A CHRONICLE OF JAILS — PREFATORY NOTE — A CHRONICLE OF JAILS — I.
DARRELL FIGGIS
“Jail Journals are always a fascinating
study. The self-recorded
thoughts and impressions of man
forcibly isolated from his fellows
in the solitude of the jail have a
certain interest which is hard to explain.
This is the case even when
the recorder is a criminal. But
when, as in the present instance,
the individual is a highly cultured
‘political felon’ making his first
acquaintance with the means and
methods which twentieth century
civilisation has provided for the reformation
of those who transgress
its laws, then, indeed, we have in
such a one’s ‘Jail Journal’ something
of surpassing interest.”—Mac.
THIRD EDITION
DUBLIN: THE TALBOT PRESS LTD.
BY THE SAME AUTHOR
POETRY
A Vision of Life (1909)
The Crucibles of Time (1911)
Queen Tara: A Tragedy (1913)
The Mount of Transfiguration (1915)
NOVELS
Broken Arcs (1911)
Jacob Eltham (1914)
Children of Earth (Shortly)
STUDIES
Shakespeare: A Study (1911)
Studies & Appreciations (1912)
The Lyric Cry: An Anthology (Shortly)
William Carleton
In “Every Irishman’s Library” (Shortly)
A
CHRONICLE
OF JAILS
DARRELL FIGGIS
DUBLIN
THE TALBOT PRESS
LIMITED
1918
THIRD EDITION
Printed at The Talbot Press, 89 Talbot Street, Dublin
TO
THE LADY AT THE GATE
The following pages were written
mainly as a record for myself of days
in which one’s private interest crossed a
wider national interest, and which therefore
seemed worthy of being set down with some
care and faithfulness. In passing them for
publication now it is necessary for me to
apologise for their incompleteness in certain
particulars. That incompleteness is due to
no fault of mine. It has been arranged to
rectify this by an edition at a subsequent
date, when the contrast of edition with
edition will reveal other matters relative to
these days.
D. F.
“On the Run,”
28th May, 1917.
By Darrell Figgis
Tuesday, April 25th, 1916, was filled with
sunshine, in token of the summer that was on
the way, while a keen wind from the north
came in reminder of the winter that was passing.
The winter had been bad, and the spring but
poor, so that work on the land was delayed, and
there had been no fishing for the year. Yet
these things had not served me ill, for I had
been tied all hours with a book overdue with
the publisher. For some months I had been
struggling with Calendars of State Papers, in
which in their introductions English editors
revealed so candidly the prejudice that marked
their work. So that I waited about the house
during the morning, loth to begin work, and
listening to the voices that came up from the
land. The spring work was in full swing.
Voices of men, voices of women, and the barking
of dogs, flowed over the land pleasantly.
Nothing seemed further removed from the day
and its work than the noise of war.
Moreover, the post was late. This was
another excuse for keeping from the desk. I
looked along the half mile of the road till it
bent behind the heath, looking for the rider
on the horse that was our only connection with
the big world.
It was not till some hours after noon that,
looking along the road for the post that was so
unaccountably late, I saw a friend making her
way toward the house on her bicycle. As she
came nearer and dismounted I could see the
traces of tears on her cheeks, and wondered.
“The post is very late,” I said.
“There is no post,” she replied, “but there’s
terrible news. There has been fighting in
Dublin. They say Dawson Street is full of
dead and wounded men. The Volunteers hold
the General Post Office, the Bank of Ireland,
and a number of buildings all over Dublin.
They’ve been attacking the Castle, but I cannot
find out what happened there. The soldiers
are attacking them everywhere with machine
guns, and they say the slaughter is terrible.”
The mountains stood in the sunshine, calm
and splendid, with a delicate mist clothing their
dark sides softly. The sea stretched out to the
western horizon, its winter rage laid by, the sun
glinting in the waves of the offshore wind like
the spears of a countless host, and the islands
of the bay, from Clare to Inish Bofin, lay in its
waters like wonderful jewels that shone in the
sun. Into this world of delicate beauty came
this news, this tale of yet another attempt to
win for a land so beautiful the freedom that
other lands knew. It was not strange that the
mind found some difficulty in adjusting itself
to perceive a tale that came like a stream of
blood across the day.
A week or so before, I had had a letter from
Sheehy Skeffington telling me that the situation
in Dublin was very strained. The constraint
of the Censor was over the letter, and so little
news was told. One knew, of course, that
Dublin Castle was only looking for a chance
to seize the Volunteer leaders, and one knew that
the Volunteers were stiff and pledged to the
utmost resistance. And Sheehy Skeffington’s
letter conveyed little more than that the situation
was daily becoming more and more
strained.
I turned for more news.
“Oh, I don’t know any more,” came the
response. “The engine-driver of the Mail
brought whatever news there is. He said that
the Volunteers held most of the railway stations,
and that the bridges were blown up and the
tracks destroyed. Fighting was going on
throughout the city when he left. That’s what
he says anyway, but nobody knows what to
believe. It’s terrible to think of. The whole
country was coming round to our way of
thinking, business men and responsible men
everywhere were waking up with your financial
agitation and other things; and now it’s all
spoilt. Everything will be worse than ever
now.”
Already the news was spreading about the
place, and knots of men were standing on the
road in discussion. It was impossible to rest
in the house, and so we set off through the
villages to see if any further news could be
learned. In one of the villages a Sunday’s
paper was discovered, in which appeared the
General Order by Eoin MacNeill, as President
and Chief of Staff of the Volunteers, countermanding
manœuvres that had been ordered for
Sunday—Easter Sunday. That only complicated
the matter. “Owing to the very critical
position”—what critical position? What was
the cause of the order? And if “each individual
Volunteer” had been ordered to refrain
from “parades, marches, or other movements,”
how then came it about that there should be
this news of fighting? The original manœuvres,
apparently, had been ordered for Sunday,
whereas this news told of trouble that had
broken out on Monday.
It was perplexing. The only thesis into
which all the available parts seemed to fit
was that it was discovered that Dublin Castle
proposed to take advantage of the manœuvres
on Easter Sunday to disarm the Volunteers,
and, finding itself baulked by this countermanding
order, had attacked headquarters and
the local centres on the following day. That
tallied with Sheehy Skeffington’s letter, and
was also all of a piece with the document which
Alderman Kelly had read at a meeting of the
Dublin Corporation some days previous. And
that was accepted by us all as the most likely
theory to account for the facts.
It was a strange day. It was a strange week.
If one’s countrymen were being attacked, pretty
plain and clear one’s duty seemed; but how
to put it into operation? Over eighteen months
before—after the gun-running at Howth—I
had been in command of the Volunteers for
the county, and at the time of the split I had
sought to hold both sides together in the
county.
Since then I had held to my desk.
Whereas once there had been five
thousand Volunteers in the county, now two
hundred exceeded their number.
The days were full of anxiety. A few of the
older people, in secure possession of their
pensions, cursed the “Sinn Feiners” roundly.
But most were perplexed, and told one another
tales of those who in elder days had died for
Ireland. There was little else to tell. The air
was thick with rumours: rumours that were
contradicted as soon as they came. It was
said that Cork and Limerick were “up,” and
that Kerry had seized the cable and wireless
stations. This was contradicted; and affirmed
again. Wexford, it was said, was “up,” and
the whole county in a blaze. Hard on this
followed news that Drogheda and Dundalk had
risen and tried to destroy the railroads leading
to the north. This last was the only exact
piece of news that came from the east coast.
More precise news came from Co. Galway,
nearer home. The east coast news did not
reach us till Wednesday and Thursday; but
on Tuesday came news that Co. Galway
was “up,” and that the Volunteers there were
under the command of Liam Mellowes, who had
returned from exile in England, disguised as a
priest, and Kenny, a famous footballer. It
was stated that they had marched on the city
of Galway, but had retired from there under the
fire of gunboats, and had turned on Athenry,
where they had encamped on one of the Department’s
farms. Thursday and Friday reported
that this force had marched on Athlone
and had destroyed the bridge there; but that
they were under retreat before a strong force of
military with artillery.
This was the only piece of news that
attempted to give details. Of Dublin no
details could be learned, except that on the
Monday Lancers had charged down O’Connell
Street, but had broken in disorder under a
heavy fire and had fled, leaving many slain.
It was not till Thursday that the news of the
taking of the Bank of Ireland was contradicted;
and at the same time it was reported that
Dublin Castle was not taken. Buildings such as
Boland’s Mill, Jacob’s Factory, and the Four
Courts, were said to be in possession of the
Volunteers, who were resisting desperately;
but these names were not mentioned with
any touch of authenticity, but rather like the
names and symbols of a fantastic legend.
It was difficult to know what to believe or
know. Each succeeding day, instead of clearing
the air with more precise news, thickened the
rumours that flew, until even what finally transpired
to be true seemed to possess the least
likelihood of truth. The police posted reassuring
bulletins on the telegraph poles, but nobody
gave any heed to these. They were read, and
turned from in silent, deep distrust. From them
first came the news that Sir Roger Casement
had attempted to land on the coast of Kerry
with rifles from a German transport, but that he
had been arrested on landing in a small boat,
and that the transport with rifles had been
sunk. “German help is now at the bottom
of the sea,” declared the notice. Nobody
believed any particle of the notice. The fact
that a few of the old-age pensioners clutched
the news to themselves so avidly only deepened
the distrust.
From the coastguards on Wednesday news
was circulated that the German Navy had
attacked in force on the East Coast of England,
in the attempt to effect a landing for troops;
but that all the German fleet was sunk and the
English fleet had lost two battleships. One of
the coastguards’ wives, however, the following
day was heard to state that not two, but eight
battleships had been sunk on the English side;
and this spread swiftly through the villages.
Little comment was made on the change in the
story; and that fact was more significant than
many words.
II.
Such were the days of an anxious week.
None knew what to believe, what to trust,
or what to distrust. Work was impossible.
Sleep even was almost impossible. We could
but drift about and wait, when to do so seemed
almost like a tragic cowardice. What proved
finally to be well-grounded of the rumours
that flew were disbelieved. What proved to be
false were the only matters in which any reliance
was placed. None doubted, for instance, that
Cork and Limerick were “up,” or that Wexford
County was in a blaze, or that Ballina, quite
near home, had captured Killala Bay. None
placed much reliance in the rumours of fierce
fighting round Boland’s Mill and Jacob’s Factory.
