Miss Cunningham's
interests, and I will not lay my hand
upon her brother."
"I don't know what you mean," he said,
sullenly.
"I'll tell you," I returned, "if you'll sit
253
down here and listen to me for a few minutes
longer. After that, as far as I am concerned,
you are free to do as you choose. You look
surprised–but whatever may have been your
faults and your offences, I would stake my life
you love your sister."
"She is the only being on earth I do love,"
he replied, still half dazedly.
Then he sat down, his eyes furtively on me,
and I seated myself beside him.
"She is sacrificing herself for someone," I
remarked. "I think I begin dimly to understand
now who that someone may be. I think,
too, that circumstances have given me the right
to be inquisitive, as I can still further explain
to you later on. Is Miss Cunningham going
to marry Carson Wildred to save you from
any unpleasant consequences of the past, for
instance?"
He started as though he had been struck.
"She is not going to marry Carson Wildred!"
he exclaimed.
"Oh, yes, she is, unless it can be prevented.
I see I have even more to tell you than I
254
thought. Is it long, may I ask, since you have
seen your sister?"
"Last November," he said drooping his
head, and bringing under my eyes again the
hair that was like hers.
"Ah, that explains your ignorance. The
man had not shown his hand at that time.
Now I am going to trust to your affection for
Miss Cunningham, to your presumable wish to
save her from unhappiness, and talk to you
as though we had been allies instead of enemies.
Perhaps I may be a fool for my pains; but
something seems to say to me―"
"Something says right. Go on!" he ejaculated,
gruffly.
No doubt the very most dunder-headed of
lawyers or detectives would have told me that
I was mad, thus deliberately to give all my
good trumps away to the treacherous, hired
scoundrel whom I had been hunting down with
the dogged ferocity of a bloodhound. On
principle, of course, I was all wrong, and I
knew it; but still I went on.
I told him the strange story of the past few
255
weeks from beginning to end. I commenced
with the part which concerned Farnham and
Carson Wildred alone. I did not pass over
that which had to do with Karine, my hopeless
and unrequited love for her, my passionate
anxiety to serve her at all costs; and I ended
by declaring my certainty that Carson Wildred
and Willis Collins were one and the same man.
"He is doubly a murderer," I said. "And
yet, unless you and I together can keep him
from it, he will be your sister's husband."
"I'll kill him first!" exclaimed my companion.
"I think the trick can be done without resorting
to such extreme measures as that," I returned,
"especially if you are willing to come
over from his camp to mine."
He looked at me sharply for a moment without
answering, then he said:
"You seem pretty quick, I've noticed, in
what you've just been telling me at putting
two and two together. Well, you say you were
at the Santa Anna Hotel the night the murder
was committed ten years ago. You knew
256
there were two men mixed up in it. You remembered
one of them; would you remember
the other?"
"He was a mere boy," I said, "and it's a
long time ago. He must have changed almost
beyond recognition."
"He's just twenty-nine at present; I've
good reason to know, as I'm he."
It was my turn to be astonished, but it was
not policy to show it. Therefore I merely said,
"Oh, indeed!"
"You see," he went on dully, "that's where
Wildred has had his pull over me since he ran
across me, by a piece of devil's own luck, in
Canada five years ago. As you say, I have
changed; but his eyes are like gimlets, they'd
pierce a stone wall. It's quite true, as you suspected,
that he and Collins are one. I knew
him by a queer scar on his hand, shaped like a
star–perhaps you've observed it? But he
didn't mind. He seemed even to find a sort
of pleasure in telling me how he had been to a
clever fellow in Paris, and got himself made
over into another man, so that he might the
257
more easily turn his back upon various little
episodes of the past. I couldn't have proved
it if I'd wanted to, he was so different, and had
worked up such a new record for himself to
travel on. He knew that, and he knew, too,
that I was in his power."
"I don't exactly see how that came about,"
I objected.
"Don't you? You're not so quick as usual,
then. I'd been accused of the murder at the
Santa Anna Hotel. I hooked it, and got over
to Mexico, so to Spain and France. I'd always
been a black sheep, you know, but that was
the first really serious trouble I'd got into.
However, as I said, five years later, when Wildred
and I met, I was in Canada; I'd turned
actor (I'd always a little talent that way), and
was doing pretty well. He pointed out to me–and
I wasn't very long in seeing his point–that
I was not so much changed but what I
should easily be recognised by those who had
known me during those wild days when I'd
been under his thumb in San Francisco, and
the authorities there would still be very glad
258
to hear of me. He didn't happen to want anything
of me just then, but he allowed me to
understand that it was to my interest to keep
sweet with him. And from that day to this
he's had his eye on me."
"But it was he who was accused of that
murder, not you," I said.
