IN order to shew how persons recover
out of a fit of this Disease, by
the mere efforts of nature, I shall beg
leave to premise a few of the most
probable opinions, and best establish’d
propositions, concerning Animal Motion,
which I shall here take for granted,
and refer the reader, for a physical
demonstration of them, to the ingenious
Essays of Doctors Porterfield,
Whytt, Simson, and Haller.
Animal and Muscular Motion is said
to be of two kinds, viz. Voluntary, and
Involuntary or Habitual.
By Voluntary Motion is meant the
action of any Muscle or Muscles produc’d
by an immediate or conscious
determination of the Mind; of this
kind are the several occasional motions
of the Body.
Involuntary or Habitual Motions are
such as proceed originally from the
Mind also, but are so establish’d, by
long custom, that the Mind is not
immediately conscious of them, nor
can stop them at pleasure13. To this
class, the Motion of the Heart, the
peristaltic Motion of the Stomach and
Guts, Respiration, and several Motions
of the Eyes belong.
The vital Motions are suppos’d to
be continued by a stimulus constantly
applied to the Fibres of the Muscles
which perform them.
Hence the Ventricles of the Heart
are constantly irritated and stretch’d by
the Venous Blood, which brings them
into contraction, to propel the Blood
through the Body.
Thus the Alimentary Tube is mov’d
by the irritation of the food, rarefied
air, &c.
And in like manner respiration is
carried on, by the uneasiness that is
felt in the Lungs at the end of every
dilatation and contraction of the Thorax,
which is owing to the resistance
that the Blood meets with, both from
the collapsing of the Lungs, and from
the pressure of the rarefied air on the
small Pulmonary Vessels, during their
expansion: to which may be added,
the elasticity of the Cartilages.
These several stimuli can only be
perceiv’d by a sentient principle, which,
in the human species, is call’d the Soul.
When the Soul is first united with
the Body, and receives command over
the organs of Motion, it seems to have
been laid under a kind of necessity,
by which it is compell’d to exert these
organs in avoiding whatever is hurtful,
and in chusing whatever is apparently
beneficial, to the Body.
’Tis evident, from the laws of the
Circulation, that when the Motion of
the Blood through the Lungs is stop’d,
for a short time, the right Ventricle of
the Heart must be violently distended,
and consequently severely stimulated.
This strong irritation may bring the
Ventricle into a vigorous contraction,
which is all that is wanted to put the
admirable machine again in motion;
for, as soon as the right Ventricle discharges
itself into the Pulmonary Artery,
’tis plain, from the laws of hydraulics,
that the Blood must move in
the Pulmonary Veins; and therefore
the pressure on these vessels must be
overcome. Thus the circulation of the
Blood will be renew’d, and the vast
distention of the vessels about the Heart,
will rouse the attention of the Mind
to change the uneasy position of the
Body as soon as possible; which will
alter the direction of the Heart’s center
of gravity, and therefore take the pressure
off the Pulmonary Veins and inferior
Auricle, and by that means afford
a free passage to the Blood through
the Lungs. In this manner people
may recover, without any external assistance.
’Tis highly probable that the Motion of
the Blood is renew’d before any of the
Voluntary Motions are recovered; for
we never find that any of the Voluntary
Motions remain after the Motion of the
Heart ceases; and the surprising process
of generation shews, that the first
Motion observable in animal Bodies, is
that of the Heart14. We have many
instances, in Brutes, of the Heart’s
Motion continuing long after the action
of the Voluntary Muscles is quite destroy’d15.
It is not improbable, that the
human Heart would contract itself after
Death, if the same experiments
could, with any degree of humanity,
be tried on it, that are made on the
Hearts of Brutes: and the great Lord
Bacon gives an instance of a criminal’s
Heart, which he saw, after torn from
the Body, leap up and down for several
minutes16.
In a severe fit of the Night-mare,
when the Motion of the Blood, and
consequently the Motion of the Heart,
is stop’d, the Mind, must be in a terrible
agony; and the only chance it
has for further communication with
the Body, depends upon the vigour
and sensibility of the right or superior
Ventricle of the Heart; for, if it be
not able to push the Blood through the
Lungs, and overcome its own weight
at the same rime, de Vita Actum est.