None doubted that Athlone Bridge had been
blown up and that the Galway boys were retreating
from the town, contesting every foot of the
way against a large English force. None
believed in the landing and capture of Casement.
One of the county papers published a special
edition on Thursday recording all the rumours.
“The Mayo News,” however, refused in its
edition on the Saturday to print or give ordinary
circulation to any rumours, and advised its
readers to wait patiently until some reliable news
was to hand. The question of food had become a
matter of alarm, for now that the Rising had
lasted a week, it might well last much longer,
with strange results to follow. And a good
part of one’s efforts were occupied with discovering
where flour was available.
Then on the Monday came news that Padraic
Pearse had surrendered, and that the Commandants
under him were accepting the order,
though reluctantly. The first week’s strain was
released, but the mood of the people began to
make a slow change, such a change as Pearse
had foreseen. Already in the first week that
change has appeared; but the news now told
of defeat, an ancient tale in Ireland, full of
old honour. On Tuesday the mail was resumed.
Papers came and were passed eagerly
from hand to hand. The people were afraid,
but sullen. Martial law gave unlimited
power to the peelers, who continued in
bands of three and four with carbines
slung over their shoulders along the roads;
but the Rising was already beginning to
take its place among Ireland’s tragic efforts
for freedom. The causes were not known;
men had, in fact, ceased to wonder whether
it had been a planned Rising or a provoked
resistance. The outstanding fact was its utter
failure; and that became its greatest success,
for so it became kneaded into a history never
very far from an Irishman’s emotional consciousness.
And when the further news came
that a large part of the city of Dublin was in
ruins as the effect of artillery fire, and when
steadily through the week the tale came of
execution succeeding to execution, the sullenness
changed to exasperation. Even those who
during the Rising had been whole-hearted in
their denunciation of it, became bitter of
speech.
Not the least cause inducing this were the
wholesale arrests that were being reported from
all over the country. I had already been
warned, many months previously, that my
arrest had been determined for the very first
chance I gave certain persons at Dublin Castle.
The warning had come through a friendly
channel, and I had accepted it as a compliment
to my intrusions in public affairs. But now the
case was different, for one’s political opponents
were clothed with unlimited power. Moreover,
there was another thing that gave me reason to
fear.
Yet when that week was passed, and the
greater part of the next, I began to think that
my schedule would never be called, in spite of
the fact that each day’s paper recorded a general
sweep-up all through the country. On May
10, I went to bed late as usual. I had been
setting potatoes all day, and had been working
making a precis of State Papers till late at night.
I retired at about two o’clock in the morning.
As I turned into bed, a strong presentiment
came on me suddenly, almost like an oppression,
that I was to be arrested the following morning.
It was so strong that I thought to wake my
wife; but, feeling ashamed of it, I lay wakeful
and wondering.
III.
Two hours later I was wakened by the heavy
tread of many feet down the road. A large
number of men were passing round the house.
We leapt out of bed, and, peering through the
windows, could see two peelers at each window,
with rifles at the “ready.”
A man who was down on the foreshore, with
my house between him and the village, afterwards
described the scene. The whole force
of eighteen peelers, three sergeants, and a
district inspector, had charged down my
boithrin at the double—charged down on a
house in which one man, one woman, eight hens
and fifteen chickens lay asleep. There was
little need for so desperate an attack.
Agitated counsels could point no better way
than a peaceful surrender; so I went out to
the porch, and through the window spoke to
the district inspector. I told him that my wife
was dressing, and that I would stand there in
his sight if he would give her a few moments
in which to put a few clothes about her before
his men took possession of the house. He
agreed. But the local sergeant had other notions
of the proper and fitting thing to be done on so
auspicious an occasion. Some baulks of timber
were lying about the house, and with these, and
some heavy rocks, he set about to batter down
the doors.
Two peelers came into the bedroom with me
while I dressed, while the others tied every
available piece of paper that could be found into
parcels. And after a hurried breakfast I was
borne off on a motor car for Castlebar Jail, with
a peeler sitting each side of me, and one in front,
beside the driver, with loaded carbines. It
was a cold, miserable morning, and a hurricane
of wind and rain swept about the car.
IV.
Castlebar was my first jail. I was more
fortunate than many who were swept-up during
those days. I was at least accorded a prison-cell.
Compared with these things, which I learned
afterwards, my condition was kingly. I was
treated as an ordinary criminal.
The events of the day had presumably come
with too great a shock to make much effect, for
I was all the time strangely unperturbed and
calm. It was only when all my things had been
taken from me and I was placed in a reception-cell
that the reaction came. A reception-cell
is about two-thirds the size of an ordinary cell,
with only a small window, and very dark. Its
only furniture is a little stool. When the door
clanged against me and the key grated in the
lock, an almost overpowering desire came on
me to shout aloud and batter on the door with
my fists. That was succeeded by a feeling of
utter helplessness. Tears had need to be controlled.
I remember resolving never to permit
the caging of a bird, although that had always
been a principle with me. For now the principle
took a new and poignant shape.
I was left there an hour or so (time ceased to
count when emotion became so much more
heavily charged) before being removed to my
allotted cell. Castlebar Jail is constructed
like the letter V. The building runs down each
side of the V, with a high wall connecting the
base, thus making a triangle of the whole. Each
wing contains one line of cells, on each of the
two floors, in the outer wall. The space included
in the triangle is open to the sky, is floored with
flints (up through which two daisies nevertheless
grew), and is used as a special exercise yard.
The main large yard lies beyond the left wing.
Two distinctive features of Castlebar Jail stand
out in my memory as contrasted with the English
jails I was to visit. The English jails were
built of red brick, warm to the eye. Castlebar
Jail was built of grey granite, cold and forbidding,
like a dungeon. On the other hand, the
cells and passages of the English jails were
floored with stone, whereas Castlebar Jail was
floored with timber. I was to appreciate the
virtue of this later. One other difference is
worthy of note. All the English jails were of
considerable size. Castlebar Jail is quite small.
The difference is noteworthy because it signified
a difference in the number of criminals expected,
and in fact, as I learnt while there, Castlebar
Jail had been specially re-opened because of the
Rising-Out.
The reception cell in which I had been placed
lay on the ground floor of the right-hand wing,
near the entrance at the apex. My appointed
cell was on the first floor of the left-hand wing,
near the base. There I saw for the first time,
what was later to become a familiar sight in
other places—the equipment of a cell. In the
far left-hand corner stood the bed-board, raised
on end against the wall, with blankets draped
over it. At its base was coiled the mattress.
In the middle of the right-hand wall stood the
little table, with a stool beside it; and on the
wall hung a copy of the prison rules.
A cheerless morning, a cheerless experience,
and a cheerless abode. Even grimness, that
faithful consolation in adversity, was hard to
summon. I put down my bed-board and
stretched the mattress upon it, wishing to forget
everything in sleep. But in a short while the
warder passing on his round looked through
the spyhole in the door. The key grated in the
lock, and I was roughly told to put up the
board at once and to arrange the things as I
had found them. No bed-board was allowed
to remain down after five o’clock in the morning
or to be put down before half past eight at
night.
The warder was a dark-visaged man, with a
harsh northern accent. He shouted when he
spoke as though he addressed a herd of cattle.
He was a fair specimen on the warder side of an
inhuman system, and one could imagine from his
manner the men whom he was accustomed to
handle. One could imagine, too, the soulless
beings prisoners must inevitably become under
such a man and with such surroundings. Either
they must become meek and cringing, or, in the
effort to defy so abject a fate, they must become
turbulent and violent. The former meant a
life of peace; the latter meant a life of ceaseless
torture; but the latter was at any rate a more
honourable estate. After shouting threats and
abuse at me with which the whole prison resounded—after
informing me that he would soon
dress me into shape, grand and all as I was—the
warder went out, leaving me feeling as though
I had been pitched into a cesspool.
Yet his visit was salutary. It whipped one
out of one’s misery, and gave one something to
fight for. I turned to the rules on the wall
and read them carefully and completely. The
jail having been newly re-opened, the Governor
was a Chief Warder acting as Governor. (This
I afterwards perceived, for I did not then know
the distinction between Chief Warders and
Governors.) Later in the morning he entered
to give me my instructions for the day; and
when he did so, I had sufficiently mastered the
section relating to “Prisoners Awaiting Trial”
to interrogate him on its application to myself.
I claimed the right to books, to tobacco, to
daily newspapers, to daily letters out and in,
to daily visitors, to my own meals ordered
from the town, and to getting another prisoner,
if I so wished it, to clean out my cell
each day.
Whatever was there to be claimed, I claimed.
At first he sought to put me by. But when I
compelled him to an admission that I was at
least a “Prisoner Awaiting Trial” then I
claimed the fulfilment of the rights accorded to
that type of prisoner. It required some address
at first to get him to converse, for the usual
method was harshly and instantly to strike down
any attempt at conversation. It was necessary
at first, quite casually and calmly, to ask an
interpretation of the rules; and then, once the
net of discussion was cast, it was not so difficult
to hold him in its toils.
He looked at me as though he wished he had
removed the troublesome rules. “You forget,”
he said, “these aren’t ordinary times. You
are under martial law now. The soldiers are
the masters of us all now, so they are. I amn’t
very sure that I know where I am myself. Rules
don’t apply now. Nothing applies. I get my
instructions from day to day. They might take
you out to-morrow morning and shoot you,
so they might, and nobody to save you. Isn’t
the whole of the City of Dublin in ruins? I
cannot give you but what I’m bid, and those
rules don’t relate to you—they don’t relate to
anybody.”
He granted me permission, however, to send
out for my meals, if I so wished it, and to write
one letter each day, on a sheet provided for that
purpose. As a tally against the failure of my
other rights he agreed that I might keep my
bed-board down for certain hours of the day
a concession that very much perplexed my
northern warder.
I learnt from the other prisoners afterwards
that this Governor was very rough and harsh
with them. At first he was so with me; but
finally he shewed me as much kindliness as was
possible under the circumstances. He did so
in a strange way. He would enter my cell and
shout at me as harshly as at any; and then he
would close the door, sit on my stool, and begin
to talk quite humanly. Such conversations
would conclude as brusquely and sharply as they
began. Thus a certain kinship emerged between
us. We were both Irishmen, with a stranger’s
martial hand against us both, thrusting me into
jail, and abrogating his rules. In that mood he
always spoke to me as one fellow-countryman
might to another of some unintelligible foreigner
that had come into our land; and then he would
remember that he was leagued with the foreigner,
whereas I was pledged against him, when he
would make some curt remark and leave me.
