There are characters in this story of Comito's
of whom he never got a glimpse until the case
came to trial. There are still others involved of
whom he never even heard; in fact, not a few
big fish are in the net of the Secret Service whose
names will probably never be revealed to the
public. This circumstance does not prevent me,
however, from surrounding Comito's statement
with certain additional facts that may serve to
illuminate the plan followed by Lupo and
Morello in building up their sinister organization.
It often happens that disputes occur among
the different elements of the Italian criminals
in New York City and in other parts of this
country. For instance, the Neapolitan element
deals almost exclusively in the traffic of women.
Sometimes this business is invaded by a hostile
group from among the Sicilian element. Invariably
quarrels result and the disputes nearly
always end in a shooting or a stabbing affair.
It is well known to the Service that the quarrels
of the Italian criminals among themselves
are settled without the help of the police whenever
this is at all possible. When a gang member
is wounded, secrecy requires that no ambulance
be called or a doctor summoned who
is not a friend of the gang. This precaution is
easily appreciated when one comes to think that
a call for an ambulance would require the presence
of a policeman and a public report being
made of the affair. Again, should a doctor, who
is not known to the gang, be called in, he is required
to make a record of the occurrence and
report any suspicious injury to the police. If
there is a death the coroner must needs be notified.
To avoid entanglement and trouble with
the authorities the various gangs have impressed
in their service a physician or two who may be
relied upon to bind up the wounds and keep
the affair a secret. Many murders are in this
way covered up and escape the attention of the
police and the public.
There was a man at the trial of the counterfeiters
who was unknown to Comito. Upon this
man's testimony Morello expected to prove that
he was ill in the house during the period that
he was actually out and around and very active
in the counterfeiting scheme.
Dr. Salvatore Romano is the man. The doctor
perjured himself and testified to please Morello,
whose vengeance he feared.
After being indicted by the Federal Grand
Jury, we were able to get a statement from Dr.
Romano. Incidentally this statement disclosed
the method whereby Morello and Lupo gathered
their first money by sending "Black-Hand" letters
to countrymen who were suspected of having
money, or who could in any way be coerced
into being useful to the gang.
Dr. Romano's cross-examination follows:
Q. Tell us, doctor, from the beginning, how
you happened to get mixed up; start from the
time you knew Mr. Morello.
A. I met him in this country. He was living
in East One Hundred and Seventh Street;
we were living at East One Hundred and Sixth
Street. He comes from the same town that my
grandmother and mother hail from in Sicily—Corleone—and
while I was studying in my third
year at the College of Physicians and Surgeons
at Columbia, my folks received a letter from a
"Black-Hand" Society.
Q. Who received it?
A. My mother.
Q. She knew Morello how long previous to
this?
A. She had known him on the other side;
never had anything to do with him here.
Q. About when was it she got this "Black-Hand"
letter?
A. Seven years ago; I was a third-year student
in the College of Physicians and Surgeons.
Q. What was the substance of the letter?
A. The substance of the letter was that unless
a certain amount of money was paid they
would kill me. Naturally, my folks did not tell
me anything at all about it for fear that I would
get excited, neglect my studies, and so fail in
my examinations. The folks kept the thing
quiet for a few days. The "Black-Handers"
also said that if anything were told to the police
authorities, the murder would take place anyway—money
or no money. You see, my father was
not here. I was a young man, my brother was
a small boy, and my family did not know what
to do at the time. My grandmother, though,
knew this man Morello to be mixed up with people
of questionable character, and so she went
to him or he happened to meet her (I don't know
which); anyway, she confided the thing to Morello.
He said, "All right, don't get excited;
they don't kill people off all at once. Wait until
you get another letter. Then we will see if
we can find out the party who writes those letters."
Finally, another letter was written. Then a
third, and a fourth letter came. Morello always
took the letters under the pretext of studying
the handwriting and to find out the origin of
the letter. Eventually, he found out the origin
of the letter, he said and—
Q. What was the origin?
A. Never found out. He just said that he
had found out that they were willing to settle
for $1,000, but that he would pay $100 and that
he would make sure they returned the money
to him after they found out who he was; he said
that we need not worry any more.
Q. Did you pay the $100?
A. No. Morello offered to pay the $100
himself and expected to get it back. He said:
"I will pay and see that they return it to me."
Q. Who would return it?
A. Those people would return the money
again to him.
