WHO WAS THE THIEF?
When
Roswell rose the next morning he felt
cross and out of sorts. His head still ached a little,
and he wished he were not obliged to go to the store.
But it was out of the question to remain at home, so
he started about half an hour after the usual time,
and of course arrived late.
"You are late this morning," said Mr. Baker.
"You must be more particular about being here
in good season."
Roswell muttered something about not feeling
quite well.
Putting his hand into his pocket by chance, his
fingers came in contact with the key which he had
made to open the cash drawer. Just as he was passing
Mark, he drew it out and let it drop into the
side-pocket of his jacket. So, if suspicion were excited,
the key would be found on Mark, not on him.
The critical moment came sooner than he had anticipated.
A Mr. Gay, one of the regular customers of the
bookstore, entered a few minutes later.
"Good-morning, Mr. Baker," he said. "Have
you got a 'Tribune' this morning?"
"Yes, here is one. By the way, you are just
the man I wanted to see."
"Indeed, I feel complimented."
"Wait till you hear what I am going to say. You
bought a copy of 'Corinne' here on Monday?"
"Yes."
"And handed me a five-dollar bill on the Park
Bank?"
"Yes."
"Well, I find the bill was a skilfully executed
counterfeit."
"Indeed! I didn't examine it very closely. But
I know where I took it, and will give you a good bill
in exchange for it."
"I locked it up lest it should get out," said Mr.
Baker.
He went to the drawer which Roswell had opened.
Roswell listened to this conversation with dismay.
He realized that he was in a tight place, for it was
undoubtedly the five-dollar counterfeit which he had
taken, and paid to the Secretary of the Madison
Club. He awaited nervously the result of Mr.
Baker's examination.
"Don't you find it?" asked Mr. Gay.
"It is very strange," said Mr. Baker. "I placed
it at the top of a pile of bills, and now it is
gone."
"Look through the pile. Perhaps your memory
is at fault," said Mr. Gay.
Mr. Baker did so.
"No," he said, "the bill has disappeared."
"Do you miss anything else?"
"No. The money is just five dollars short."
"Perhaps you forget yourself, and paid it away to
a customer."
"Impossible; I always make change out of this
drawer."
"Well, when you find it, I will make it right. I
am in a hurry this morning."
Mr. Gay went out.
"Has any one been to this drawer?" inquired
Mr. Baker, abruptly.
"You always keep it locked,—do you not?" said
Mr. Jones.
"And keep the key myself. Yes."
"Then I don't see how it could have been
opened."
"There was nothing peculiar about the lock.
There might easily be another key to fit it."
"I hope you don't suspect me, Mr. Baker?"
"No, Mr. Jones, you have been with me five
years, and I have perfect confidence in you."
"Thank you, sir."
"I hope you don't suspect me, sir," said Roswell,
boldly. "I am willing to turn my pockets inside-out,
to show that I have no key that will fit the
lock."
"Very well. You may do so."
Roswell turned his pockets inside-out, but of
course no key was found.
"How lucky I got rid of it!" he thought.
"Now it's your turn, Mark," he said.
"I'm perfectly willing," said Mark, promptly.
He put his hand into his pocket, and, to his
unutterable astonishment and dismay, drew out a
key.
"I didn't know I had this in my pocket," he said,
startled.
"Hand me that key," said Mr. Baker, sternly.
Mark handed it to him mechanically.
Mr. Baker went behind the counter, and fitted the
key in the lock. It proved to open the drawer with
ease.
"Where did you get this key?" he said.
"I didn't know I had it, sir," said Mark, earnestly.
"I hope you will believe me."
"I don't understand how you can hope anything
of the kind. It seems very clear that you have been
at my drawer, and taken the missing money. When
did you take it?"
"I have never opened the drawer, nor taken your
money," said Mark, in a firm voice, though his
cheek was pale, and his look was troubled.
"I am sorry to say that I do not believe you,"
said Mr. Baker, coldly. "Once more, when did
you take the five dollars?"
"I did not take it at all, sir."
"Have you lent the key to any one?"
"No, sir. I did not know I had it."
"I don't know what to do in the matter," said the
bookseller, turning to Mr. Jones, his assistant. "It
seems clear to me that the boy took the missing
bill."
"I am afraid so," said Jones, who was a kind-hearted
man, and pitied Mark. "But I don't know
when he could have had the chance. He is never
left alone in the store."
"Roswell," said Mr. Baker, "have you left
Mark alone in the store at any time within two or
three days?"
Roswell saw the point of the inquiry, and determined,
as a measure of safety, to add falsehood to
his former offence.
"Yes, sir," he said, in an apologetic tone, "I left
him in the store for two or three minutes yesterday."
"Why did you leave him? Did you go out of
the store?"
"Yes, sir. A friend was passing, and I went out
to speak to him. I don't think I stayed more than
two or three minutes."
"And Mark was left alone in the store?"
"Yes, sir. I had no idea that any harm would
come of it."
Mark looked intently at Roswell when he uttered
this falsehood.
"You had better confess, Mark, that you took the
money when Roswell was out of the store," said his
employer. "If you make a full confession, I will
be as lenient with you as I can, considering your
youth."
