Primitive ballads have a straightforward felicity; many of them a conjuring
melody as befits verse and music born together. Their gold is
virgin, from the rock strata, and none the better for refining and burnishing.
No language is richer in them than the English.
Edmund Clarence Stedman
The old song of Chevy-Chase is the favourite ballad of the Common People
of England; and Ben Jonson used to say, he had rather have been the
author of it than of all his works.... For my own part, I am so professed
an admirer of this antiquated song, that I shall give my reader a
critic upon it.
Joseph Addison
Ballads are living organisms.[1] If a teacher requires
a pupil to analyze minutely a ballad according to rules
of prosody and literary criticism, the analysis ruthlessly
destroys its spontaneous folk-spirit. To dissect
a ballad is literary slaughter.
We all know how the cold-blooded analysis of choice
masterpieces destroys forever a pupil’s pleasure in
reading them. The teacher of ballad-literature should
use the opposite method to that of literary criticism.
She should make her pupil delight in a ballad for
its own sake; for its unity, its swinging rhythm, its
unself-conscious expressions of emotion, and for the
human life within it.
A ballad treated in this sympathetic manner will
become a thrilling memory for the pupil to carry
through the years. A ballad presented thus has educational
values besides that of giving joy. It may be
used to develop the pupil’s sense of time and rhythm;
to enlarge his vocabulary; to teach him to express his
thoughts without affectation; to give him ease in sight-reading
of Scottish dialect and old English spelling and
to accustom him to obsolete words. As a memory
exercise for the pupil, the learning and recitation of
ballads is unrivaled; because young people memorize
them without effort. And furthermore, ballads have
dramatic qualities that hold and move a mixed audience
of boys and girls of all ages—and of grown folk,
too, for that matter.
But perhaps the most important educational function
of ballad-literature is that of being a safety-valve
for the escape of new, fast-rising feelings and enthusiasms
of growing boys and girls, feelings that throng
and press for utterance. Young people do not know
how to put them into their own words, but find a
wholesome and satisfying means of expressing their
emotions through learning and reciting ballads or by
reading them aloud.
There are many versions of old ballads, of some as
many as twenty or more; those most suitable for young
people are given here.
There are included here ballads in Scottish dialect,
and in old English wording with obsolete spelling and
capitalization. These versions may be used with confidence
by the teacher, because no pains have been
spared in collating them by authoritative texts.[2]
Even such differing forms as o’ or o; wi’ or wi; e’e or
ee; then for than or than for then; and variations of
proper names, as in “Proud Lady Margaret,” have
been followed according to the text used.
Quotation marks, only, have been added for the convenience
of the young folk. A few objectionable, but
unimportant, words have been changed. In the version
of “Chevy-Chase,” Bishop Percy’s Folio Manuscript
has been followed with a few emendations from his
Reliques, including the capitalization of the first letter
of each line. The Folio Manuscript is more authoritative
than the Reliques.
Some of the ballads and verses which follow the old
forms given by collectors are: “The Stormy Winds Do
Blow,” p. 2; “Sir Patrick Spens,” p. 3; “The Dæmon
Lover,” p. 7; “Chevy-Chase,” p. 21; “Proud Lady
Margaret,” p. 62; “The Famous Flower of Serving-Men,”
p. 65; “The Young Tamlane,” p. 255; “Thomas
the Rhymer,” p. 93; “The Wee Wee Man,” p. 114;
“The Earl of Mar’s Daughter,” p. 115; “Kemp
Owyne,” p. 122; “Fair Anny of Roch-royal,” p. 191;
“The Cruel Sister,” p. 196; “Blancheflour and Jellyflorice,”
p. 209; “The Gay Goss-Hawk,” p. 218;
“Bonny Baby Livingston,” p. 224; “Young Beichan
and Susie Pye,” p. 237; “The Wife of Usher’s Well,”
p. 263; “Sir Roland,” p. 265; the Robin Hood ballads,
p. 290 ff.; “True Valour,” p. 355; “Pilgrimage,” p.
351; “Peace,” p. 356.
In striking and pleasing contrast to the old ballads
are the modern ones with capitalization to please
modern children. It may be noted that the texts of
Keats’s “La Belle Dame,” and Campbell’s “Earl
March,” are different from the versions usually included
in children’s ballad-books. The texts followed
here are those most lately approved by literary critics.
