At Professor Ferguson’s house in Edinburgh,
nearly a year later—in February.
It is a cheerful, comfortable room, marked by the
taste and culture of Edinburgh literary
society at its best, with the elegance of
fashion. A few portraits of Scots men of
letters and action hang on the wall—Allan
Ramsay, Robert Fergusson, James
VI., Robert Bruce; in addition there are
books and a pair or two of claymores, and
two or three prints, including one by
Bunbury of a dead soldier and his dog.
On the mantelpiece is a bust of David
Hume. The chill Scots winter day is
brightened by a large fire in the grate;
outside is snow.
Folding doors are open to a room beyond, where
a luncheon party has been taking place.
The ladies have left the table, and are
seated round the room before us. They are
the hostess, Mrs. Ferguson, the Duchess
of Gordon, Mrs. Montgomery, Miss
Taylor, and with them a boy of fifteen,
the young Walter Scott. Men’s voices
can be heard from time to time.
Another lady, young and beautiful, Mrs.
Stewart of Stair, is seated at the piano,
singing to her own accompaniment.
Flow gently, sweet Afton! among thy green braes,
Flow gently, I’ll sing thee a song in thy praise;
My Mary’s asleep by thy murmuring stream—
Flow gently, sweet Afton, disturb not her dream.
Thy crystal stream, Afton, how lovely it glides,
And winds by the cot where my Mary resides!
How wanton thy waters her snowy feet lave,
As gathering sweet flow’rets she stems thy clear wave!
Flow gently, sweet Afton! among thy green braes,
Flow gently, sweet river, the theme of my lays!
My Mary’s asleep by thy murmuring stream—
Flow gently, sweet Afton, disturb not her dream.
[At the end of the song Walter Scott goes
to a desk at the back of the room, and
turns over the pages of a book.]
The Duchess: Bravo! A very beautiful
song.
Miss Taylor (very fashionable, rather plain,
towards fifty, and not for poetry): And you say
he gave it to you?
Mrs. Stewart: He sent it this morning.
Miss Taylor: Rather indelicate, don’t you
think—that piece about snowy feet?
Mrs. Stewart: I think it’s lovely.
Miss Taylor: Well, I must say I should feel
rather embarrassed myself.
Mrs. Ferguson (benign and easy, the professor’s
wife): I like that tune so much—Afton
Water, isn’t it?
Mrs. Stewart: Yes.
Mrs. Ferguson: Jamie used to whistle it, I
remember.
Mrs. Montgomery (marble, more the duchess
than Gordon herself): I must say, Mrs.
Ferguson, your young lion behaves himself
quite prettily.
The Duchess: Why shouldn’t he, Mrs.
Montgomery?
Mrs. Montgomery: Oh well, Duchess, you
would hardly expect it from a ploughman,
now would you?
The Duchess: ‘Flow gently, sweet Afton!
among thy green braes’—wouldn’t you expect
it of that?
Mrs. Stewart: His conversation is entrancing.
Miss Taylor: A very dangerous young man,
and with those eyes too.
The Duchess: Nonsense, Martha. You
needn’t alarm yourself.
Miss Taylor: Well, I shouldn’t like to be
alone with him.
The Duchess: I am sure he would be discreet.
I think you’re a very lucky woman,
Mrs. Stewart. I wish Mr. Burns would write
poems to me. My husband says there’s never
been such a natural genius in Scotland before.
Mrs. Montgomery: Oh, come now. For an
uncultivated talent it is pretty well, we may
allow. But we must not turn his head.
Miss Taylor: I entirely agree with you,
Mrs. Montgomery. Most unsafe.
Mrs. Stewart: I wonder he hasn’t married.
Mrs. Montgomery: Oh, my dear, haven’t
you heard of the scandal in his own village?
It would have been jail I’m told if it hadn’t
been for some Mr. Gavin Hamilton who took
a fancy to him. But I believe he has several
families.
Miss Taylor: I really don’t think we ought
to encourage him. And one of his poems, I
hear, is quite friendly to the Devil.
The Duchess:
But, fare-you-weel, auld Nickie-ben!
O wad ye tak’ a thought an’ men’!
Ye aiblins might—I dinna ken—
Still hae a stake—
I’m wae to think upo’ yon den,
E’en for your sake!
Miss Taylor: Most confusing.
Walter Scott (moving from his book to Mrs.
Stewart): Have you any more of his poems,
ma’am?
Mrs. Stewart: I have his book, Walter.
Walter Scott: I wish I could read it.