"What!"
The man seemed either not to believe or
understand me.
I repeated the statement, and then, when
he stammered his astonishment, his ignorance
of all that had taken place in San Francisco
after his escape (at which we had all tacitly
connived at the time), I went on to explain
the true circumstances of the case. Carson
Wildred had deceived him into the belief that
he alone had been suspected–that if he were
caught he would be promptly hanged.
"He has told the same story to your sister,
I would swear!" I exclaimed, hotly. "It is
for this reason that she has been persuaded into
promising to marry him. Believing that he
knows your whereabouts, and holds it in his
259
power at any moment to have you punished as
a murderer–believing, too, no doubt, that you
did commit the murder, she has been ready to
save your life by the sacrifice of all that has
made hers dear."
"Curse him! I'd take my oath you're
right!" he asseverated. "He's sly enough and
vile enough for anything."
"Did you ever see Harvey Farnham?" I
questioned.
"Yes, years ago I knew him well, and liked
him immensely–as he did me, I think. It was
in Tuolumne County, California, where he had
a gold mine–the Miss Cunningham. It was
I who named that, oddly enough it may seem
to you, after my sister, of course. He wasn't
aware of that, but thought it was just a whim
of mine, that probably I'd admired some girl
called 'Miss Cunningham,' and wanted to pay
her a compliment. You see, no one knew me
by my right name even then.
"It was before that hateful time when I got
in with Collins, or Wildred, whichever you like
to call him, and not long after I'd run away
260
from home and England under the assumed
name of Hartley–it was my mother's maiden
name. I was only seventeen or eighteen, but
I was pretty sharp for my years, I'm afraid,
for I'd been among a queer lot already, and
one night I would have got into a row with
some older man over cards, a row that might
have ended badly if it hadn't been for Mr.
Farnham, who had dropped into the place to
look on, and who stood by me for all he was
worth.
"It seemed he noticed me the moment he
entered the room, thinking that I looked
enough like him to be his own son. Afterward
he took me up, making a lot of me, wanting
to find out where I'd come from, and all
that. He thought my resemblance to him
(which everyone who saw us together invariably
remarked) a wonderful joke, and used
to call me his 'boy,' and 'sonny,' getting it into
his head that I was a sort of 'Mascot,' who
brought luck to him in whatever he undertook.
That was the principal reason, of course, that
he was so keen on having me name his mine for
261
him. I think if I had sowed all my wild oats,
and been willing to settle down a bit into a respectable
member of society, there was a time
when he wouldn't have minded adopting me,
for some old, unhappy love affair or other had
kept him out of the marriage-market, eligible
as he was, and he swore that he never meant
to marry, even for the hope of having an heir
to all his money. Yes, I might have been that
heir if I hadn't been a fool, for Farnham certainly
thought the world and all of me in those
days. As it was, he did me many a kindness."
"And now, by way of repaying that affection
and those kindnesses," I could not help exclaiming,
with a returning touch of the old
bitter contempt, "you've undertaken to help
his murderer to get off scot free. You've been
masquerading in the very clothes the poor fellow
wore, you've been using his luggage, trading
on the likeness to him which once won for
you his regard, heightening it in every way
by artificial means, so that not only shall Carson
Wildred, or Willis Collins, escape suspicion,
but that he may enrich himself on the
262
dead man's millions. You even set an hotel
on fire to finish the whole fiendish plot with a
fine dramatic effect!"
The poor wretch, who had made such a wreck
of his young life, was white as death, and shaking
like an aspen. I could see the beads of
sweat oozing out on his pale forehead. "For
God's sake," he implored, "don't say that to
me; I can't bear it! Until you told me just
now I swear to you by all I hold sacred–by
my sister's love, which I so little deserve–that
I never dreamed of Harvey Farnham's being
dead. You may believe me or not, as you like,
but you're her friend, so I should be glad that
you should believe. And, at least, you owe it
to me in common justice to hear what I've got
to say.
"Collins always managed to keep his eye
on me, and knew my whereabouts and my doings,
making me feel that at any moment he
could come down on me if he chose. I daresay
he had other men in his power like that, men
whom he thought he might wish to make his
tools at one time or other. I didn't often hear
263
from him, though I knew myself shadowed,
and knew also, only too well, whom I had to
thank for it. You can't guess the horror of
the feeling, or how it got on my nerves. I
fancied it would drive me to madness or suicide
one day, always knowing I was watched,
that I could never, try as I would, escape that
Eye, which was really Willis Collins's, spying
me out across the ocean.
"Well, a cablegram came from him commanding
rather than asking me to go to England,
saying that it would be much to my
advantage to do so, and that my fare and all
expenses would at once be sent me in advance.