V.
Later in the morning I heard the jingle of the
warder’s keys, the grating of locks, and the
tramp of feet down the wooden passage outside.
Presently it came to my turn, and my door was
flung open. When I made no move, my warder
appeared in the doorway with angry countenance
to ask me what I was doing.
“Am I wanted?” I asked.
“You’re to come out to exercise, and look
sharp. If you’ve a coat there, bring it with
you, it’s raining.”
Through the small high window, ribbed with
heavy bars and paned with thick, dirty glass,
it was impossible to say what sort of a day passed
by outside. The different texture of the twilight
within was the only indication.
I was taken to the big yard, and there, for the
first time, I saw my fellow-prisoners. There
was an Excise Officer, two men whom I did not
know, and two Gaelic League organisers. One
of these last, as I entered the yard, threw
up his hand in a Connacht salute, and greeted
me: “ ” It was surely
a strange welcome to a prison yard; and
the warder’s voice barked out across the
yard: “Stop that talking there.” I was
instructed to keep my distance from the others
behind and before, and in silence we all walked
round and round the yard under a cold drizzling
rain.
Afterwards I learnt that a large batch of
Westport men had been sent to Dublin two days
before, and that the prison was now beginning
to fill up again. This, apparently, was the
reason of the delay in my arrest. The police
could only arrest as the prisons gave them space.
For Ireland’s prisons were not able to keep
pace with this new (and yet not so very new)
manufacture of criminals.
For an hour we marched round in silence;
and then we were taken in for our dinners.
The two Gaelic League organisers had been
appointed as the prison orderlies. Warders
never do any work, that being an offence to the
relative height at which they are placed; all
work is done by prisoners under their direction.
Therefore, Sean Seoighe brought me in my
dinner; and when I in my ignorance asked for
a knife and spoon with which to eat it, he, on
his week-old experience of jails, passed quickly
out into the passage to control his mirth, leaving
me to the astonishment of the warder, who asked
me if I knew where I was. The astonishing
nature of my request seemed to rob the warder
of his asperity, for he went out in silence, leaving
me to an old horn prison spoon.
At three o’clock we were taken out again
for exercise, and by that time I had already
fallen into prison craft. Old criminals, I was
told, develop it to such an extent that their
communications with one another, in the friendships
they establish, become almost as complete
as in ordinary life, despite the close scrutiny
under which they are kept at all times. I can
well understand it; for here were we, new to
the game, and without any experienced hand
among us, bringing all our wits to work in order
to establish communication with one another—that
communication between man and man
without which life is as unhealthy as a standing
pool. Our minds became cunning and crafty;
the whole being became watchful and alert for
opportunities that had to be caught swiftly
as they passed, while the outward manner maintained
a deceptive innocence. The result was
not conscious; or at least it was only half-conscious;
for a new kind of reflex seemed to
be developed. As we walked round the yard
for instance, we timed our journey with the
warder, who walked up and down a small path
by the prison wall. The result was that we were
walking toward the far end of the yard as he
walked away from us toward the prison door.
Thus his back would be turned just as we
reached the most favourable part of our round,
and by that time the distances between us
would have become reduced as though quite
naturally. It was a manœuvre that, ordinarily,
would have been difficult to execute, yet it was
managed quite simply, and, as it were, naturally.
Then, as we passed round the favourable bend—while
the warder was walking away from us
down his little path—a swift conversation would
proceed, in voices pitched just to reach the man
before or the man behind, and without any
perceptible movement of the lips. And by the
time the warder had turned about we were
slowly finishing the bend with lengthening
distances between us, erect, and with calm
faces forward. Thus we came to know who we
all were, where we were taken, the circumstances
that attended our arrests, and soforth.
This play of wit became no small part of the
daily life; and the penalties that were involved
gave spice to existence.
When we were taken back to our cells I had
a fairly exact knowledge of who my fellow-prisoners
were, and who had been there before
me, and when they had been removed. One
became part of a new continuity, and I had
a strange feeling as though I had been in prison
for a long time. Supper was taken at five, and
consisted of prison cocoa and bread. It was
the last meal for the day, and the only thing
left to do was to wait for darkness. In Castlebar
Jail the gas jet projects an inch into the cell,
and is never lit except during the winter months.
For though prisons are sometimes spoken of as
reformatories of character, yet elaborate precautions
are taken to prevent suicide. Hence
the horn spoons. Hence also the rope or wire
netting beneath the landings. Hence the gas
jet, for from anything in the nature of a bracket
a man might hang himself. And such precautions
are very necessary. As I sat in my
cell waiting for darkness to come, I felt for the
first time the beginnings of the system on me.
The blank, bare walls, the high, dark window,
the deathly silence outside, broken only by the
occasional tread of the warder, the jingle of his
keys by his side, and the sound of the cover of
the spy-hole as he slid it aside to spy in upon
me—all these outward things joined, with the
instant repression of every sign of humanity,
by communication with a fellow-prisoner, or
by a word with the warder, to produce a mental
blank and a complete absence of any part of the
rhythm or colour of life. One never sees anything
resembling a smile on warders’ faces: they
seem tutored to graveness or sullenness, as
though they wore masks, and the only human
exchange one can sometimes catch is through the
eyes—a quick flash there will sometimes let one
know that this warder at least is still a man and
has yet not wholly become a machine. So one
never sees flowers in prison (save for one exception
that I was to meet, where the exception was
rooted in literary history); and prison yards
are always floored with shards of flint or coal
slack, or something very like ashes. Colours
are never seen, and I remember later with what
extraordinary joy I feasted my eyes on a blanket
with which I was provided—crimson, and yellow,
and claret—a wonderful thing. Everything is
toneless, colourless, featureless, expressionless,
noiseless (unless the noise be the harsh voice of
a warder) void and unhuman.
In the twilight that thickened in my cell I
sat that first night feeling these influences sink
into my soul—or rather, I felt them advancing
toward me, with intent to blot out the thing that
was I, the personality that was my being, without
which I was not. And I was afraid, afraid as
of some last obscenity. I have read those who
have recommended meditation before such a
grey void, so to purchase the final liquidation
into the great everlastingly-flowing Nirvana.
To such, a prison can be commended. Such a
philosophy has never commended itself to me,
to whom Life is meaningless unless it be for the
production and perfection of personality; and
personality is meaningless unless it be the
utmost differentiation of mind, the utmost
liberty of thought and action, the utmost canvassing
of desire and will, without any regard
to authorities and bans and interdictions, or
monstrous (literally monstrous) attempts at
uniformity, imperial or otherwise. And so I
sat there on my stool beside my little table,
feeling the first pressure of a cold enormity
muffling Life at every turn, seeking to reduce
me to the utter blankness that is its ideal.
The prison system protects itself by a number of
contrivances against the suicide of its victims;
but suicide is indeed the logical outcome of the
system, it is its final perfection. When personality
has been so far repressed that it can make
no demonstration of itself, neither by voice nor
signal; when personality looks upon faces that
are as expressionless as the white-washed wall
and flint-strewn yard; when the mind at last
echoes the blankness it meets with a blankness
as fitting, and the outer world becomes forgotten,
literally forgotten:—what difference is there
between such a state and the final quenching
of the spark of life in a body whose only value
is that a soul inhabits it? The last state is
simply a logical completion of the first.
Thought? I had during my life conceived
of prison as a place where a man could in silence
and solitude think out things. As I sat in my
cell that first night in prison I knew on a sure
insight (what I was later to prove) that this was
all wrong. As though something spake it in
my soul, I knew that thought would become
sluggish and slow, and finally would not exist
at all, until even the effort to recall the names
and faces of friends would be relinquished as
too fatiguing. I knew that; I divined it that
first night instantly; and I was afraid. Some
of the others told me that they wept every
night; and I understood it. But when the
darkness compelled me to make up my bed, I
simply took off my coat and collar and boots,
and rolled the blankets about me as I lay down,
determined that I was going to make a fight
for it.
The following morning, when the Chief Warder
came to see me, I started again on the rules and
regulations. We fought long and hard; and
finally he granted me permission to get a daily
paper and to smoke one pipe a day. “Only,”
he said, “you must smoke it outside, and you
must smoke it in a special yard by yourself
where the smell of the tobacco won’t annoy the
others.” I agreed; and before he left me he
took the “Rules” from the wall and bore them
away with him.
So I took my exercise that morning by
myself, in the small yard between the forks of
the prison building. My pipe was presented
to me, and my pouch. When the pipe was
filled, I was presented with a match, and I was
watched while I lit up. Then my pouch was
taken away and the door was locked behind me
and I was left alone.
The yard was very small, and triangular. It
had apparently not been much used, for the
flints lay loose upon the surface of the ground,
save for one little circle in the centre that had
been trodden hard. Two sides of the triangle
were formed by the prison, the walls of which
rose sheer above me, cold and grey, with
menacing barred windows at regular intervals.
On the third side a high wall of masonry made
the base of the triangle. The day was sunlit,
but the sunlight could only fall across a small
corner of the yard. Two daisies were growing
in the centre of the circle: which I picked, and
instantly regretted the selfishness and vandalism
of the deed.
I walked round and round, smoking my pipe;
but when my pipe was finished, the folly of my
decision faced me. Here I was shut for another
hour on a floor of flints, surrounded by oppressive
grey walls that rose sheer above me, with nothing
to look upon but walls and floor, and high
above me a patch of blue sky, across which
clouds sailed. Deeply I envied the other men
their sight of one another, and their craft and
tricks to outwit the warder. I walked round
and round the little circle, first one way and
then the other; and gave that up. I tried
lying down in the corner, where the sunlight
fell; but found flint shards not the most inviting
of seats. And it seemed an interminable time
before the warder unlocked the door to unloose
me from what had become a refined form of
torture.
Yet I did not admit defeat. As I came
away, the Chief Warder offered me another
pipe in the afternoon, on the same terms;
and I accepted. But that was enough. The
prison cell was better than that little yard,
flint-strewn, beneath grey walls and barred
windows. When I came back in the afternoon
I took occasion to slip up the flap from the spy-hole,
unobserved; and the warder closed the
door without noticing this. So I was enabled
to relieve the tedium of my cell by looking out.