Q. He said that he would pay the money
and that he would get it back from the Black-Handers?
A. Yes. Then the whole thing quieted down
and naturally my people thought they were under
obligations to this man Morello. And then
when the danger was over my folks told me
about it and remarked about what a terrible thing
we had escaped.
About three or four months later, Morello
came around and said to my mother:
Q. Did you hear him?
A. No. She told me.
(Continuing) "I have a notion to get married.
I'm in with a woman who has a baby as
the result of our relations. Now that I want
to get married, I want to break off this relation,
and if it is not inconvenient to you I would
like to bring this baby, this little girl, to your
house until everything is arranged."
Q. That is the illegitimate child?
A. She could walk; was over one year old.
Q. Who was the woman?
A. I do not know.
Q. At that time he lived on Chrystie Street?
A. No. I understand he had a restaurant.
Of course, my folks said that it was no trouble
for them. There were three or four women in
the household, and it would be no trouble for
them to take care of the little child.
Q. All the time you thought that you were
under obligations to him?
A. Yes; just for that thing.
Q. Don't you know who the woman was?
A. No; never saw her.
Q. Sure you didn't?
A. No.
Q. Do you know her?
A. No, she was a Sicilian. I don't know her
personally.
Q. Is she living?
A. I imagine she is.
Q. What was her name? What was she
called?
A. Didn't know at all. Probably my grandmother
would know.
Q. Was this after or before the barrel murder?
A. I think the barrel murder was after that.
Q. He lived on Chrystie Street at that time?
A. Yes. And so the baby was brought to
our house and we took care of it, a nice little
baby. Nothing happened at all—no disturbance.
They came around to our house about once a
week to see the baby. I kept on studying;
never bothered my head about anything at all.
I went out early in the morning and came back
late; never bothered much with the affairs of
the family. That baby died. First it got the
measles, then bronchial pneumonia. It was a
little over two years old when it died.
Q. Did Morello marry this woman?
A. The woman he married is his present wife.
He had got her from the other side. The sister
(Morello's) had gone to the other side and
arranged for this marriage. So nothing happened
until after I was graduated. Then these
people began to call on me as a doctor.
Q. He then lived in East One Hundred and
Seventh Street?
A. I think in East One Hundred and Seventh
Street, and he began to call on me; and
then the brother-in-law and then cousin, etc.,
called.
Q. Who is his brother-in-law?
A. He has three brothers-in-law, Lupo,
Lima and Salima.
Q. Which one of his brothers-in-law did you
treat?
A. I treated all three of them.
Q. Are Lima and Salima in this country
now?
A. Yes, in New York City.
Q. And did you treat other relatives?
A. I treated all their relatives, and all free
of charge. They would call me; I would examine
them, prescribe, etc., but I got no pay.
Q. Did you ever ask them for any?
A. No.
Q. Why not?
A. On account of the obligations; also the
familiarity. Right from the start I thought that
I was doing a wise thing not to ask for money
for my services.
Q. What did you know about Morello about
that time?
A. My folks had told him all about those letters
and he had fixed it all up; we had no disturbance
because we were under his protection.
Q. Did you know that you were under his
protection?
A. I knew as well as the family did.
Q. What protection did you think that he
could give you?
A. Receiving no disturbance from the "Black-Handers."
Q. Did you know that he was connected with
the "Black-Handers" then?
A. I did not know that he was a "Black-Hander,"
but I knew from the fact that he had
arranged everything that he must have known
something about these people.
Thus I became the regular physician for these
people and never got any pay. In the meantime
I tried to get as much hospital experience
as I could and get out of New York, because,
if a man goes out of New York to a strange
place without any experience—
Q. Why did you want to leave New York?
A. Not because I was afraid, not because
they were doing anything to me, but because I
was tired of doing work for nothing; I never
could put any money in the bank.
The whole number of relatives, babies and
patients, amounted to about sixty. It would not
be one day, but the next day, and all the time
they were on my hands. And I got no pay.
My mother was in the same position. My
mother is a midwife. I tried to get hospital experience,
and as soon as I was in the position
to leave New York I departed, and I have never
heard from him at all except when I received
letters from my mother who told me that they
kept on frequenting the house.
Q. What was the interview you had with
Commissioner Wood?[5]
And when did you have
that interview?