"Mr. Baker," said Mark, quietly, more at his
ease now, since he began to understand that there
was a plot against him, "I cannot confess what is
not true. I don't know what Roswell means by what
he has just said, but I was not left alone in the
store for a moment all day yesterday, nor did Roswell
go out to speak to a friend while I was
about."
"There seems to be a conflict of evidence here,"
said Mr. Baker.
"I hope the word of a gentleman's son is worth
more than that of a match boy," said Roswell,
haughtily.
"To whom do you refer, when you speak of a
match boy?"
"To him," said Roswell, pointing to Mark.
"He used to be a vagabond boy about the streets
selling matches, and sleeping anywhere he could.
No wonder he steals."
"I never stole in my life," said Mark, indignantly.
"It is true that I sold matches about the streets,
and I should have been doing it now, if it had not
been for my meeting with kind friends."
"As to his having been a match boy, that has no
bearing upon the question," said Mr. Baker. "It
is the discovery of the key in his pocket that throws
the gravest suspicion upon him. I must see his
friends, and inquire into the matter."
"Of course they will stand by him," said Roswell.
"We may get some light thrown upon his possession
of the key, at any rate, and can judge for ourselves."
"I shall keep you employed until this matter is
investigated," said Mr. Baker to Mark. "Here is a
parcel of books to be carried to Twenty-Seventh
Street. Come back as soon as they are delivered."
Mark went out with a heavy heart, for it troubled
him to think he was under suspicion. Theft, too, he
had always despised. He wondered if Richard
Hunter would believe him guilty. He could not
bear to think that so kind a friend should think so ill
of him.
But Mark's vindication was not long in coming.
He had been out scarcely ten minutes when Roswell,
on looking up, saw to his dismay Tracy, the secretary
of the Madison Club, entering the store. His
heart misgave him as to the nature of the business
on which he had probably come.
He went forward hastily to meet him.
"How are you, Crawford?" said Tracy.
"Pretty well. I am very busy now. I will see
you, after the store closes, anywhere you please."
"Oh," said Tracy, in a voice loud enough for Mr.
Baker to hear, "it won't take a minute. The bill
you gave me last night was a bad one. Of course
you didn't know it."
Roswell turned red and pale, and hoped Mr.
Baker did not hear. But Mr. Baker had caught
the words, and came forward.
"Show me the bill, if you please, young gentleman,"
he said. "I have a good reason for asking."
"Certainly, sir," said Tracy, rather surprised.
"Here it is."
A moment's glance satisfied Mr. Baker that it was
the missing bill.
"Did Roswell pay you this bill?" he asked.
"Yes, sir."
"For what did he owe it?"
"I am the secretary of the Madison Club, and
this was paid as the entrance fee."
"I recognize the bill," said Mr. Baker. "I will
take it, if you please, and you can look to him for
another."
"Very well," said Tracy, puzzled by the words,
the motive of which he did not understand.
"Perhaps you will explain this," said Mr. Baker,
turning to Roswell. "It seems that you took this
bill."
Roswell's confidence deserted him, and he stood
pale and downcast.
"The key I presume, belonged to you."
"Yes, sir," he ejaculated, with difficulty.
"And you dropped it into Mark's pocket,—thus
meanly trying to implicate him in a theft which you
had yourself committed."
Roswell was silent.
"Have you taken money before?"
"I never opened the drawer but once."
"That was not my question. Make a full confession,
and I will not have you arrested, but shall
require you to make restitution of all the sums you
have stolen. I shall not include this bill, as it is
now returned to my possession. Here is a piece of
paper. Write down the items."
Roswell did so. They footed up a little over six
dollars.
Mr. Baker examined it.
"Is this all?" he said.
"Yes, sir."
"Half a week's wages are due you, I will therefore
deduct three dollars from this amount. The remainder
I shall expect you to refund. I shall have
no further occasion for your services."
Roswell took his cap, and was about to leave the
store.
"Wait a few minutes. You have tried to implicate
Mark in your theft. You must wait till his
return, and apologize to him for what you have
attempted to do."
"Must I do this?" asked Roswell, ruefully.
"You must," said Mr. Baker, firmly.
When Mark came in, and was told how he had
been cleared of suspicion, he felt very happy. Roswell
made the apology dictated to him, with a very
bad grace, and then was permitted to leave the store.
At home he tried to hide the circumstances attending
his discharge from his mother and his
cousin; but the necessity of refunding the money
made that impossible.
It was only a few days afterwards that Mrs.
Crawford received a letter, informing her of the death
of a brother in Illinois, and that he had left her a
small house and farm. She had found it so hard a
struggle for a livelihood in the city, that she decided
to remove thither, greatly to Roswell's disgust, who
did not wish to be immured in the country. But
his wishes could not be gratified, and, sulky and discontented,
he was obliged to leave the choice society
of the Madison Club, and the attractions of New
York, for the quiet of a country town. Let us
hope that, away from the influences of the city, his
character may be improved, and become more manly
and self-reliant. It is only just to say that he was
led to appropriate what did not belong to him, by the
desire to gratify his vanity, and through the influence
of a bad adviser. If he can ever forget that
he is "the son of a gentleman," I shall have some
hopes for him.