Ways in which ballads may be used in the classroom
or during Poetry Hours:
1. Reading aloud for development of literary taste.
This is the most important educational use of ballads.
The teacher should read them aloud to the class, giving
them all their native swing and quick pulsation.
The minstrels, who composed them, often accented
words to suit the length of their lines; so if the reader
will lend her voice to the rhythm of the verse, the
accents will fall where they belong. Such words as
country, harper, singer, damsel, lady, and battle should
sometimes be accented on the last syllable, as countrý,
singér, harpér, ladý.
2. Memorizing and reciting. Boys and girls enjoy
learning ballads by heart. They do so with astonishing
ease. The teacher may assign one ballad to the whole
class; or she may divide the class into sections and
assign a ballad to each section. This should be done at
least two or three weeks before the period for recitation.
The teacher may then call on one or more of the
pupils to recite.
3. Story-telling from the ballads. The teacher may
read aloud a ballad. She should read it two or three
times to the class. Then the pupils may retell it in
story form either orally or in writing.
4. Dramatization. Ballads are so dramatic and simple
in their movement that they may be easily acted in
the schoolroom with or without improvised scenery
and costumes. The teacher or pupil may read aloud
the ballad, while some of the boys and girls act it out
in dumb show; or, better yet, the actors may recite the
lines that belong to their parts, and the teacher may
read aloud the descriptive parts only. Whenever a
refrain occurs, as in “The Stormy Winds Do Blow,”
the whole class may join in reciting it.
5. Writing from memory. The teacher may assign a
ballad to the class to learn by heart; and then she may
have the class write it out from memory following closely
the spelling, punctuation, and dialect of the text.
6. Original ballad-writing. Young people are natural
ballad-makers. At the end of the year, after memorizing
and reciting ballads and listening to them read
aloud, the pupils will be so saturated with ballad-spirit
and meter, that ballad-writing will be a second
nature. The teacher may then tell, very briefly but
interestingly, the plot of a ballad, and let the pupils
put it into original verses, giving them a week or two
in which to do so. After this exercise the teacher may
assign a local legend or story for practice in original
ballad-writing.
The Programme that is given here is merely suggestive.
All the ballads in the book are good to read aloud,
and most of them may be dramatized or memorized.
The course presented below shows a teacher how she
may, by progressive steps, develop her pupils’ taste
for ballad-literature, and prepare them to appreciate
more mature forms of narrative poetry, such as metrical
romances and epics.
1st Week. Reading aloud: The Laidley Worm O’ Spindleston-Heughs,
p. 148.
2d Week. Reading aloud: Little Billee, p. 159; Brian O’Linn,
p. 160; Dicky of Ballyman, p. 162; The Cinder King,
p. 167.
3d Week. Dramatization: The Stormy Winds Do Blow,
p. 2; The Noble Riddle, p. 208; “Earl March looked
on his dying child,” p. 203.
4th Week. Reading aloud: The Lady of Shalott, p. 124; The
Singing Leaves, p. 131.
5th Week. Dramatization: Kemp Owyne, p. 122; The Erl-King, p. 86.
6th Week. Reading aloud: Robin Hood and Little John,
p. 291; Robin Hood and Clorinda, p. 297.
7th Week. Dramatization: Ballad of the Oysterman, p. 164;
Earl Haldan’s Daughter, p. 58; The Greeting of Kynast,
p. 74; A Tragic Story, p. 158.
8th Week. Reading aloud (Halloween Week): The Spell,
p. 254; Sir Roland, p. 265; The Cruel Sister, p. 196;
The Skeleton in Armour, p. 270.
9th Week. Dramatization: Glenara, p. 212; The Dæmon
Lover, p. 7.
10th Week. Reading aloud: King Alfred and the Shepherd,
p. 176.
11th Week. Story-telling from the Ballads: Young Beichan
and Susie Pye, p. 237.
12th Week. Reading aloud: The Fairy Thorn, p. 87; The
Kelpie of Corrievreckan, p. 97.
13th Week. Memorizing and reciting: True Valour, p. 355;
The Touchstone, p. 347; Barclay of Ury, p. 341; Pilgrimage,
p. 351.
14th Week. Reading aloud: The Heart of the Bruce, p. 333.
15th Week. Memorizing and reciting (for Christmas): The
Royal Court, p. 353; Peace, p. 356; The Three Kings,
p. 357.
16th Week. Reading aloud: Lady Clare, p. 59; Sir Galahad,
p. 348.
