Although John Clare was a peasant suffering from poverty all
his life, his poetry was not written with a propagandistic but
with an artistic purpose. The literature of the eighteenth
and nineteenth centuries dealing with country life was either
artistic or social in purpose. Ebenezer Elliott, living at
the sane time as Clare, wrote poems with a social
purpose—for the repeal of the Corn Laws, and the lowering
of the import duties on raw material. Although Elliott was
actually benefitted by the Corn Laws, yet he wrote against them
most bitterly. John Clare, on the other hand, impoverished
all his life by the Corn Laws and other similar measures, wrote
nothing dealing with a change in the agricultural
situation. Both writers are to be praised for their
honesty, for their ability to detach themselves from immediate
personal interests, and for their fidelity to their artistic and
social purposes.
The poems of Clare may be divided into three classes: the Love
Poems, the Nature Poems, and the Poems dealing with social
life. In all the poet’s writings he is dominated by
an artistic purpose rather than by a desire to reform or change
conditions. We should expect this to be so in the Love
Poems, which form the bulk of his work. Yet, we may learn
something of the country life from these poems, if we take them,
written by a peasant as they are, to be typical of the sentiments
felt by all the rural laborers. In spite of the material
hardships and privations, there is a simplicity and sweetness in
the peasant’s love, an inner life of tender emotions and
warmth of feeling, that is in stark contrast with external
hardships. Clare, in the love poems, expresses these
sentiments of the peasant. The poem best illustrating the
simple love is one entitled, “My Love, thou art a Nosegay
Sweet.”—
And when, my Nosegay, thou shalt die,
And heaven’s flower shall prove thee;
My hopes shall follow to the sky,
And everlasting love thee.
The ballad entitled “William and Mary,” [15] in which two rural swains are talking
of their sweethearts, shows an elevated emotion and respect for
the objects of their love, that is deep felt and natural.
I strive to please her morning, noon, and
night.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
For her in harvest when the nuts are brown,
I take my crook to pull the branches down.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
The garland and the wreath for her I bind
Compos’d of all the fairest flowers I find.
And finally, a few lines showing the simplicity of the
peasant’s imagery and comparisons.—
’Tis Spring, my Love, ’tis Spring,
And the birds begin to sing;
If it were winter, left alone with you,
Your bonny form and face,
Would make a Summer place,
And be the fairest flower that ever grew.
Besides the sweet and simple love-life of the peasants, the
poet expresses their thoughts about the beauties of nature.
Nature must have afforded delights that did much to make up for
the poverty of the peasant’s lack of material
comfort. Clare expresses these delights of the inarticulate
peasants when he describes their sentiments, as well as the
beauties of their native scenes.
O Native endearments! I would not forsake
thee,
I would not forsake thee for sweetest of scenes.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
Your skies may be gloomy, and misty your mornings,
Your flat swampy vallies unwholesome may be;
Still, refuse of nature without her adornings,
Thou art dear as this heart in my bosom to me.
The poet finds beauty in the common, ordinary, natural objects
of the low fen and the marshy country of his birth. But in
these scenes he saw only the less gloomy and oppressive
aspects. The commons may have been brown and barren, but
Clare remembers them when they were green and dotted with wild
flowers. He wrote with fancy, feeling, and reflection about
these simple objects of nature. In his fancy he lived the
life of insects, which to many are simply annoyances, but which
to him are fairies, with colored hoods and burnished wings,
disguised in a sort of splendid masquerade, rocked to sleep in
the smooth velvet of the hedge-rose, or slumbering like princes
in the heath’s purple hood, secure from rain, from dropping
dews, in their beds and painted walls. A jolly and royal
life this seems, this life of a hand of play-fellows mocking the
sunshine with their glittering wings, or drinking golden wine and
metheglin from the cup of the honey flower. In a reflective
mood, he sees into the eternal mysteries of nature, beneath the
forms and symbols of outward appearances. Cowslips of
golden blooms will come and go as fresh two thousand years from
now as they are today. Brooks, bees, birds, from age to
age, these will sing when all the ambitious things of earth have
passed away.
There are two characteristics in the nature poems of Clare:
truth in the painting of the objects, and tenderness in his
sentiments toward them. The poet is both truthful and
tender when he paints a bird’s nest, a nest often seen but
never disturbed. The nest of the pettichaps, close to the
rut-galled wagon-road, so snugly contrived, although without a
clump of grass to keep it warm or a shielding thistle spreading
its spear in protection, is built like an oven. . . .