Opposite my spy-hole was a window looking
down into the yard that I had left; and there,
to my astonishment, I saw a hat passing round
and round, coming into sight, and passing out
of sight. The hat just appeared over a bar of
the window, which hid the face of the wearer.
A hat, and no more; like a tantalising glimpse
into another world; but something about that
hat struck me as familiar. It was astonishingly
like the hat of P. J. D., the editor and proprietor
of “The Mayo News,” the one paper that had
refused to print any rumours during the week
of the Rising. Had he then joined me in
jail?
That night when at supper I asked for the
daily letter I had been promised, the Chief
Warder informed me that he had received
instructions from the military authorities that
I was not to be permitted any sort of communication
with the outer world, by letter or by
visit. The previous day I had written to my
wife saying that my daily letters were to be a
sign to her that I was safe and well, and would
show her where I was. I wish no man the
hours I spent that night.
VI.
The next morning I asked the Chief Warder
if he had any labour gang at which I could be
employed, for I dreaded a continuance of the
thoughts that had been with me through the
night.
“I can put you moulding my potatoes,” he
said, with the air of a man who spoke of something
so ridiculous that it disposed of itself.
“Very well,” I said.
“Can you mould potatoes?” he said.
He seemed to be diffident now when his
humour took actual shape.
“I can try,” I said. “I was eight hours
setting them the day before you took me.”
So a Gaelic League organiser, an Excise man,
were employed throughout that day moulding
the Chief Warder’s potatoes; we enjoyed the
work; and we enjoyed it none the less because
of the new warder under whom we were placed.
This warder had made his first appearance, as
far as I was concerned, the previous day. The
mask he wore was not sour, but melancholy;
and that in itself was a great difference. His
voice, too, suggested possibilities. It was
southern, and somewhere muffled in its official
brevity a human quality echoed. I had heard
that quality instantly when, the previous day,
he came into my cell to bid me hasten as he had
others to attend to besides myself. I had not
hastened; but, quite deliberately, I had stood
and looked at him. “’Tis queer criminals you
have these times, warder,” I said. I looked at
him; and he looked at me. Then he went to
the door, looked up and down the passage, and
returned to me. “Faith, you’re right, sir,”
he said. “’Tis a queer sort of criminals these
times.” It would be hard to express all that
he managed to convey in those few words. Perhaps
the melancholy mask he wore was all the
more melancholy because of the thoughts he
could not utter. Strange pass for a man when
his hand is bought against his fellow-countrymen;
and strangest of all when his heart is not
bought with his hand. We had no cause to
regret our warder during that day’s labour;
but I am sure he was not as sorry for us as I
was for him.
He was with us on Sunday also. It being
Sunday, we only received one hour’s exercise
during the morning; and as the Chief Warder
and his other officials had gone to Mass the
warder was in sole charge of us. Therefore we
all had exercise together; and when I entered
the yard I saw that my guess of Friday was
correct, for there was P. J. D. already before
me. He threw up his hand in welcome, and a
smile lit over his face. I passed over and
walked behind him.
There were many new faces there. There
were about sixteen or seventeen of us. Some
were in prison clothes.
Some had come into conflict with English
troops with whom they had been stationed.
I turned to note the others in civilian clothes.
One was an elderly man, with grey beard and
majesterial manner: I never found out who
he was. The man, however, who struck me most
walked just ahead of P. J. D. Tall and athletic
of build, he strode round and round the path,
the very embodiment of wrath. His face, when
I caught a side glance of it as he turned each
bend, was black and lowering. Once as we
came round the corner that served so well for
our quick interchanges, he turned about, took
a quick glance at the warder’s retreating back,
and shook his fist at the prison and all it
signified, and said: “By God, but there’ll be
a big judgment to pay for all this yet.” Then
he strode on again, striking his heels on the
ground. He had probably just completed his
first night in jail; and his emotion had not yet
become transmuted into something more settled
and grim. “Keep your heart up, man, keep
your heart up,” I heard P. J. D. whisper.
“There’s plenty of time before all of us.”
VII.
When I was wakened the following morning
I was informed that I had to be ready for removal
in an hour’s time. The Chief Warder
did not know where I was to go, only that at
six a guard of soldiers would come for me. It
was his opinion that I was to be taken for the
courtsmartial in Dublin. That meant anything;
it meant, to be more precise, whatever the
police desired or intended, for the reign of
terror was abroad in the land, and every
man’s fate was decreed by whatever the police
had decided would make an appropriate chapter
in his leabhran at Dublin Castle, without other
evidence than the evidence of the compilers.
During those days that man was safest who
was permitted to remain in any one place for
a length of time, for presumably the present
orgy of blood and long sentences, of courtsmartial,
and authority on its war-steed champing
the ground, would begin to pall. Nevertheless,
I welcomed the change. Anything
seemed better than inaction. It was better to
go out and take one’s fate than to stay skulking
in a cell. My only anxiety was for my wife,
who would know nothing of my removal, and
from whom it seemed decided to withhold all
knowledge of me.
P. J. D. came down after me to the office
where our “effects” were handed back to us.
We were to be fellow travellers on the road,
and we were marched through the streets of
Castlebar to the Railway Station under a
sergeant’s guard of eight men. It was too early
for the town to be astir, and those who were
abroad seemed rather abashed by the spectacle.
At the station, as the train came in, to my
great joy I was hailed by my wife, who, not
getting the promised daily letter, had travelled
down by the same train that was to take me to
Dublin to discover what was happening. A
little tactful authority with the sergeant included
her in the same carriage with ourselves;
and thus began a co-operation, from without
and from within jail, that was to be of rare
value in the future.
Again I was fortunate in my custodian. The
sergeant belonged to one of the North Staffordshire
battalions that had been rushed over for
the Rising-Out, and he was a kindly, homely man,
very much unlike some of his guard. The
songs that came from the adjoining compartment
were clearly meant to hearten us with
the thought of friendship. There was no
timidity in the choice of theme, and the peeler
who accompanied us (as guide to the strangers
in charge of his own countrymen) was clearly
restive hearing songs it had become his first
instinct to baton. But the sergeant was in
command, and he maintained a strict dignity.
At Athlone our companions next door managed
to convey the state of affairs to others on the
platform, with the result that the cheering crowd
had time to vent their feelings outside our door
before they were swept away. Then a peeler
on the platform beckoned to our sergeant, and
whispered something to him. When he returned
to his seat beside me, I asked him what
had been said to him.
“He was telling me to be careful, as there are
sympathisers of yours in the next compartment
and on the platforms.”
“That doesn’t surprise you, sergeant, does
it?” I asked.
He thought for a moment; then, “No, sir,
it doesn’t,” he said. And after a minute’s
further thought, he added: “It’s easy for me
to see who has the people’s wish, and who has
the unpleasant job. You mustn’t think, sir,
I like it; for I don’t. It wasn’t for this kind
of thing I joined up. Why every nation can’t
manage its own affairs without other nations
butting in, I can’t for the life of me imagine.
I thought it was to stop that kind of thing they
told me I was wanted out in Belgium.”
Apparently he had been driven to thought.
He was a tall, strongly-built man, with a long
head and grave face—the kind of man who
takes life very seriously and very earnestly.
He came from the pottery district, where he had
been employed in some clerical capacity; and
when he told me he was fond of books I knew
at once what kind of company he kept and what
kind of books he read. In that company the
cause of small nationalities had given him
much heart-searching. Very earnestly he had
thought the thing out, and in an international
morality not at all lightly gotten-by, he had
donned khaki, won his stripes, and been dispatched
to Ireland for first service. I have
wondered sometimes how he got on in Belgium.
Perhaps he laid down his life in order that small
nations should have freedom declared as their
indefeasible right.
At Dublin, when I suggested that P. J. D.
and I should hire cars across to Richmond
Barracks, and that he should divide his guard
between us, he willingly accepted the proposal.
VIII.
At Castlebar rigorous care was taken that
P. J. D. and I should not speak with one another.
Care had been taken that we should exercise
apart, and only by the accident of the shortage
of staff on the Sunday had either of us been
able to do more than guess at the other’s
presence. At Richmond Barracks we were
thrown together perforce, and were condemned
to sleep under the one slender blanket.
In the room to which we were consigned there
were already twenty-five others. The officers
who took us up told me that it was known as
the Leaders’ Room: a description that, at that
time, was ... ominous....
From it, De Valera had gone to his life’s sentence;
from it, I was told, Sean MacDiarmada
had gone to his death...;
and there Count Plunkett had been required to
answer for the consciences of his sons. And
a goodly company remained there yet, from
whom we received a hospitality the joviality
of which gave no heed to the courtsmartial that
slowly worked their way along the lists provided
by a diligent officialdom. Presents from
friends were permitted, under supervision; and
food so obtained was put into a common commissariat,
presided over by mighty Sean
O’Mahony, the ruler and president of our company.
From this store we were regaled without
further ado, while he stood between us and the
others who rose to welcome us to our fate. He
would suffer none to approach us with a more
immediate welcome or inquiry until we had had
what we would of the hospitality it was his to
dispense; and then we mixed in the company
into which we had been cast.
So, for the first time I came into touch with
those who had had their part in the Rising.
There were some of the company on whom the
burning yet remained. Most had been through
a historic week, and three had been severely
wounded. In all cases these were leg wounds
from bullets, and two of the number had been
lying on the wooden floor, covered by blankets,
when we entered. Coming as I did from a part
of the country where only wild, whirling rumours
had reached, sound and fury of things that had
and things that had not occurred, there was
something of a thrill in this first touch of the
actual event. One faded into insignificance
beside the simplest follower that had borne
the heat of the day. He would be a man
of little emotion, surely, who did not feel as I
did at that moment, with a touch of awe and
respect kindling in his veins. It seems then to
me a little thing that a man should think and
labour for his country beside those who had
offered dear life for her sake.
Therefore, when one of the wounded men
limped up to me, claiming an acquaintance I
had forgotten, I was anxious to discover from
him where he had fought, and to learn some
details of the fighting. He had, with high
personal courage and ability, filled one of the
commands in the defence of the South Dublin
Union, and was not loth to tell his tale. But
our conversation was overheard, and an uproar
rose.
“He’s going to tell about the South Dublin
Union again. No, no; that can’t be allowed.
We’re tired about the South Dublin Union.”
I protested that I wished to hear. “I’m sorry,
but we can’t permit it. We’ve heard that
story so often that it’s not safe for us to hear it
again. It’s really not safe. If you let him,
he’ll tell it you for a week; but we can’t permit
it; we’ve our nerves to consider.”