Mrs. Stewart: I’ll lend it to you.
Walter Scott: Will you really? Thank you.
He has got lovely eyes, hasn’t he? I should
write poems if I had eyes like that. Couldn’t
you sing again?
Mrs. Ferguson: Yes, please do, Mrs. Stewart.
Miss Taylor: Something with a little religion
in it.
Mrs. Stewart (after a glance at this, sings):
Her flowing locks, the raven’s wing,
Adown her neck and bosom hing;
How sweet unto that breast to cling
And round that neck entwine her!
Her lips are roses wat wi’ dew,
O, what a feast her bonnie mou’!
Her cheeks a mair celestial hue,
A crimson still diviner.
Miss Taylor: Really!
The Duchess: I think my husband is right,
Miss Taylor.
[From the room beyond comes the sound of
voices, or particularly of one voice, raised
in argument. Mrs. Montgomery majestically
moves up to a view of the proceedings.]
Mrs. Montgomery: Dear me. Mr. Burns
seems to be making a speech. I fear I was
mistaken.
The Duchess: It’s that foolish man Robertson.
He was speaking ill of Mr. Gray’s Elegy.
He was very provoking. Mr. Burns does
quite right to defend it.
Burns’s voice (from the far room): Sir, I now
perceive a man may be an excellent judge of
poetry by square and rule, and after all be a
damned blockhead.
[The Reverend Mr. Robertson, a pedantic
and acidulated clergyman, comes
hurriedly through the door accompanied
by his host, Professor Ferguson, followed
by Burns.]
Mr. Robertson: Did you hear that?
Professor Ferguson: I beg you, Mr. Robertson—
Robertson: It is highly preposterous—
Burns: Will you allow me, sir, to apologise?
I withdraw my observation, and you may call
the Elegy what you will.
Ferguson: May I add my word—
Robertson: Very well, very well. I will overlook
your indiscretion, Mr. Burns. And believe
me Gray is a very inferior poet.
[They are now followed into the room by
Dr. Blacklock, the aged blind poet,
and Lord Muir, a middle-aged sporting
laird. Blacklock sits beside the Duchess
of Gordon, conducted by Ferguson;
Robertson by Miss Taylor;
Muir on a chair near them; Ferguson
goes to Walter Scott, who has returned
to his book at the window; and
Burns joins Mrs. Stewart, who is
still seated at the piano. There is an
undercurrent of conversation from the
various groups.]
Miss Taylor (to Robertson): That was extremely
generous of you, dear Mr. Robertson.
Robertson: Charity becomes my cloth,
madam.
Muir (immensely pleased with the incident):
Yes, but a damned blockhead. That’s
straight riding, you must allow that, sir.
Robertson: I regret, your lordship, I am no
Nimrod.
Muir: No, but damme, sir, we can all admire
a straight line. I like the lad.
Miss Taylor: It’s all very well, Lord Muir,
but it’s most unbecoming to call a reverend
gentleman a—h’m—blockhead.
Muir: A damned blockhead, ma’am, that’s
the word.
Robertson (turning his back to him, addressing
Miss Taylor): As I was remarking to you
at luncheon, the history of pew-rents is very
misleading—
[They drift into their own conversation.]
Muir (to Mrs. Montgomery, under his
breath): That’s the kind of poetry I can
understand.
Burns (to Mrs. Stewart): You did me
great honour in your singing.
Mrs. Stewart: The songs are their own recommendation,
Mr. Burns.
Burns: Sponsored by such beauty, madam,
they could not fail.
Mrs. Stewart (touching the piano very lightly
to the air of ‘Afton Water’): Do you find Edinburgh
agreeable?
Burns: Some moments of it.
Mrs. Stewart: I hear of your fame everywhere.
Burns: Fortunately it does not deceive
me.
Mrs. Stewart: But you have the sincere interest
of many.
Burns: There are not many whose interest
is valuable. With most, I please for a season—a
new fashion in the window.
Mrs. Stewart: A poet must not be bitter,
Mr. Burns.
Burns: I am not bitter, madam. I know my
friends from the rest, that is all.
Mrs. Stewart: Your friends should be happy.
Burns: You are very gracious. You forget
the—condescensions.
Mrs. Stewart: But that would be impossible.
Burns: Believe me, it is common. My
plough lends a virtue to flattery.
Mrs. Stewart: There is honest esteem as
well—delight.
Burns: I am as sensitive to it, madam, as
the top leaves to the last ripple of evening
wind. You are bountiful.