Scarcely admitting two fingers in,
Hard to discern the bird’s snug entrance win:
’Tis lined with feathers warm as silken stole,
Softer than seats of down for painless ease,
And full of eggs, scarce bigger e’en than peas;
Here’s one that’s delicate, with spots so small
As dust, and of a faint and pinky red;
Well, let them be, and Safety guard them well—
A green grasshopper’s jump might break the shell.
The other objects of nature that delighted the peasants, and
were poetised by Clare were ants, clover blossoms, and perhaps an
early butterfly. Again, we find an intimacy with the furry
animals of the commons.—
And the little clumbling mouse
Gnarls the dead leaves for her house.
No other poet has such a collection of insects and
animals.
The little gay moth lovely to view
A-dancing with lily-white wings in the dew;
He whisked o’er the water-edge flirting and airy
And perched on the down-headed grass like a fairy.
And there came the snail from shell peeping out,
As cautious and fearful as thieves in the rout.
The sly jumping frog, too, had ventured to ramp,
And the glow-worm had just ’gun to light up his lamp.
Thus we can get an idea of the country life from the love
poems, which showed the tender emotional love-life of the
laborer, in spite of his mental poverty and material
hardships. Likewise, in the nature poems, the poet shows
the beauties of nature in the country. The peasant
delighted in these beauties; he is rich in poetic sentiments and
intimate observations, though he is poor—if we judge
poverty to be a lack of food and clothing. If the Poet had
any resentment of the social and economic situation, we should
expect to find it in the poems dealing with Social Life.
Crabbe’s lines in the “Village”, that
describe a boy fainting in the fields from exhaustion, are
memorable. Such lines might have come aptly from Clare, who
as a laborer, fainted from exhaustion and hunger, and often went
without food. These lines of Crabbe’s are exactly
descriptive of the miseries of the poor, as experienced by Clare
himself.—
He strives to join his fellows in the field,
Till long-contending nature droops at last.
Declining health rejects the poor repast.
His cheerless spouse the coming anger sees,
And mutual murmurs urge the slow disease.
However
we never find a trace of bitterness in the poems of social life
written by Clare. Instead, he describes the hay-making time
in this manner:
And meadows, they are mad with noise
Of laughing maids and shouting boys,
Making up the withering hay
With merry hearts as light as play.
All his life the poet longed for a spot of ground of his own;
but enclosures made this an impossibility. Yet, when Clare
wrote about enclosures, it is not about a personal wrong or
injustice that he speaks; but about the loss of beauty or of
something dear to his heart that had been, but now was gone.
Whenever I must along the Plain,
And mark where once they grew,
Remembrance wakes her busy train,
And brings past scenes to view.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
The green’s gone, too—ah, lovely scene!
No more the kingcup gay
Shall shine in yellow o’er the green.
And shed its golden ray;
No more the herdsman’s early call
Shall bring the cows to feed;
No more the milk-maid’s evening brawl
In “Come Mull” tones succeed.
Both milk-maid’s shouts and herdsman’s call
Have vanished from the green;
The kingcup’s yellow, shade and all,
Shall never more be seen;
But the thick-cultur’d tribe that grow
Will so efface the scene,
That aftertime will hardly know
It ever was a green.
In this same connection, in the “Village
Minstrel,” we find these lines lamenting the absence of old
scenes and objects of beauty that are gone.—
There once were springs, when daisies’ silver
studs
Like sheets of snow on every pasture spread;
There once were summers where the crow-flower buds
Like golden sunbeams that sheltered Lubin’s head;
There fallen trees the naked moors bewail,
And scarce a bush is left to the tell the mournful tale.
Although the poet never wrote to reform agricultural
conditions, he is often realistic. He even denounces them
occasionally, but his prevailing tone is lamentation—for
the passing of the meadow-blooms and pasture-flowers—for
the trimmed hedge-fences and well-kept lawns.
Enclosures came and every path was stopt.
Each tyrant fix’d his sign where paths were found
To hint a trespass who might cross the ground.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
But who can tell the anguish of his mind,
When reformation’s formidable foes
With civil wars ’gainst nature’s peace combined,
And desolation struck her deadly blows
As curst improvement ’gan his fields inclose;
Oh greens, and fields, and trees, farewell, farewell!
His heart-wrung pains, his unavailing woes
No words can utter, and no tongue can tell,
When ploughs destroy’d the green, when groves of willow
fell.
Clare sees the hut of clay where the widow lives; he sees the
poor house, and feels the sting that must be the feeling of the
pauper when he accepts charity from the parish.
Yon parish-hut, where want is shov’d to
die,
He never views them but his tear would start;
He passed not by the doors without a sigh,
And felt for every woe of work-house misery.