From what has been said it appears,
that lying on the Back is a dangerous,
uneasy position, and should be carefully
avoided, even when we are awake.
I believe few can lie long on the Back
without feeling an uneasiness in the
Breast, which is soon remov’d by turning
on either Side: but when People
are buried in sleep, and are incapable
of that action, the consequence is dreadful,
for the reason often mention’d.
We may be convinc’d, that, if lying
on the Back would not impede the
Vital Motions, nature would have directed
us to chuse that position in sleep,
because it requires scarcely any muscular
action. But, on the contrary, we find
that most of the human species prefer
lying on either Side.
As colonel Townshend’s case is a
remarkable instance of the dangerous
effects which may proceed from lying
on the Back, and as it may serve to
illustrate my theory of this Disorder,
I shall here quote it at full length, that
the reader may the more readily observe
the analogy between his mechanical
suppression of the Vital Motions, and
a fit of the Night-mare, It is thus related
by Doctor Cheyne, in his English
Malady17.
The CASE of the honourable
Colonel Townshend.
“Colonel Townshend, a gentleman
of excellent natural parts, and
of great honour and integrity, had
for many years been afflicted with
a nephritic complaint, attended with
constant vomitings, which had made
his life painful and miserable. During
the whole time of his illness, he
had observ’d the strictest regimen,
living on the softest vegetables and
lightest animal foods, drinking asses
milk daily, even in the camp: and
for common drink Bristol-water,
which, the summer before his death,
he drank on the spot. But his illness
increasing, and his strength decaying,
he came from Bristol to Bath
in a litter, in autumn, and lay at
the Bell-Inn. Doctor Baynard (who
is since dead) and I were called to
him, and attended him twice a day
for the space of a week; but his
vomitings continuing still incessant,
and obstinate against all remedies,
we despair’d of his recovery. While
he was in this condition, he sent
for us early one morning: we waited
on him, with Mr. Skrine his Apothecary
(since dead also;) we found
his senses clear, and his Mind calm,
his Nurse and several Servants were
about him.
“He had made his will and settled
his affairs. He told us he had sent
for us to give him some account of
an odd sensation, he had for some
time observ’d and felt in himself:
which was, that composing himself
he could die or expire when he pleased,
and yet, by an effort or somehow,
he could come to life again;
which it seems he had tried before
he had sent for us. We hear’d this
with surprize; but as it was not to
be accounted for from any common
principles, we could hardly believe
the fact as he related it, much less
give any account of it; unless he
would please to make the experiment
before us, which we were unwilling
he should do, lest, in his
weak condition, he might carry it
too far. He continued to talk very
distinctly and sensibly above a quarter
of an hour about this (to him)
surprising sensation, and insisted so
much on our seeing the tryal made,
that we were at last forced to comply.
We all three felt his Pulse first:
it was distinct, though small and
thready; and his Heart had its usual
beating.
“He composed himself on his Back,
and lay in a still posture for some
time; while I held his Right-hand,
Doctor Baynard laid his Hand on
his Heart, and Mr. Skrine held a
clean looking-glass to his Mouth.
I found his Pulse sink gradually,
’till at last I could not feel any, by
the most exact and nice touch. Doctor
Baynard could not feel the least
motion of his Heart, nor Mr. Skrine
the least soil of breath on the bright
mirror he held to his Mouth; then
each of us by turns examin’d his
Arm, Heart, and Breath, but could
not, by the nicest scrutiny, discover
the least symptom of life in him.
“We reasoned a long time about
this odd appearance as well as we
could, and all of us judging it inexplicable
and unaccountable, and
finding he still continued in that
condition, we began to conclude
that he had indeed carried the experiment
too far, and at last were
satisfied he was actually dead, and
were just ready to leave him.