17th Week. Story-telling from the Ballads: The Earl of Mar’s
Daughter, p. 115.
18th Week. Reading aloud: Ballad of Meikle-Mouthed Meg,
p. 32.
19th Week. Dramatization: The Gay Goss-Hawk, p. 218;
Thomas the Rhymer, p. 93.
20th Week. Reading aloud: Young Tamlane, p. 255.
21st Week. Memorizing and reciting: Lord Lovel, p. 204; The
Beggar-Maid, p. 214; The Sands of Dee, p. 190; Lochinvar,
p. 215.
22d Week. Reading aloud: Fair Anny of Roch-royal, p. 191;
Bonny Baby Livingston, p. 224.
23d Week. Story-telling from the Ballads: Blancheflour and
Jellyflorice, p. 209.
24th Week. Reading aloud: The Child of Elle, p. 244.
25th Week. Writing from memory: The Birth o’ Robin Hood,
p. 290; The Wee Wee Man, p. 114.
26th Week. Reading aloud: More Modern Ballad of Chevy-Chase,
p. 21.
27th Week. Story-telling from the Ballads: Cochrane’s Bonny
Grizzy, p. 70; The Frolicksome Duke, p. 169.
28th Week. Reading aloud: May of the Moril Glen, p. 138.
29th Week. Writing from memory: The Wife of Usher’s Well,
p. 263.
30th Week. Reading aloud: Sir Patrick Spens, p. 3; Hynd
Horn, p. 231.
31st Week. Writing from memory: Proud Lady Margaret,
p. 62.
32d Week. Reading aloud: Song of the Outlaw Murray,
p. 301.
33d Week. Original ballad-writing: Barbara Allen’s Cruelty,
p. 201; Alice Brand, p. 81; The Famous Flower of
Serving-Men, p. 65.
34th Week. Reading aloud: The Eve of St. John, p. 279.
35th Week. Memorizing and reciting: The Fairy Tempter,
p. 80; The Luck of Edenhall, p. 135; La Belle Dame
sans Merci, p. 91.
36th Week. Reading aloud: The Mermaid, p. 10.
37th Week. Original ballad-writing: King James the First and
the Tinkler, p. 173; Valentine and Ursine, p. 314; Belted
Will, p. 47.
38th Week. Reading aloud: Kilmeny, p. 101.
39th Week. Original ballad-writing: The teacher may assign a
subject for this—a local legend or story of a patriotic
or historical event.
40th Week. Entertainment for Parents and Friends of Pupils:
The ballad-course may close with an afternoon or evening
entertainment. This may be made delightful. All
the pupils should take part in the exercises.
Many of the old ballads are set to charming ancient
tunes, and may be sung by the whole school. Banjo
or guitar accompaniment is specially appropriate to
ballad airs. Musical scores for some of the ballads in
this book—“The Cruel Sister” (“The Twa Sisters”),
“Hynd Horn,” “Sir Patrick Spens,” “Young
Beichan,” “Proud Lady Margaret,” “The Famous
Flower of Serving-Men,” and “Lord Lovel”—may be
found in Professor Child’s English and Scottish Popular
Ballads, large edition, part 10. If the music of old
ballads is not obtainable, then popular, well-known
ballads, such as “Annie Laurie,” “Ben Bolt,” and
“Loch Lomond,” may be sung in their stead.
The following outline for an entertainment may be
varied to suit the abilities and interests of the boys and
girls who are to take part:
One or more ballads sung by the pupils.
Recitation.
Dramatization.
Ballad-reading.
A ballad solo.
Recitation.
Reading of the best original ballad composed by a pupil.
Dramatization.
Recitation.
Close: the audience and pupils may sing one or more
popular, well-known American ballads, such as may
be found in any good song-collection.
In making up her Programme, the teacher should
avoid selecting very long ballads for memorization and
recitation. It is best to let the pupils who are to recite,
choose the ballads they like best. She should be careful
to balance her Programme with verses of all kinds—grave
and gay, sad and weird, romantic and historical.
She should so artistically compose her Programme
that it will play on the emotions of her audience, moving
it from laughter to tears, from awe to the heroic.
That is what ballads are for, to touch the heart, as
well as the head.
This entire course, as outlined for forty weeks, may
be followed by Librarians and Social Workers. They
may, however, shorten the Programme or alter it to
suit the occasion.