Neither does the old dame at the parish cottage, as she stands
in the door viewing the children play, and remembering her past
youth—neither does she escape the poet’s eye.
She turns from echoes of her younger years
And nips the portion of her snuff with tears.
The poet sees another old woman gathering cress, to make a
savory salad for Luxury’s whim. For her labor the old
woman will get a penny and a frown. These objects of nature
were just as natural for Clare to write about, as the brown
leaves falling in the autumn instead of the green leaves coming
out in the spring. The dismal as well as the sunny days,
the joys as well as the sorrows, he shews in his picture of the
country life.
However realistic the poet may be, he is dominated by his
artistic purpose; and for this purpose he chose scenes in the
country that amused or aroused tender emotions in him. He
shunned, perhaps sub-consciously, the things that brought up
feelings of there being injustice in the world. His
peasants never lack enough food, or some kind of a hut that they
call home. In the wood-cutter’s cabin the
“careful wife displays her frugal hoard, and both partake
in comfort though they are poor.” His country
laborer, working on some enclosed farm, is a religious man, not
the drunken ignorant peasant who spends his few pennies at some
tavern while his wife and children starve. This laborer,
Clare depicts going out with his children on a Sunday
afternoon.
And often takes his family abroad
On short excursions o’er the fields and plain
Making each object on the road
An insect, spring of grass, or ear of grain;
Endeavoring thus most simply to maintain
That the same power that bids the mite to crawl
That browns the wheat-land in its summer stain,
That power which formed the simple flower withal,
Formed all that lives and grows upon this earthly ball.
Clare writes that his purpose is not to lament the sorrows but
to show the joys; and we may take the dominant motive of the poet
from the following lines:
But useless naming what distress reveals,
As every child of want feels all that Lubin feels.
In accordance with this purpose, in the “Village
Minstrel”, his longest poem, he gives us a variegated
picture of idyllic country life.
In the Spring the country hums with new life. On his way
to plow the fields, the peasant feels the Spring-time in the air;
the birds sing merrily as they build their nests; the
blue-meadow-daisy peeps farther out from the grass; while the
white lambs grazing on the green commons look like the last
remnants of the winter’s snow. The milk-maid hums a
love song as she weaves a garland to crown the first returning
cow. The housewives gossip about the hens and the geese;
while on Sunday after church the men talk about the good and the
bad signs of the weather for the growing grain.
Then the Spring passes into summer, with its gentle, quiet
breezes. A droning insect disturbed by a shrill sound of
the hay-maker’s scythe ceases for a moment his course; a
butterfly rests on a stalk and is swayed to and fro by the breeze.
The laborer, returning home in the long summer twilight,
remembers the ghost stories told the past winter; and as the
night comes on he hears the swashing sound of the drowned
Amy’s boots. Mid-summer is ushered in with its feast,
and every heart is jumping with joy. In brand-new clothes
the swain goes to the place of merriment, eager to meet his
sun-tanned lass. The woodsman and the thresher, children
and kin from the neighboring village, are all present. At
the cotter’s house, Joe tunes his fiddle for the
dance. When the fiddler is paid, the place is cleared for
the merry games that follow the feast.
Great sport for them was jumping in a sack,
For beaver hat bedecked in ribbons blue;
Soon one jumps down though he’s broke his neck
And tries to rise and wondrous sport they make,
And monstrous fun it makes to hunt the pig;
As soapt and larded through the crowd he flies.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
And badger-baiting here, and fighting cocks—
And wrestlers join to tug each other down.
At night the men go to the ale-house to drink, smoke, and make
merry until the money’s all gone.
Resolv’d to keep it merry while it’s
here
As toil comes every day and feasts but once a year.
Autumn, with corn gleanings and merry tales, brings its joy
and feasts. As the old women gather the last of the
harvest, they get over-heated. Stopping to catch their
breath, they amuse the children with stories or Jack the
Giant-Killer, Cincerilla, and Thumbs. When the harvest work
is done, another feast, known as the Harvest-Supper,
follows. Beer, smoking, and harmless pranks usher out the season
of mists and mellow fruitfulness.
Autumn breezes turn into sharper and more stinging blasts; the
moors and leas grow bare; the trees are stript of leaves; winter
is come. Though sombre and desolate, the peasant delights
in watching the storm, as great clouds float faster and faster as
the wind drives them before it. The woodsman, returning
home on a winter night with a load of fire-wood, looks like a
moving snow-bank. The supper is ready stewing on the hook;
the children, bright-eyed with happiness, prattle about his knees
to welcome him home. After supper with the hearth swept
clean, stories, songs, and prayer end the day.
“And thus in
wedlock’s joy the laborer drowns his care.”