So it was. In no way could I extract my
tale, and had to remain without it.
IX.
Richmond Barracks was for the military the
clearing house for rebels; for the police it was
their last chance of a stroke.
Marching tunes are in military orders, and the
men in khaki perceived no difference between
one tune and another; but the little groups
in dark green became twice as sullen, and twice
as anxious to lay their victims by the heels,
one way or another. Without a doubt Richmond
Barracks was of great value from the
dramatic point of view.
We were housed in the second and third
storey rooms of the barracks. The troops
occupied the ground floor, the guards were
posted at the doors and on the landings,
while outside the whole building was enclosed
with barbed wire barricades, guarded again
by soldiers. It was to Richmond Barracks
that the men of the Republican Army were swept
as they surrendered. Some were taken to
Kilmainham and Arbour Hill, the Castle and
other places.
Not till Asquith’s visit were these things
rectified; and even thereafter conditions were
only slowly, and, as it were, grudgingly,
amended. By the time I arrived at the clearing-house,
a fortnight after the Rising had concluded,
the amendment was in progress.
The cause for this was simple. Far more
potent than a very questionable beneficence
in Premiers, was the grim and bitter mood that
had settled on the country. This had to be
propitiated. Asquith’s visit was but a token
of political sagacity; and while I was at Richmond,
the dawning of the same sagacity on the
military mind could be seen in the shape of
extra blankets, extra and better food, benches
to sit on, tables to eat from, knives, spoons and
forks to eat with, and some care for greater
cleanliness. Slowly these things came; not
exactly with a remarkable good humour or good
will; and were received by us, as they came one
by one, with ribaldry and laughter.
Thus, soon after our arrival P. J. D. and I
were apportioned a blanket apiece, and at nightfall,
on the call of the bugle, we were instructed
by the others in their use. We all slept with
our heads to the wall and our feet toward the
centre of the room. We slept in couples for
the better use of our blankets. One blanket
was stretched on the floor, the other served for
coverlet, and our coats made our pillows. So
we slept each night, fully dressed, for the nights
were bitterly cold. It was extraordinary how
soon one’s hip-bones hardened to the floor, and
the simplicity of toilet was a great boon to
anyone who had found dressing and undressing
labyrinths of inconvenience.
In the morning the reveille sounded at six
o’clock; and from then until about eight we were
taken out in squads under armed guards, to
wash at the pumps and washbowls in the yard.
For our meals, we sat where we could or
would, on the ground, or, if one were tactful,
on the window-sills. We were all allowed to
retain up to a pound in cash, and some of the
men had purchased jack-knives from the soldiers.
Others had managed to retain their own pen-knives.
Such men were fortunate, for they
were able at once to proceed with their meals.
The others either waited until an implement
was available, or they did not wait.
Yet all these were but campaigning inconveniences.
The great thing was that we were,
by necessity, permitted one another’s company;
and the utmost joviality prevailed. None would
have thought that in one of the barrack buildings
within sight of our windows, the courtsmartial
were sitting, and that men were being picked
out from the rooms and sent to long terms of
penal servitude. No one knew whose turn
would come next. The selections were, by any
reckoning, an extraordinary hazard. Some who
confidently expected a summons, were passed
over in silence. Others were selected whose
choice was inexplicable, except on the supposition
(which indeed was no supposition)
that some local spite was exerted against them.
Any evening an officer might enter and hand
a man a paper form. That form was a statement
of the case against him, and meant that
on the following day he was to be taken before
the Court Martial. No time was given to
prepare a defence or employ counsel. The
next morning he was taken out. If his case
were not heard, he returned that evening, and
would go forth in the morning; if his case were
heard, he would not return, and we would
know nothing until, in the course of a week or
ten days, his sentence was promulgated in the
papers.
One such case stands out vividly in my
memory because of an interesting personal
relation that was suggested. Thrice a certain
officer had entered, and we had all stood in a
line before him while he, accompanied by a
detective, inspected us each carefully in turn.
Each time he had turned away dissatisfied; and
on the third occasion, as he did so, one of our
number made some jest, at which we all laughed.
Instantly the officer turned about and fixed on
one of our number.
“You’re Captain L——, aren’t you?” he said.
“I am.”
“You were at the Post Office, in charge of the
prisoners?”
“I was.”
“Just so. I didn’t recognise you out of your
uniform. You are the man. I fixed you just
now when you laughed by your gold teeth.”
When he had gone we gathered round L——
to ask him who the man was; and we learned
that he had been a prisoner in the Post Office.
When the Post Office had been set on fire, and
became untenable, the building had been evacuated
in haste. Not until they were filing out
into the street were the prisoners remembered,
and then O’Rahilly had sent L—— back to
bring them out to safety. As the prisoners
were housed in a room next to that in which the
ammunition and high explosives were stored,
beside the lift-shaft, down through which the
sparks were falling, this was a task of some
considerable danger.
X.
Men so selected went off to a criminal’s fate.
Yet the authorities in effect recognised that the
selection turned on a hazard by treating us all
as criminals. Forms were delivered on some
men with charges that astonished none so much
as the recipients; and as there was no evidence
other than police reports offered in support of
such allegations, the only thing in doubt was
the length of the sentence. On the other hand,
men were passed over who were not less astonished
at the passing. But all our finger-prints
were taken. We were afterwards considerably
amused at the assurance given in the English
House of Commons that finger-prints were only
taken “at first” “owing to the difficulty of
identification,” and that they were taken
“under military supervision.” Finger-prints were
taken all the time I was at Richmond Barracks
by a peeler whose descent on newcomers was
greeted with ironic mirth, for he was a familiar
figure as he hung about the barracks like a
hawk, carrying his implements with him. What
mirth we had we made as we went, for all that
it had a grim background; but we were certainly
assisted by comparing the declarations
in Parliament as to our estate with the conditions
we actually endured. And the idea of
any “difficulty of identification” was a joke
more than ordinarily grim. It conveyed a
wonderful conception of Ireland as a land
untracked and uncharted; whereas, in the
most elaborately policed country in the world
the only thing lacking to make our leabhrain
artistically complete was the presence of a
finger-print. And the artists in dark green
were swift to complete their pictures.
Such things, I found, were only treated with
mirth. It was curious to note the way in
which the doings of the police—either of the
R.I.C. or the D.M.P., “two minds with but
a single aim, two hearts that beat as one”—were
received. There was a bitterness in the
ribaldry with which they were greeted, a bitterness
and a certain frosty sting in the mirth; but
there was also the laughter for relief.
Not having been in Richmond Barracks during
the first days of terror, I raised a complaint
the following morning with the medical officer.
I asked his co-operation, as an Irishman who
should resent a national insult. He did resent
it; and as a result, the young officer was
compelled to apologise as a matter of discipline.
Thereafter, that officer appeared no more among
us; but neither did the medical officer.
Yet, in spite of all these things, we had
one another; and that was compensation.
I had heard of most of my companions before,
but had never had the opportunity of meeting
many of them; and I was now glad of the
chance of acquaintance and discussion. In
Richmond the first beginnings appeared of that
cementing of brotherhood among the “prisoners
of war” that was afterwards to take so fine a
form. About a fortnight after my arrival
some of us in our room were offered special
rooms, with two beds in each room; but we all
refused these without any further enquiry
rather than injure or forego that brotherhood.
Our national convictions were the same in
fundamentals, but they took different forms.
Our roots were the same, and they were set in
the same good earth; but the branches and
blossoms were various. From afar, we could
only see the branches and blossoms, and were
chiefly aware of our differences from one another;
but now that we came near one another we
could see that our roots were in the same soil.
Indeed, some came who had few roots to
boast of, but roots were soon generated, partly
by the warmth of suitable companionship,
partly by the heat engendered by their treatment.
And with all, save a possible few exceptions,
a unity and kinship was soon evolved, that
mitigated the hardship of our estate and wiped
away the sense of danger that hung over us all.
Our comradeship softened our hardship in
other ways also. The English Army was
camped round about us to stop all communication
with the outer world except through the
permitted channels. We were allowed two
visits a week. Our visitors stood on one side
of the barbed wire and we stood on the other,
with an armed guard between us. All parcels
and letters had to pass through the censor.
If the parcels contained clothing, we received
them; if they contained food, we did not
receive them. That was a part of the rapacity
of the army we did not appreciate; but there
was another side to it. We were encompassed
about with traders, and so, by uniting our
resources, and by pooling our wits, we were
able to reach the outer world by the very agency
that was intended to obstruct us. The officers
of course knew this, but they were powerless.
And therefore, since accurate accounts of our
treatment were getting out to correct the
pleasing accounts published by the military,
the authorities, in their desire to conciliate
public opinion, were slowly compelled to make
their treatment square with their accounts,
just as they were being slowly compelled to
terminate the courtsmartial that hung over
the barracks, and seemed likely to last for
another year.
Our day began with the Reveille at six, and
concluded with Lights Out, at a quarter past
ten. The intervening hours were spent in
walking up and down the room and in talk.
The only thing that broke the monotony of the
day was the continuous business of the clearing-house.
Large batches of prisoners continued
to arrive from all parts of the country, where
the police were making hay while the sun shone,
to the no small embarrassment of the military,
who seemed likely to have the greater part of
the country delivered upon them. Large
batches were being deported to England; and
there is no doubt that many were deported whom
the military had destined for their courts simply
because it had become impossible to warehouse
the cargoes of humanity that were being landed
on their wharf. And, in slowly diminishing
numbers, men were being selected....
... In the midst of this we lived
suspended until our turn came on the schedules
of the military wharfingers.
XI.
The day on which deportations were due was
always tense and strained throughout. We
were generally warned a day or so in advance
by the soldiers, and sometimes had some of the
names conveyed to us of those who were destined
to go. However they obtained this information,
it was always correct. This meant
that from the time we awoke we were all
restless. About two o’clock an officer would
enter and read a list of names. Each of those
so summoned would be given a knapsack, and
informed that he was to be ready to fall in on
parade outside at half-past two. No more was
said; and no more was needed to be said.
Some were glad to go. It meant their
removal from the danger zone, and implied that
the military did not know all that might have
been known. But these were few. For the
most part men waited anxiously all day, and if
their names were called they made a brief
comment, jocular sometimes, and sometimes
defiant, that intimated the dead weight that had
fallen on them with the news. Whatever
courts-martial might sit, so long as we were
in Ireland we were at home. There was always
the consciousness with us that our own people
were about us and bitterly resented our fate.