“This continued about half an hour,
by nine o’clock in the morning in
autumn. As we were going away,
we observed some motion about the
Body, and upon examination found
his Pulse and the motion of his Heart
gradually returning: he began to
breathe gently and speak softly; we
were all astonished to the last degree
at this unexpected change, and after
some further conversation with him,
and among ourselves, went away
fully satisfied as to all the particulars
of this fact, but confounded and
puzzled, and not able to form any
rational scheme that might account
for it. He afterwards called for his
attorney, added a codicil to his will,
settled legacies on his servants, received
the sacrament, and calmly
and composedly expired about five
or six o’clock that evening. Next
day he was opened (as he had ordered)
his Body was the soundest and
best made I had ever seen; his Lungs
were fair, large, and sound; his
Heart big and strong, and his Intestines
sweet and clean; his Stomach
was of a due proportion, the Coats
sound and thick, and the villous
Membrane quite entire. But when
we came to examine the Kidneys,
though the left was perfectly sound,
and of a just size, the right was
about four times as big, distended
like a blown Bladder, and yielding,
as if full of pap; he having often
passed a wheyish liquor after his
urine, during his illness.
“Upon opening this Kidney, we
found it quite full of a white chalky
matter, like plaister of Paris, and all
the fleshy substance dissolved and
worn away, by what I called a Nephritic
Cancer. This had been the
source of all his misery; and the
symptomatic vomitings, from the irritation
on the consentient Nerves,
and quite starv’d and worn him
down. I have narrated the facts
as I saw and observ’d them deliberately
and distinctly, and shall leave
to the philosophic reader to make
what inferences he thinks fit: the
truth of the material circumstances
I will warrant.”
In this gentleman’s case we may observe,
that the contractile power of his
Fibres was very much weaken’d, their
sensibility in a great measure destroy’d,
and his vital energy far exhausted, by
the long and severe irritation in his
Kidney; and that, when he composed
himself on his Back, the motion of the
Blood through the Lungs was easily
stop’d, in the manner above-mention’d,
viz. by the pressure of the Heart upon
the left Auricle and Pulmonary Veins;
to, which may be added, a small degree
of volition in restraining the organs
of respiration. In this dead state,
we are told, he lay half an hour; in
which time the greater part of Blood
was drove into the Veins, as generally
happens soon after respiration stops.
Hence the right Ventricle must have
been greatly distended and severely
stimulated by the refluent Blood, ’till
at length it was brought into a strong
contraction, which put the Blood again
in motion through the whole Body,
and a small spark of vital vigour still
remaining, continued it so for eight
hours afterwards.
The Mind too, in this case, as in
many others of the like kind, was probably
tir’d of its communication with
the Body, and was willing to take its
flight from an habitation in which it
felt so much pain.
I have offered this account to the
curious, not because I think it altogether
satisfactory, but hope, that its
insufficiency may induce others to give
one more adequate.
If colonel Townshend had not compos’d
himself on the Back, could he
have produc’d that surprising effect?
If he had been turn’d on his Side, would
he not have sooner recover’d? Were
not the Doctors very blameable for offering
to go away without using some
means to recover him?
It is observable, that when People
are far exhausted by Diseases, and are
on the brink of dissolution, they generally
lie on their Backs, because they
have not muscular force sufficient to
support the Body on either Side.
From what has been said concerning
the supine portion of the Body, it appears,
that it helps considerably to close
this scene of life, by stopping the
Blood in the Lungs. Hence the immortal
Boerhaave observ’d, “18Proximam
mortis causam, et ultimum
ferme omnium Lethalium morborum
effectum esse Peripneumoniam.”
If then the supine position has such
a remarkable effect in stopping the
Motion of the Blood, and consequently
in putting an end to this Life, would
it not be prudent to turn People on
their Sides, and keep them so, who are
so far spent in acute Diseases, that,
they are unable to poize themselves in
that salutary position? Would it not
be often a means of prolonging the fatal,
and of promoting an happy crisis?
When the force of an acute Disorder,
and the strength of Nature are
nearly equal, would not the weight
of the Heart cast the ballance?