There was just a hint that I had better not refuse,
which I understood as well as if it had
been a definite threat; and, anyhow, there was
a certain attractiveness in the idea of going
home–I hadn't seen Karine or England for
so long.
"I didn't mean to let my sister know of my
presence–I would have spared her that–but
I fancied myself standing among the crowd
in the Park, watching her drive by, or something
264
of that sort. Even a glimpse of her face
would have been sweet.
"But when I arrived one of the first things
Wildred did was to tell me that he knew the
Tressidys, with whom Karine was living, that
he had heard my sister often speak of me, and
that he would secretly arrange a meeting between
us. I couldn't resist the temptation of
having a few words with her when it was offered
for the asking, and I saw her at the
House by the Lock. An excuse was made to
bring her and Lady Tressidy there–something
about a portrait of Karine that was in a queer
room called the 'studio'–and while Wildred
was showing Lady Tressidy over the house I
saw my sister, and had a talk with her. She
felt grateful to Wildred for bringing it about,
and fool that I was, I didn't suspect the deep
game he meant to play with her, using me as
the decoy. I thought he had merely been willing
to take the trouble that he might get the
more work out of me when he wanted it,
though what the work was for which he had
brought me to England I didn't yet know.
265"After that first meeting with Karine I had
given Wildred my word never to try and see
her again; now I understand why. He wished
to revive all the old love she had felt by the
sight of me, awaken her sympathy for my
troubles, when she should learn his version of
them from his lips, and then keep me from her,
lest I should hear that he had asked her to be
his wife, threatening to betray me if she did
not accept, and so, in spite of my cowardice
(for I am a moral coward), setting me against
him, to be his slave and tool no more.
"When I had been in England about three
or four weeks, keeping out of the way of anyone
who might possibly remember me, Wildred
suggested the scheme of my travelling back to
America, impersonating Farnham, and finally
finishing the plot, as I did finish it to-night.
He admitted that it was for this he had sent
for me, but swore Farnham himself was in the
thing as deep as he; that it meant a fortune to
them both, which they were to share, and which
could be had in no other way. He explained
that Farnham had had bad luck in speculations,
266
was bankrupt, hadn't the pluck to begin
over again on the lowest rounds of the ladder,
nor to undertake carrying out this plan himself.
He would funk the fire business, Wildred
said, and might, instead of escaping,
actually be burned to death. The object to be
gained, of course, I was made to believe, was
getting the life assurance. Farnham was supposed
to have several policies, each one for an
enormous sum; he had left everything of which
he should die possessed, life assurance and all
the rest, to Wildred, who would actually go
halves with Farnham when the money should
be secured.
"I have nothing of my own, you know, except
what I can make by my wits, for my
father disinherited me, and I've had just a
little too much pride ever to take anything
from Karine. Wildred offered me ten thousand
pounds to work this business for him;
half to be paid down, half when the thing had
been successfully carried through to the close.
"Of course, I had sense enough to know it
was a villainous fraud, but I've never been very
267
scrupulous, and it was easy to persuade myself
that I owed Harvey Farnham a good turn
for what he did for me in the past. Besides,
I wanted the money, and there was five thousand
in notes (Wildred was too sly to give a
cheque) on the table for me to take or leave.
I didn't see that I was going to do much harm
to anybody except the insurance companies,
who are rich enough to lose, as Farnham hadn't
a relative in the world; but before heaven, if
I'd dreamed of the truth, I'd have let Wildred
do his worst before I'd have gone in with him.
"As for the Santa Anna, I knew that every
board of the hotel was assured–the landlord
would lose nothing, and after I'd kindled the
fire I knocked like mad on your door. I fancy,
though you didn't know it, it must have been
that which first began to rouse you. I didn't
give myself much time to get out, after taking
off the disguise (which I flatter myself I did
pretty well), but I just managed it. I can tell
you I was desperate when I walked in here
and found you; but now I was never so thankful
for anything in the course of my life."
268"The present question is, then," I said,
"whether you will go straight to England with
me and tell all you know about Carson Wildred?
If we stopped on this side, to prove
things step by step as we went, we should
labour under two disadvantages. It would
mean indefinite delay, and you would get into
trouble about that business at the hotel to-night.
To sail at once for England, and let
matters here take care of themselves for the
present, is our only plan, I think. What do
you say?"
"You are sure that Wildred can't swear my
life away?"
"As sure as I am that we are both alive at
this moment."
"Then I'm in your hands. I'll save my sister,
and I'll get even with Wildred for making
a tool and a dupe of me."
"By the time we have landed on the other
side," I answered, "there'll still be a clear fortnight
to do the first, and I think we may
accomplish the latter transaction simultaneously."