Whereas deportation was deportation. Moreover,
one of the men who had been deported a
short time before had been brought back again
for trial, and his tale of what had been meted
out to him in an English jail was not pleasant
to hear. Altogether, this breaking up of bonds
and transference to the conqueror’s own particular
prisons was a thing of dread, however
that dread might be covered by jocularity or
grimness.
The first deportation after my arrival was on
Saturday, May 20th. On that occasion none
was taken from our room. We crowded to the
windows to see the parade and to cheer our
comrades by our presence there; but we
were shouted back by the officers, who were
conducting the parade,
Our very friendship with one another had
become an offence.
The following week there was another list
of deportations. Three from our room were
taken, their places being filled the following
day by new arrivals from the country. On
May 23rd my name was called, with three
others from the room. The previous day I
had had an interview with solicitor and counsel
with a view to getting a statement of the charges
against me and to demanding a trial. An officer
had been present throughout the interview,
although we had protested against his presence.
He was under discipline to the very men against
whom it was our intention to proceed, and it
was a strange thing that he should be present
to learn exactly what our case might be and
how it was our intention to proceed. A further
interview was arranged for two days later, in
order that counsel might turn up certain points
of law. But in the meantime I received notice
that I was to be deported.
I had been, and then was, ill. I was really
unfit to travel, especially under these particular
conditions. But that was a matter easily
mended. When I reported sick on parade I was
taken over to the dispensary and ...
... Others who had
been summoned to the parade were treated in
the same way; and we stood out there till
about half-past four, when our escort arrived.
It was a beautiful afternoon; the sunlight
poured down through a cloudless sky and lay
like a sultry blanket on the ground. There
were about a hundred and fifty of us, in two
companies, for two destinations. We stood
there in ranks with soldiers guarding us, while
officers busied themselves with papers all about
us. I thought of the sun shining on the sea,
and clothing the mountains with a new soft
beauty, and of the summer that began now
to flow back over the earth in Achill. There
was time to indulge in reflection to the full.
At five o’clock our guards handed us over to
the escort. The barrack guard had been comprised
of English troops. The escort was an
Irish regiment. Ironic, that an Irish regiment
should escort Irishmen for deportation to
England. Stranger still when, as we were being
marched through the city, the people crowded
about us to let us know of their sympathy,
and the soldiers were instructed to keep the
people back with their rifle-stocks.
We are sometimes derided as a people rent by
divisions, but the division in this case was due
to the same cause as has created nearly all our
other divisions. That cause was symbolised
by the scene that was enacted that day. In
no way more picturesquely could the fact of a
perpetual military conquest have been staged.
And when, as we marched down along the
quays, most of us saw, for the first time, the
havoc wrought in our capital by the guns of the
conqueror, that only gave the appropriate
scenery without which dramatists have agreed
that the work of their artistry cannot be given
to the world.
At the North Wall we were put on board a
cattle boat. The cattle were herded at one end
of the pens, we were being herded at the other
end of the pens. When it came to my turn
to be penned I was surprised to hear myself
accosted by the Embarkation Officer:
“I’m B——, you know.”
“Certainly,” I replied; “we meet again.”
But I had not the dimmest notion who he was.
“I hope to be in Castlebar soon,” he said.
“I haven’t been back since I went out.”
“Is that so?” I said. “I was in Castlebar a
fortnight ago. I was stopping at the jail.”
He laughed, and turned to P. J. D., who
stood beside me as we awaited our turn to be
penned. His manner was frank and pleasant
and not at all constrained, although his penning
of us was quite efficiently done. I informed
him that I was not well, and asked if certain
accommodation could not be found slightly
more efficient than a cattle pen packed with my
fellows. He promised to see what he could do,
and went off. When he had gone, P. J. D.
informed me that he had been a Volunteer
when I was in command of the county, and
had since gained some distinction in the
European War. Presently he returned, and
conveyed some of us to a room in the forecastle,
where we had seats on which we could
stretch ourselves.
When we arrived in England, however, we
struck quite another atmosphere. Inquisitive
crowds gathered about us who lost no opportunity
of displaying their enmity and hostility.
German prisoners of war might have aroused
an equal curiosity, but they could not have an
equal enmity. Clearly and sharply we stood
out, whether we gathered on railway platforms
or were marched through streets, as nation
against nation, with an unbridgeable hatred
between us. Any attempt on our part to meet
taunt with taunt was at
; and so we were compelled to stand as
the mark of contumely and the target of contempt.
To be sure, that only stiffened us, and
we held ourselves high and unflinchingly before
the crowds. Nevertheless, there was a sickening
in most of us, for Ireland was behind us and we
were utterly in the stranger’s power.
I had lived some years in England, and had
formed many good friendships. Unlike many
of my companions, England and the English
were no strange things to me. Yet I came
then into something utterly strange, foreign,
and hostile. I could not more strangely have
been led captive among the mountains of the
moon, so icy was this world and such leagues
apart from that which I had known.
Everything was coloured by that relation.
One looked on England with new eyes, and old
thoughts became startling new discoveries.
Stafford lay for the most part steeped in slumber
as we were marched through its streets in the
morning, accompanied by a small, inquisitive
crowd. It looked incredibly sleek and prosperous
beside our Irish towns. The villas were
sleek and comfortable; the roads were sleek
and neat; the very grass beside the canal looked
sleek as though nurtured with the centuries.
Everything had an air of being well fed and
well groomed, and quite consciously proud of
the fact that it was part of a prosperous whole,
where no invader’s foot had trampled, where no
spoliation had dared to efface the moss that had
gathered for centuries on the gables, or to rough
the smooth lawns. The villas might be the latest
examples of modernity, yet that was the air
they suggested, for they became part of something
that was smooth and sleek. How different
to our Irish towns, that look as though they—not
the people in them, but they themselves—live
a precarious day-to-day existence. Each
suggests the history of their nation. One has
grown sleek with prosperity, and smooth and
round with the large air of the conqueror, with
shores that have never known invasion. The
other has been hunted from end to end by rapacious
conquest; the forests that were its pride
burnt away the better to root out its people;
the people hunted until they lost the instinct
to build for themselves permanent abodes, and,
more latterly, rack-rented till they stealthily
hid any small savings and kept middens before
their doors, until a show of poverty from being
a disguise became a habit; rising against the
conqueror in a series of revolts foredoomed to
failure, but triumphant in what they spoke of—a
spirit still unbroken; stricken to earth again
by soldiery that marched through the land;
and harnessed by a network of legislative acts
that intended to inhibit industry and commerce
with the nations of the earth, and that succeeded
in their intention. And yet there was no
question of a choice between the two. For
with one individuality had become smoothened
away, the wheel having come full circle;
with the other individuality was sharp and
keen, angular it might be, but alive for the
future.
H. P. and I were speaking of these things
when we arrived at Stafford Jail. It was about
six o’clock in the morning as we were marched
through the gates and lined up outside the
prison. The building looked gloomy and forbidding
as it frowned down on us with its
hundreds of barred windows. It had lately
been used as a detention barracks; that is to
say, as a prison for soldiers, the major part of
the population of England having donned khaki
but not having doffed their sins therewith.
Therefore, it was staffed by military, who received
us from our escort and marched us up
the great building to the cells that had been
allotted us. And once again I heard the key
grate behind me.
XII.
Stafford Jail covers a large space of ground
surrounded by high brick walls, and contains
three prisons, with the usual outhouses, such
as the Governor’s office, the reception-cells, the
cookhouse, laundry, hospital, workshops, and
chapels. In the centre stands the original
prison, known as the Old Prison, a building of
an old type of architecture, with high gabled
roof and large windows. A path ran beside it,
between it and the Governor’s office, and this
path led at each end to the two newer buildings
that face each other and complete the square.
One is known as the New Prison, of menacing
exterior, with small windows heavily barred.
The other is known as the Crescent, because
of its shape. Both are plain solid buildings,
but in the Crescent the windows are large and
less dungeon-like. Windows mean much to
the outward look of a prison, but they mean
much more to its inward life.
In the ordinary life of the jail—if it is at
all possible to speak of a jail containing an
ordinary life—women occupy the Old Prison,
long-sentence and penal servitude men the
New Prison, and short-sentence men the
Crescent. While we were there soldiers under
sentence occupied the Old Prison, and the
Irish Prisoners of War the other two prisons.
Dublin men occupied the Crescent, having been
brought there on Monday, immediately after the
surrender; and the men from the country
districts were put into the New Prison as they
came to hand, together with a few Dublin men
who had been swept up during the week after
the Rising.
Flanking the jail on each side are the Union
and the Lunatic Asylum, and to judge from the
size of all three, the population of that part of
England seems to be in a bad way. Afterwards
I had an opportunity of looking from one
of the higher windows over the walls, and I
could see factory chimneys stretching to the
horizon. Factory chimneys, lunatic asylums,
jails, poorhouses, and sleek suburbia: a pretty
picture of civilization. All the jail buildings
were in red brick, which was at least warm to
the eye. The New Prison held about four
hundred cells, and the Crescent about the
same.
Being one of the later Sweep-up I was placed
in the New Prison. Within, it was not unlike
a church in some ways, chiefly in the matter of
gloom. It was comprised of three wings,
branching from the central hall. Right and left
ran a long high hall, with church-like windows
at each end. Each side formed a wing, and
opposite the gate there extended a third smaller
wing. The walls of each wing rose like a cliff
on either hand, with three tiers of cells like so
many caves. Round the cells run balconies
with spiral stairways connecting them. Across
the midmost balcony wire netting is extended
lest men’s nerves get the better of them. Half-way
down each wing the monotonous succession
of cell doors is broken on each side, and a little
recess formed for latrines.
Each wing bears a letter of the alphabet,
and each cell a number. Each man on entrance
has his name inscribed on one side of a cardboard
form, and his cell number on the other. This
is placed in a wooden slot outside his cell. The
name is turned to the wall, and the number
turned to view. By that is signified that his
name is no longer needed, and he becomes a
number. Inasmuch as the system is subtly
devised for the extinction of personality, of
identity, this is a deft piece of symbolism of
which any dramatist might be proud. In
Stafford I was C 2:21:—Wing C., Balcony 2,
Cell 21.