The Duchess (speaking across): Mrs. Ferguson,
do you think we might ask Mr. Burns to
sing one of his songs himself?
Mrs. Ferguson: If he would be so kind.
Burns: Madam, if her Grace so compliments
me. Will Mrs. Stewart play an air for
me?
Muir: Couldn’t it be something with a
chorus—eh? Nothing like opening the lungs,
sir (to Robertson).
Robertson: I regret, your lordship, I am no
Orpheus.
Muir: No, but damme, sir, sing cracked,
what odds?
Burns: Do you know ‘The Campbells are
Coming,’ madam?
Mrs. Stewart: This?
[She plays the air.]
Burns: Aye—that. I’ve made some new
verses for it—thus—
[He sings.]
Upon the Lomonds I lay, I lay,
Upon the Lomonds I lay, I lay,
I looked down to bonnie Lochleven
And saw three bonnie perches play.
The Campbells are comin’, Oho! Oho!
The Campbells are comin’, Oho! Oho!
The Campbells are comin’ to bonnie Lochleven,
The Campbells are comin’, Oho! Oho!
Great Argyle he goes before;
He makes the cannons and guns to roar,
Wi’ sound o’ trumpet, fife and drum;
The Campbells are comin’, Oho! Oho!
The Campbells are comin’, etc.
The Campbells they are a’ in arms,
Their loyal faith and truth to show,
Wi’ banners rattling in the wind,
The Campbells are comin’, Oho! Oho!
The Campbells are comin’, etc.
[The Duchess of Gordon, and Mrs.
Stewart, with Blacklock and Ferguson,
join enthusiastically in the
choruses, Mrs. Ferguson more mildly,
Mrs. Montgomery perfunctorily, and
Muir excitedly, moving about the
room, vainly exhorting Robertson and
Miss Taylor. Walter Scott, tense
with wondering admiration, slowly approaches
Burns as he sings, and stands
beside him.
At the close of the song there is a burst of
applause, and cries of, ‘Bravo! Bravo!
Another please, Mr. Burns,’ through
which is heard.]
Miss Taylor (to Robertson): Very incendiary
in sentiment, I must say.
Robertson: A very just criticism.
[The calls for another song persist.]
Burns: The tune of ‘The Collier’s Bonnie
Lassie’?
[Mrs. Stewart plays the air, and he
sings, very quietly, his audience now
Mrs. Stewart alone.]
O saw ye bonnie Lesley,
As she gaed o’er the Border?
She’s gane, like Alexander,
To spread her conquests farther.
To see her is to love her,
And love but her for ever;
For Nature made her what she is,
And never made anither!
Thou art a queen, fair Lesley,
Thy subjects, we before thee:
Thou art divine, fair Lesley,
The hearts o’ men adore thee.
The Deil he could na scaith thee,
Or aught that wad belang thee;
He’d look into thy bonnie face,
And say, ‘I canna wrang thee!’
[Very gravely and courteously he bows to
Mrs. Stewart at the end, and to a
murmur of approval moves across to the
fireplace. Mrs. Stewart remains talking
to Walter. Muir follows Burns
to the fireplace.]
Muir: Very pretty, Mr. Burns—especially
that one about the Campbells. I believe you
join our little party at dinner to-night?
Burns: I am much obliged to your lordship.
Muir: The Barley Sheaf at seven. I subscribed
for two copies of your book. Don’t
understand most of it, but I daresay I’ve
spent money worse. And I like straight riding,
sir. Seven o’clock. [Burns bows to this.]
Muir (to the Duchess): Good-day, your
Grace. (To Mrs. Ferguson.) Very entertaining,
Mrs. Ferguson.
[He takes his leave generally and goes,
speaking to Ferguson on his way out.
Robertson is saying good-bye to Miss
Taylor, and crosses to Mrs. Ferguson.]
Robertson: Good-afternoon, Mrs. Ferguson.
A most instructive gathering, I am sure.
Mrs. Ferguson: Good-afternoon, Mr. Robertson.
It was very considerate of you to
spare us the time.
Robertson (bowing stiffly to Burns): Good-afternoon,
Mr. Burns. And may the Lord
chasten your muse.
Burns: Yes, sir. I will speak to Him about
it.
Robertson: I will remember it in my devotions.
[He follows Muir, taking leave of the
company as he goes.]
Burns (to Mrs. Ferguson): I fear I was a
little heated before we left table. I beg your
indulgence. (To the Duchess.) Ma’am.
The Duchess (privately to him): You were
quite right. He is a—damned blockhead, I
think you said.