A. That was four or five years before I left
New York. The main thing he wanted to know
was whether I knew these people well enough
to tell stories. Whether I could tell him that
these people were "Black-Handers"?
I had read in the newspapers that they had
been in trouble with the law; but they had treated
me fairly well and I said nothing against these
people. Commissioner Wood wanted to know
about these letters, and naturally I did not
tell.
Q. Did you treat Cecala?
A. No, I never treated him.
Q. Did you ever treat any of the defendants
besides Morello?
A. No. Lupo, Morello and Palermo. Palermo
was operated on for something. At the
time I was called in to give the ether.
Q. What was Morello's business after he
gave up the grocery?
A. Real estate; then they started the real
estate deal, the Ignatz Florio Association. The
way they worked that was—I don't know how
many got together, about nine or ten, and they
started in by building a house and selling it—they
said, "We will build a house and sell it and
in that way there will be a big profit and from
that profit we get dividends." They got people
to buy shares; the shares were payable, I think,
$5 down and $2 per month. So they came to
my mother and she bought one share for herself,
one in the name of my brother, and one in my
name. When they got enough money they
bought a lot, built a house and sold it, and got a
dividend of 40 per cent. You could then either
take the dividend, and put the money in your
pocket, or leave it and it would go on the share.
So most of the people left their money to go to
their credit.
Q. Who got the money?
A. They claimed there was a big boom in
real estate and they made another deal; they
got 35 or 30 per cent. dividend. Then they
started to build eight tenement houses, four on
One Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street and
four on One Hundred and Thirty-eighth Street,
near Cyprus Avenue.
At the time they were building, the crash came.
They took advantage of the prices and said,
"We have not enough money to keep on; the
shareholders will have to come together and pay
more money on each share."
I paid $10 extra on each share. At that time
my mother had acquired eight shares. She had
bought another for herself. Then my cousin
had bought two for herself, which she did not
want to keep, so my mother told her she would
buy them from her.
Q. Did Morello know anything about your
going to see Commissioner Wood; did you tell
him?
A. Yes. I—
Q. What did you tell him?
A. I said that Commissioner Wood, when he
found out that I would not give the information
he wanted, said that I was just like the rest
of them and then told me that I might go.
Q. Did you tell Morello before you went
down?
A. No.
Q. What did Morello say when you told him
that you had been down there?
A. He said that is the way you have to do
everything.
Q. What do you know about the barrel murder?
A. Absolutely nothing at all.
Q. What do you know about Inzarillo?
A. He is considered of questionable character.
Q. Do you know the Terranova Brothers?
A. They are the stepbrothers of Morello.
Q. Do you know anything about them? Did
you treat them?
A. Yes, quite a long while; they had a disease
which required that they come to my house
every day, both Morello and the Terranovas.
Q. When was that?
A. That went on for about two years.
Q. What two years?
A. The two years just preceding 1907 and
1908.
Q. Was Morello born with that deformed
hand?
A. Yes. He was so much crippled that they
called him "Little Finger."
Q. Then you did not treat Morello in 1909?
A. At the time that I stated I did see him
at No. 107 East One Hundred and Thirty-eighth
Street; also, I saw him in Rizzo's house,
and he would complain of pains; he was always
complaining.
Q. He was not sick in bed?
A. No.
Q. You did not have any consultation with
Dr. Brancato?
A. No. I think that I may have had one
consultation with him when he was at One Hundred
and Thirty-eighth Street.
Q. When?
A. I think it was before the time I covered.
I think it was in December, 1908, also.
Q. That means January and February?
A. No.
Q. He was not treating Morello?
A. He was the family physician in a way.
Q. What do you think of him?
A. Dr. Brancato? I want to state the fact
as honestly as if he were my brother. I think
he was a figurehead, too.
Q. Did he ever say about what he was going
to testify?
A. He said we were up against a bad proposition.
"Let us make our testimony as light as
possible," he said. I asked him how we could
avoid a thing of that kind. They would get us
into trouble and we would have to stand for it.
Q. Who came to you and told you that you
would have to testify?
A. Nobody; but this is the way it was done:
They went to my mother and began to talk to
her.
Q. Who?
A. Mrs. Morello and the mother of Morello
and the brothers of Morello. So they went there
and began to explain that they had got into very
serious trouble. They also said that the only
way—
Q. Who?
A. That he could be possibly saved would be
to produce an alibi. I was to say that he was
not out at any time he was accused of being out.