Cells are ever the same, even as their occupants
are presumed to be. My cell at Stafford
was the same as at Castlebar, save that the
upper half of the walls was painted yellow
instead of being whitewashed, the lower half
red instead of yellow, and the floor paved.
The window was much smaller and very dark.
Unlike Castlebar, it had no gas jet inside. Instead
of this, a square thick pane of glass beside
the door covered an incandescent burner that
was lit from outside. The cavity in which the
burner stood narrowed to a small slit in the
outer wall, lest any prisoner should magically
narrow himself with a view to escaping through
an aperture a foot square. Beside the door
appeared the usual bell handle. By turning
it sharply to one side a gong was rung above the
latrine recess, and the same action registered
one’s number outside.
XIII.
All that I had feared in Castlebar now returned
upon me; yet, curiously, not so keenly, not so
sharply. Already there had been a dulling of
consciousness, a blunting of the susceptibilities.
During the early morning we were examined
medically and then bathed in antiseptic. We
needed it; herded on the dusty floors of Richmond
Barracks we had collected what was to
be collected, and had, as a Tyrone lad put it,
“grazed our cattle through-other”; and the
doctor nodded gravely over his inspection,
like one who thought, “Well, this is the Irish
nation: report has not spoken untruly of them.”
Then we were taken back to our cells. During
the afternoon we were taken out for a quarter
of an hour’s exercise in silence round one of the
yards at the back of the prison, and solemnly
informed that if any attempt to communicate
with one another were detected we would be
removed to special punishment cells and fed on
bread and water for a week. Back to our cells
then until the following afternoon.
That was our life. We were awoken at five
and brought out for lavatory parade. Soon
after six breakfast was served out to us. This
consisted of a tin mug of tea, a square lump
of white bread, and a small piece of margarine.
Inasmuch as the mug served for soup as well
as for tea, and presumably the tea was decocted
in the same vessel as the soup, there was a
strong similarity of taste between the two.
Nor was the fluid that reached us always very
hot. We were not permitted either knife, fork
or spoon. While we took our breakfast the
staff retired to theirs, and the curiously deathly
prison silence descended on the place. At a
quarter to eight the staff returned with the
jangling of many keys, and soon the shouts of
commands rent the air. For we were now to
scrub out our cells. On the ground floor each
man had, in addition to his cell, to scrub a
portion of the hall opposite his door. When
this was accomplished, if the staff-sergeant had
any general instructions to announce, or could
by any means devise an occasion for instructions,
we were put on parade in the hall to hear him
discourse. The staff-sergeant had a Biblical
gift of iteration without the Biblical music of
phrase. Nor had he the faculty of disguising
his repetitions. He had, however, a certain
ornateness of expression which, though it was
not exactly Biblical, succeeded in relieving the
monotony of his discourse. If he had two
simple announcements to make he occupied
himself for half an hour with them, and with
variations on them, striding up and down the
line of us, shouting at the top of his voice, while
his staff of non-commissioned officers stood
amongst us to see that we gave due heed to what
he said. He was an excellent man, however;
and meant kindly.
Back then to our cells, where we sat till dinner.
This was brought round (by orderlies appointed
from among ourselves) at twelve. Dinner consisted
of soup and a lump of white bread.
The soup was contained in the same mug as the
morning tea, and was, until one became accustomed
to it, a strange looking spectacle. In
the midst of it floated a lump of something that
varied according to one’s varying luck. If one
were fortunate it was, mainly, meat; if one’s
luck were only fair, it consisted of fat, with streaks
of lean bravely running through it; if one’s
luck were completely out, it was gristle, with
bits of meat set in it like amethysts in quartz
(and indeed the meat was illuminated by strange
colours astonishingly like amethysts). Either
the animals slain for our eating were curious
beasts or my luck was badly out, for the
succession of gristle that came to my turn was
noteworthy. Afterwards I managed to smuggle
out one of the islands that floated in my soup,
and sent it entire to a member of the English
Parliament, thinking the effect might be
remarkable if it were thrown dramatically across
the floor of the House, as Burke once threw a
dagger. Two or three potatoes in their skins
were served with the soup; and the whole meal
had to be manipulated with one’s fingers. I
became quite expert with the course of time in
discovering where pieces of meat crouched in
their layers of gristle and bringing them to the
light of day with my forefinger. Yet often I
decided that the meal was not worth the fatigue
involved, and left it where it stood.
The afternoons served our scanty pleasure,
for then we were taken out for exercise, which
usually lasted twenty minutes to half an hour,
and on some occasions longer, according to the
pleasure of the sergeant in control. For the
staff worked through the prisoners in batches
through the day. How one looked forward
to that glimpse of sky overhead, to that beat
of the summer’s sun on one’s body. The
yard was of great size as befitted the size of
the prison, and was laid with ground clinkers,
or some black earth of the nature of ashes,
surrounded by a concrete path. There was no
colour to be seen anywhere, save the red bricks
of the gaol and the black floor of the yard. Yet
the sky was blue overhead, and the sun was
golden; and though these things were plaintive
in what they told of a summer passing in pomp
elsewhere, yet their immediate gift made that
half hour of the day the moment for which we
lived during the 23½ hours’ existence in a cell.
Moreover, after a time I tried an experiment.
I quietly stepped out of the file into the yard
and began running easily within the circle that
the others made about me. I saw the sergeant
look at me, not quite knowing what to make
of the innovation. Then another stepped out,
and ran behind me; and another, and yet
another, till there was a string of half a dozen
of us. Nothing was said the first day; and
the innovation once begun it was continued.
Thus we had another event to which to look
forward during the long hours.
At five came tea, which was a repetition of
breakfast; and then set in the hours we most
dreaded. The staff went home at five, and
silence settled down over the prison—a silence
that was not broken till five the next morning.
Now and then as the night watchman passed in
his padded shoes I would hear the spy-hole slot
being moved aside and would know that an eye
was looking in upon me. Then the slot fell back
again. The eye had passed on to the next cell.
But all the time the silence was profound.
The lengthening day, with the altered hour,
gave light till ten at night. That is to say,
the customary twilight of the cell did not change
to profound gloom and then to darkness till
after that hour. That made the case worse,
for one would not take refuge in sleep. It
would be hard to say how many times I counted
the number of bolts that studded the door,
how many times I counted the number of bricks
in each wall, how many times I measured the
number of feet from end to end of the cell, from
side to side, and from corner to corner. This
was one’s occupation for twenty-three hours
out of the twenty-four, save for the time given
to sleep, until one fell back on bitter blank
staring ahead.
Sometimes, as though to make the silence
still more oppressive, I heard one of the other
prisoners somewhere down the prison break into
a song. Then a harsh voice would loudly call on
him to be quiet; and silence would be supreme
again. Already on my first day I had established
friendly relations with my corporal. He
was, I discovered, a London Irishman, and he
happened to be more easily quickened to interest
on that account. I asked him once what the
other men did with their time, when he spied
in upon them, thinking to find comfort for my
hours in a more intelligent knowledge of the
life that was silently proceeding around me.
“Most of them just sit on their stools and
stare at the wall. It’s horrible to see them.
Lots of them are crying—some that you wouldn’t
think of. And a lot of them are praying, always
praying. And that’s worse, for things are not
as bad as that. It makes me feel bad to see
them.”
I thought of Dame Quickly with her, “Now
I, to comfort him, bid him a’ should not think
of God; I hoped there was no need to trouble
himself with any such thoughts yet,” and
smiled. But I wished I had not asked him my
question.
Yet, strangely enough, the thing that I had
feared with such horror in its coming at Castlebar
did not quicken in me such fear now that it had
settled upon me. The process had, as most
processes do, brought its own rather ghastly
relief. In Castlebar I had been keen and sensitive;
my mind had been quick to speed ahead
and anticipate the approaching evil; and that,
if painful, was a preferable estate to this dead
inertia, when the mind seemed hardly to have
any existence in the body.
and I cannot wonder at it; for often one would
spring to one’s feet and march up and down the
cell in a mental excitement that was almost
unendurable. Such times, when they came,
came intolerably, for they came with diminishing
frequency; but the usual state was inertia.
There was something of learned patience about
it; something of a reserve that waited its day;
but deeper set than these things was the blankness
of being that it was the first duty of the
whole system to achieve.
I tried, for instance, to bring before me the
faces of those whom I knew, and to imagine
what they might be doing as I thought of them.
I sought, thus, to give myself a life in the life
that others were living; but could I think of
those lives, could I bring their faces before me?
It was not that they fled me. The mind simply
would not rise to the effort. I tried to surrender
myself to problems of thought that had fascinated
me in the past, and to problems of being
into which all life’s meaning had been crowded.
But at most the wheel only spun round, never
gripping the metal; and more often the wheel
refused to move. The life within the cell was
significantly told by the card outside: the
name was turned to the wall, and only a number
was turned to view. Prison cells are not dwellings,
they are sepulchres.
So the days passed, one by one, while the
summer rolled by outside. Even the will to
fight seemed lost.
XIV.
Sunday brought relief. That day there was
no exercise; but when we were aroused we all
went to Mass. The Protestant Chapel was
used, for there was no room elsewhere for both
prisons-full. Everybody went, whatever our
creed, both for the comfort of one another, and
for the joint comfort of worship. There I saw
for the first time the Dublin men from the
Crescent, many of them known to me, many
of them wearing the uniform of the Republican
Army, in some cases scarred by battle. It was
a large concourse, and the body of song was a
joy to hear after our enforced silence. The
warders sat at regular intervals on seats above
us, with their backs turned to the Altar and their
faces toward us, like strange idols perched aloft.
The priest, I learned, had told the first men
on their arrival that he was there to fulfil his
functions only, though he abhorred their actions
and could have no dealings with them. This
he had announced at their first Mass, and he
had till now preserved that attitude, never
suffering himself to discover by closer contact
the cause of the sufferings that stirred his anger.
The following day I put myself down to see
him, and during the course of the morning he
visited me.
“You wish to see me,” he said. He was
exceedingly kind and courteous.
“Yes,” I said; “I wish to congratulate you
on the fact that you are not here in prison with
us.”
“I don’t understand you.”
“For preaching sedition, or at least reading
seditionary stuff. You recall the epistle you
read yesterday? I think it was misapplied,
mind you. You were exhorting us to do just
what we had done, and had been thrown into
prison for; but you read it all the same, and
deserve congratulation. Do you remember:
‘Be ye doers of the Word, and not
hearers only, deceiving your own selves, for
if a man be a hearer of the Word, and not
a doer, he shall be compared to a man beholding
his own countenance in a glass. For he
beheld himself, and went his way, and
presently forgot what manner of man he was.