Ferguson (to Miss Taylor): Very striking
poems those, don’t you think, Miss Taylor?
Miss Taylor: Poetry is a pagan art, Mr.
Ferguson.
Ferguson: But such fervour is refreshing.
Miss Taylor: Very irregular.
[Burns has moved up to Ferguson, and is
studying the Bunbury print on the wall.]
Blacklock: That young man has the pure
flame of genius in him.
Mrs. Montgomery: A little disconcerting,
doctor. We have to remember society, you
know.
Blacklock: Society may be trusted with its
own preservation, Mrs. Montgomery, but
Scotland has never heard songs the like of
that before. We must cherish them.
Burns: There is a sublime pathos in that.
(Reading from the print.) ‘The child of misery
baptised in tears.’ Whose words are those?
Ferguson: I do not remember. Dr. Blacklock,
perhaps—Doctor, ‘The child of misery
baptised in tears’—do you recall the author?
Blacklock: No, I am afraid not.
[Walter Scott speaks with some timid
excitement to Mrs. Stewart.]
Mrs. Stewart: Walter Scott here tells me
they are by Langhorne.
Burns: Indeed, Langhorne. You read the
poets?
Walter Scott: Every day.
Burns: They will never fail you. I am much
indebted to you, Mr. Scott.
[He leaves the boy entirely elated, and
moves towards his place by the fire.]
Blacklock: Mr. Burns.
Burns (crossing to him): Sir?
Blacklock: I am an old man, Mr. Burns, and
I have been allowed, if I may say so, many
honours. I would give them all to have
written those songs.
Burns: They have often been my only
security, sir.
Mrs. Montgomery: Dr. Blacklock is very
considerate of your merit, Mr. Burns.
Burns: There are obligations, ma’am, not
easy to discharge with modesty. I am very
sensible of Dr. Blacklock’s kindness.
Blacklock: Mr. Burns is quite right, Mrs.
Montgomery. I was not offering him compliments.
[He lifts his hand paternally for Burns to
take. Burns, with great tenderness, returns
the salute, and goes back to the fireplace.
Miss Taylor rises and moves
over to Mrs. Ferguson.]
Miss Taylor: Good-afternoon, Mrs. Ferguson.
We meet on Friday.
Mrs. Ferguson: Yes, Miss Taylor.
Miss Taylor: Good-afternoon, Mr. Burns.
I trust you will not neglect the vineyard.
Burns: There are no vineyards at Mossgiel,
madam.
Miss Taylor: I mean the Lord’s. The labourer
must be worthy of his hire.
Burns: The labourer—hired. Yes, I will
remember.
[Miss Taylor takes leave of the Duchess
and the company, and goes, accompanied
to the door by Mrs. Ferguson.
Walter Scott comes to Mrs. Ferguson
and shakes her hand. He stands a moment
before Burns, looking at him uncertainly.]
Burns (holding out his hand, which Walter
takes): Good-bye.
Walter Scott: Good-bye, sir.
[Leaving Burns rather poignantly taken
aback by the unexpected ceremony of
address, he bows to the Duchess and the
others and goes. Mrs. Stewart is now
standing by Dr. Blacklock, and as
Mrs. Montgomery rises, she takes her
place.]
Mrs. Montgomery (to her hostess): Good-afternoon.
Good-afternoon, Duchess. If I
can help Mr. Burns with any recommendation,
he will let me know. Word left at
Wilson’s bookshop will reach me.
[She goes, escorted by the Fergusons.]
The Duchess: Dr. Blair was praising your
poems this morning, Mr. Burns. But he suggested
that you might with advantage enlarge
your scope. He spoke of Dr. Young and
Mr. Akenside.
Burns: I fear my Pegasus is for light
journeys only, your Grace.
[Mrs. Ferguson is now sitting opposite
Mrs. Stewart with Blacklock.
Ferguson joins the group at the fire.]
Blacklock: If Mr. Burns would humour me
before I go, might I ask for another of his—masterpieces.
The Duchess: Yes—please.
Burns: Will Mrs. Stewart favour me—the
duet you were speaking of?
[Mrs. Stewart goes to the piano, and
they sing.]
As I gaed down the water-side,
There I met my shepherd lad,
He row’d me sweetly in his plaid,
And ca’d me his dearie.
Ca’ the yowes to the knowes,
Ca’ them where the heather grows,
Ca’ them where the burnie rows,
My bonnie dearie!
Will ye gang down the water-side,
And see the waves sae sweetly glide?
Beneath the hazels spreading wide
The moon it shines fu’ clearly.