I was to understand that he was the wrong man
mentioned in court. They explained to my
mother that the police knew that Dr. Romano
had been their physician. It would be only natural
that they call me; I could then testify that
I was treating Morello at the time and he was
unable to get out when, the charges alleged, Morello
was around and doing things in the counterfeiting
plant.
They explained to my mother that there was
no other man that could be called, because no
other man would be trusted. The police knew
I was Morello's physician, they said.
And then my mother asked them not to call
me, that it would be putting me into trouble, and
that I would have to abandon the business I had
started.
They told her that it was an absolute necessity
that I come down from Rochester and testify.
If I did not come, they said, Morello would be
sentenced surely. "Naturally," they said, "we
think if the doctor would come down, Morello
will be free."
So my mother wrote to me. "This is the last
proposition they are going to give you," she said.
"I think you cannot avoid coming down."
Q. She wrote and told you about it? Have
you got that letter?
A. No. Naturally I would not keep a letter
of that kind. I thought the matter over. I
knew the character of the men I had to deal
with. I knew that if I refused and Morello
got a big sentence they would put the whole
thing up to me. I thought of my mother down
here going out and in at night, and I had something
to fear. Probably if it had been for myself
only I would not have considered it; I would
have looked at it differently. It seemed that I
had no alternative in a case of this kind. They
telegraphed me.
Q. Who?
A. The brothers Terranova.
Q. What did they say?
A. Be in New York to-morrow to appear
in Court for the testimony of my brother.
Q. When was that sent to you? When did
you get the telegram? Was it a day or two
before you came down?
A. Yes, but I came down at once. The first
time I came I remained here two days. Not being
called, and not being able to leave my business
for such a long period, I rushed back to
Rochester.
Q. When did you come down again?
A. One week later at the time the detectives
were testifying.
Q. And you came down later? Did you go
to your mother's house?
A. Yes.
Q. Whom did you see there?
A. Terranova, Nick Terranova.
Q. What did he say to you?
A. "I am very sorry to trouble you. I know
what you are losing. I know that you are doing
this for us, but it is absolutely necessary.
You are in no danger at all"—he was all the
time in the house—"there will be no danger for
you; you will be all right."
Q. Did he tell you what you had to say?
A. He said, "How many times a week do
you want to say that you saw him?" I answered
once a week. "I want to make my testimony
as light as possible," I told him, "so as not to
get into trouble with the Court." He said that
once a week was probably too little; "make it
twice a week," he said. And I said, if I remember
rightly, I saw him twice a week.
Q. Did he tell you the time and the period?
A. He told me the period from the latter
part of December to the early part of March.
Of course I could not testify further than that.
Q. Was Dr. Brancato there?
A. I was all alone.
Terranova said to me that when his brother
(Morello) comes out of the Tombs I was to tell
him just what I was going to testify to in Court.
This in order to keep Morello from getting
mixed up in his testimony, and also for the additional
purpose of keeping Morello's mind at ease
in the courtroom. Terranova told me to come
along with him, and he made me stand in the
corner there until he (Morello) came out, and
I was to say he had rheumatism.
Q. He said that; did Terranova tell Morello
you were going to testify?
A. We had arranged that.
Q. When did you first see him?
A. When they were bringing him down from
the Tombs to the courtroom.
Q. Did Terranova speak to Morello?
A. Yes. He first spoke to Morello.
Q. And he told him that you were willing
to testify for that period?
A. Yes.
Q. Then what did you say to Morello?
A. "I am going to testify for you, that you
had rheumatism for that period, from the latter
part of December to the first part of March."
Q. Up to the time you left for Rochester?
A. Yes. He said, "Don't fear; we are out;
there is no danger at all; you need not fear, and
I tell you that I was not out of the house at
all; nobody saw me and nobody will know the
difference, because I was as pale as a ghost at
the time."
Q. They did not know we had eight men
watching them at the time—
A. I came the first time, was here two days
and was not called; I hung around the Court
and finally had to go back to Rochester and look
after my business.
Q. When did you first see Dr. Brancato?
A. The second time I came down to New
York.
Q. Did you know that he was going to testify
too?
A. Terranova told me—
Q. What did he say?
A. "He is going to testify that you were in
consultation." Terranova took me from the
courthouse here to Dr. Brancato.