Ca’ the yowes, etc.
If ye’ll but stand to what ye’ve said,
I’se gang wi’ you, my shepherd lad,
And ye may row me in your plaid,
And I sall be your dearie.
Ca’ the yowes, etc.
Blacklock: The sweetest voice of Caledonia’s
sons, Mrs. Ferguson.
The Duchess (rising): Well, your poet has
captivated me entirely, Mrs. Ferguson. I return
to Gordon Castle next week, Mr. Burns.
I hope you will visit us there.
Burns (kissing her offered hand): If you will
indulge me so far, your Grace.
[The Duchess says good-bye to Mrs.
Stewart and Dr. Blacklock, and
goes out with Mrs. Ferguson, passing
Ferguson at the door. Ferguson
moves down to Blacklock.]
Blacklock (rising): Mr. Ferguson? I am
greatly your debtor. It has been one of the
most memorable occasions in a long life. A
very great privilege, Mr. Burns.
[He holds out his hand in the direction of
Burns, who takes it with real veneration.
Then he goes, Ferguson directing his
steps.]
Burns: You are staying in Edinburgh long?
Mrs. Stewart: I leave to-morrow.
Burns (looking at his watch): I must go.
Mrs. Ferguson will be tired of me. You sang
enchantingly.
Mrs. Stewart: You are joining the Barley
Sheaf party to-night?
Burns: Yes.
Mrs. Stewart: You are happy there?
Burns: I am free. And nobody patronises
me.
Mrs. Stewart: But they have been very
civil to you here.
Burns: Some of them. And there have been
consolations even beyond that. The old man,
and the boy, and you. But the others—you
heard. Why should I? Where does it lead
me?
Mrs. Stewart: Success at the Barley Sheaf is
more gratifying?
Burns: I know, madam, I know. But I
shall never learn discipline.
Mrs. Stewart: Not even for the sake of your
friends?
Burns: In a few weeks I shall have passed
out of all this—back from it, if you will. My
friends, who will they be then? I do not expect
remembrance.
Mrs. Stewart: That is not kind.
Burns: It is generous of you to think it. O,
I am not ungrateful, believe me. I have been
fortunate in opinions that I shall cherish.
But those—with their vineyards, and
preachments over me, and Akensides, and
Wilson’s bookshop—did you hear that? My
time may come, but it is not now, in Edinburgh.
Mrs. Stewart: And so birthright may be
wasted, at the Barley Sheaf?
Burns: Do not let me deceive you, madam.
Like my songs—yes, I pray you will do that.
But they thrive in that company—I am at
home there. I am not proud of it, and it will
settle my account early, likely enough. But
I know my condition. Virtue was born a
caprice in me, madam, and fortune has not
husbanded her for me. I sing sometimes, and
for the rest I have no talent, perhaps, but a
little to know myself.
Mrs. Stewart: I understand. And you will
be yourself.
Burns: Even through disaster, I must. It is
the only honour I have.
[The Fergusons come back.]
Mrs. Ferguson: Forgive us, please.
Burns: Thank you, Mrs. Ferguson, for your
kindness—it was very obliging of you to
bring me here. Good-afternoon.
Mrs. Ferguson: Good-afternoon, Mr. Burns.
Ferguson: Many flattering things have been
said, Mr. Burns.
Burns (to Mrs. Stewart): Good-afternoon,
madam.
Mrs. Stewart: Good luck, Mr. Burns.
Ferguson (going out with him): Very flattering,
I assure you. Most gratifying you must
find it—
[They go out.]
Mrs. Ferguson: Shall you come with me,
my dear, to Dr. Mackenzie’s?
Mrs. Stewart: I think I would rather stay at
home this afternoon, Mrs. Ferguson.
[Ferguson returns and goes to his desk for
a book.]
Mrs. Ferguson: Certainly, my dear. I’ll tell
Maggie.
Ferguson: Very pleasant. Dr. Robertson
was most instructive at lunch upon the second
epistle, don’t you think? Yes.
[He bustles out.]
Mrs. Ferguson: She shall bring tea to you
here.
[She goes.]
[Mrs. Stewart plays a few notes of
‘Afton Water’ on the piano. Then she
changes the air, and sings very softly.]
O whistle, and I’ll come to you, my lad,
O whistle, and I’ll come to you, my lad,
Tho’ father and mother and a’ should gae mad,
O whistle, and I’ll come to you, my lad.
[She pauses, and laughs lightly and humorously
at herself, and]
THE CURTAIN FALLS