Q. That is Nick Terranova?
A. Yes.
Q. What did you do down in Brancato's office?
A. We simply agreed as to what we were
going to say; that is the time Dr. Brancato told
me "we are up against it."
Q. On the quiet?
A. On the quiet.
Q. Was Terranova there?
A. He was in the outside room.
Q. Did he tell you how you would fix it up—he
did not treat Morello?
A. No. Morello was not sick; he had no
rheumatism, but complained all the time of pains.
Q. Did Dr. Brancato tell you he had not
treated him?
A. We did not argue about that. It was
understood.
Q. It was understood that you had to swear
falsely?
A. Because we could not do otherwise! So
they came to me principally because I was his
regular physician and they got Dr. Brancato—
Q. To come in after you went to Rochester?
A. I do not know what Dr. Brancato said.
Q. Do you know Maria Capellano; she is no
relation to you?
A. Who?
Q. The trained nurse who said she treated
him?
A. No.
Q. Do you know Gasparo Candido, the druggist
on One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street,
now at No. 23 New Bowery?
A. No.
Q. Did you ever have any conversation with
Mrs. Morello?
A. No—the only conversation I had with her
was—"Please do that for the love of the children;
try and help my husband."
Q. Where did you have that conversation?
A. She came to my house.
Q. You fixed the whole thing up with the
Terranova boys?
A. With Nick.
Q. What happened after you got through
testifying?
A. I rushed back to Rochester.
Q. Have you heard from them since you
have been indicted?
A. My mother told the whole crowd that she
would have nothing to do with them; didn't care
what the consequences would be. She said:
"You have ruined my son; the last good thing
you have done for us." They said to her,
"Don't worry, everything will be all right."
She said: "I don't care how it goes; I don't
want to see you any more."
Q. Did you hear anything about the alibi
that you were going to establish for Cecala?
A. I heard something when I was in the
lawyer's office.
Q. Were you down in the lawyer's office
at all?
A. Twice. He said: "What is your testimony
to be?" I told him, and he said all right.
Q. The only lawyer you ever saw?
A. Yes.
Q. Terranova was the one who had all the
conversation?
A. Nick, yes. He did the telegraphing.
Q. How did he sign the telegram?
A. Terranova.
Q. Did not sign Nicholas?
A. No, I don't think he did.
Q. He was down in Towns'[6]
office?
A. He was; he never left me a minute.
Q. What conversation did you have with
Ponticelli?
A. Only that I got there before he did. I
was introduced to him here.
Q. By whom?
A. I do not recall.
Q. He is a friend of Morello's?
A. I think he was; lived downtown; they
were neighbors.
Q. Did you not have a store up there?
[Rochester.]
A. No. I went away from New York with
a druggist.
Q. His name?
A. Bisconti. He went out there [Rochester]
for the purpose of setting up a drug store,
and I to set up an office. Naturally, I would
be doing business with him. If I had any patients
he would fill out the prescriptions. We
proposed to help one another. We could not
set up the drug store right away, so I rented
my office to him and kept some medicines there;
and I wrote my prescriptions and told the patients
that if they wanted they could have the
prescriptions filled out right in the house. That
thing did not work because people would pay
one dollar for the visit to me and sixty or seventy
cents for the medicine, and they thought
it was a scheme. I told Bisconti that as we had
come to Rochester together I would help him all
I could to set up a drug store there. This was
when we parted.
Q. How long have you known Bisconti?
A. About three months.
Q. Did any of the crowd ever give you
checks to present at the bank?
A. No. Ponticelli has a store with three or
four men working. He came to me and asked
if I could do him a favor. I had been there only
two or three months. He said that he was doing
much business and that as I was not doing
very much he requested me to go and cash a
check for him. It was for $300 made out by
Ponticelli himself.
Q. Did they ever discuss the counterfeit
operations with you in any way?
A. No.
Q. The only thing you know about them is
that they made you come down here and testify?
A. Yes.
Q. Did they threaten your mother?
A. No.
For making this statement, which shows up
the methods whereby the "Black-Handers" operated
and tried to escape the punishment of the
court for the offenses with which they were
charged, Dr. Romano was allowed to go free
after sentence was suspended.
Dr. Brancato, the other physician, was tried
twice, once the jury disagreeing and the second
time he was found not guilty.
I have no criticism of the action of the jury
in Dr. Brancato's case. It is simply in line with
the "fortunes of war" that the government was
unable to land Dr. Brancato.