But he that hath looked into the perfect law
of liberty, and hath continued therein,
not becoming a forgetful hearer, but a doer
of the work; this man shall be blessed in
his deed.’
“That’s sound talk; every word of it applies;
and we are blessed in the deed, though we are
in prison all the same.
In that connection you think over that phrase
about the man who looked into a mirror, and
presently forgot what manner of man he was,
till he became a doer of the Word after having
looked into the perfect law of liberty. I thank
you for that epistle; and I congratulate you
that you are not in prison.”
Afterwards he moved among us intimately
and always. He made it his business to know
each man personally, and there was scarcely a
man to whom he did not endear himself. In
very literal truth he spent himself and his
substance for us all. He got into touch with
the men’s families at home, and reassured both
man and family as to the state of the other.
During those days, indeed, he lived his life with
us, and every man turned to him as to a brother.
What he said to me of his opinion of the men
may pass; but I subsequently heard that he
said publicly in his chapel in the town that if
his hearers wished to know what faith was, what
religion, what principle and truth, he would
commend them to look in the jail. He had his
convictions and emotions as an Englishman;
we had ours as Irishmen; but there is no man
who was at Stafford Jail for his convictions and
emotions who does not cherish with affection
the name of Father Moore.
Some Sundays afterwards he had occasion to
read the following epistle:—
“Be you humbled under the mighty
hand of God, that He may exalt you in the
time of visitation. Casting all your care
upon Him, for He hath care of you. Be
sober and watch; for your adversary the
devil, as a roaring lion goeth about, seeking
whom he may devour; whom resist ye,
strong in faith....”
As he did so, his eye travelled over to me; and
the following day he came over to me.
“I know what you are going to say. You
make me watchful of my epistles,” he said.
XV.
Deadened and inert though the barbarity of
solitary confinement caused one to become
(and even as solitary confinement ours was
particularly severe and therefore particularly
barbarous) there were times when the whole
being rose in revolt. Anything would have
been preferable to it. On one such occasion I
demanded to see the Commandant of the jail.
When he came, I requested to know exactly
why I was being punished, and for what offence.
I told him that I wished to have his answer in
writing and to be able to communicate with my
solicitor with a view to taking action. My
thought was that a personal suit against him
might prove abortive, but that it might cause a
publicity the effect of which would be healthy.
He replied that I was not being punished;
that I was simply being “detained.” I said
that this could not be. According to prison
regulations, solitary confinement of so severe a
nature was punishment at least equivalent to
birching. Would he birch me without acquainting
me with the cause of such a punishment?
No, he said, he would not. Then why, I asked,
was I receiving a punishment equivalent in
severity without a cause assigned. I wished to
be provided with a cause, and to be provided
with it in writing.
The Commandant himself was gentlemanly
and courteous. A few days afterwards when I
repeated my request he told me he was simply
acting under orders, and that he could not
change matters without orders. I asked him
then if he would communicate my request to
the War Office, under whose instructions he
proceeded; and he promised to do so.
Some time elapsed; and when he spoke to
me further about the matter he asked what it
was that I demanded. He asked me if I would
particularise. I replied that the War Office
had on their own initiative defined us as Prisoners
of War. It had been announced to us that
all our letters had to be so addressed; all the
orders given to us were made applicable under
that heading. I said I did not quarrel with the
designation; both nationally and personally
I hailed it. It was, I agreed, a splendid designation;
but such being our state, I demanded
on our behalf the application of the international
agreement governing the treatment of prisoners
of war—an agreement that, I believed, had been
ratified between the belligerent powers during
the first week of the war. In other words, I
wanted tobacco and pipe, I wished any books
that I might order or that might be sent in to
me, daily papers, free communication with my
fellow-prisoners, and the opening of cell doors
by night and by day, the right to have food sent
into us, and the return of my money in order
that I might be able to purchase food in the town,
and facilities to purchase it, by canteen or by
order. I added that what I demanded I demanded
not for myself but for all of us, and in
all of the prisons.
After a few days he came to me to say that
the War Office had authorised him to grant these
rights, but to grant them in stages, and with
one stipulation. That stipulation he would
announce to the men. Having put us all on
parade he announced the rights that would
be granted, but said that it would first be
necessary for us to choose a commandant from
among ourselves who would be responsible to
him for the good order of the prison, and who
would have power to maintain discipline. The
men appointed me, and I created officers for
each of the landings.
So began our little republic, and so extended
our educative influence. When the rights were
in full force the staff became supernumeraries.
We created our post office and handled our own
parcels and letters for distribution. Rules were
laid down for the ordering of our life together;
and only once or twice was it necessary to
take disciplinary measures (solitary confinement
in one case as a pathetic reminder!), for the
general spirit of loyalty and affection was
sufficient—was, in fact, remarkable with a body
of men not accustomed to the strict rules necessary
to the ordering of such a community. The
appointed officers were responsible for their
landings, made daily reports, and brought up
any cases with which they were unable to deal.
And so from top to bottom we maintained ourselves,
quietly eliminating the staff, to the no
small dissatisfaction of some of them, though
with the good will of most. There was, in fact,
no work for most of the staff to do.
At seven each morning, after breakfast, and
at eight at night, the bell was rung, and we all
gathered for public prayers. Michael MacRory
Irish orator, and Padraic Pearse’s gardener, led
the Rosary. Englishmen speak much of our
religious differences. It devolved upon me as
a Protestant to summon the prayers, and none
thought otherwise of it than as a natural thing,
while every Protestant knelt with his fellows in
prayer to the one God. Whatever announcements
or enquiries Father Moore had to make
were made through a Protestant, and had anyone
suggested that they should not have been
so made, it would have fared ill with him.
They were made as a simple matter of authority
by whoever was in authority. The reason
for this was that we were sufficient in ourselves
to guard over our own affairs without a stranger’s
hand to create trouble.
These daily prayers were a great astonishment
to the staff. One sergeant declared to a visitor:
“I heard a lot about these Sinn Feiners being
a bad lot, but you should see them. They’re
a religious lot. They goes to prayers and
church same as we goes to the theaytre.” And
when, some days after our public prayers had
begun, the news came that the “Hampshire”
had sunk, there was not a man of the staff but
was fully assured that it was our prayers had
sent Lord Kitchener to his death.
At ten each night every man was required
to be off the corridor and balconies, and any
conversation in cells after that time had to
be conducted softly, in order not to interfere
with those who wished to sleep; and within
five minutes of the ringing of the bell the prison
was clear and quiet. The staff became accustomed,
if they had business to execute with us,
to resign it into our hands for prosecution.
Those who did not do so made a sad affair of
their undertaking. Which is a parable. In a
phrase, our motto was:
It was interesting to notice our influence on
the staff. We never troubled about them;
they had their interests and we had ours; and
only occasionally the national opposition clashed
sharply. Yet they confided in us. With our
extended rights the library was opened to us;
and the librarian-warder informed us that he
was at first afraid to be left alone in the library
with any one of us. Apparently he thought we
would bite out his windpipe unexpectedly,
or playfully split his skull. But when his first
visitor, a man from Belfast, contemptuously
described his collection of books as “piffle,”
and asked that certain other books should be
procured from the officers’ library, as he himself
declared: “My word, I was surprised. I
thought you Sinn Feiners were a wild lot of
savages from what I heard of you. But you
are men of culture, most of you. It’s a bit of
a shock to a man to find out.” The librarian-warder
was quite pleased at the widening range
of his ethnographical knowledge.
Yet the most interesting member of the
staff was the sergeant of the R.A.M.C. He was
a Doctor of Literature at Oxford, and also, I
believe, a Docteur ès Lettres at the Sorbonne.
He had been out at Gallipoli, whence he had
been invalided home. As he passed on his
rounds he would often come into my cell for a
talk. We very seldom spoke on national questions,
for I assumed that our orbits of interest
on such matters would not cut each other at
any point; our conversation was generally
on literary or philosophical matters. But once
he came up to me with a definite thing to say.
“You know,” he said, “the Government
make a great mistake putting men like you into
prison. You will never forget it; you can
never forget it; no man could who canvasses
experience with his intellect. They’re simply
a lot of grandfatherly old fools at the top of
affairs, and we always make a muddle of things.
They should either give you a clear run, and let
you make what you can of your country and
take the chances; or they should wait their
chance and shoot you out of hand and laugh at
the racket afterwards. But all this sentimental
talk about your country, followed up by all this
muddle, simply makes a thinking man sick.
All this business,” and he indicated the hundreds
of us standing talking about the yard, “is
clumsy, it’s idiocy, and it breeds more clumsiness
and idiocy for the future.”
“Which of your two alternatives would
you adopt?” I asked him.
“Well, you know, one likes to meet a man to
whom one can talk; intellect, and all that sort
of thing, and culture, and care for art, they’re
rare enough in this world, and one wouldn’t
altogether care to take the responsibility of
destroying any part of it—”
“But you’d shoot me all the same.”
“Yes, I think I would.” He was quite
serious. “Quite possibly that’s because I’ve
just been seeing a lot of blood; and I don’t
think I would have said that two years ago.
But just now I’d shoot you. I wouldn’t of course
do it in a stupid way. I’d wait till you gave
me a chance; and sooner or later you
would, for you have your convictions, and
they’d lead you into my hand; and then I’d
shoot you instantly, and without trial if need
be, without waiting anyhow. Of course there’d
be trouble afterwards, but I’d wait quietly till
that blew over, as it would.”
“That wouldn’t get you out of the wood, for
you’d make a martyr of me and exploit my
ideals.”
“That’s so. There’s that side, of course.
But still that’s what I think I’d do. I certainly
wouldn’t go muddling about trying to do two
mutually contradictory things at the same
time. All you men here—the whole thing’s
simply offensive.”
“Does the hypocrisy offend you then? You
ought to have become accustomed to that by
this time as a nation.”
“Well, yes, in a way it does, I suppose. But
it’s not that mainly; it’s the clumsy thinking;
it’s not thinking the thing out from the beginning.
Do I horrify you?”
“Not at all. If you came over to Ireland you’d
have a great audience. We’d agree with you
in every word, simply and utterly. We’d be
delighted to meet one of your nation who looked
at things without any silly sentiment. You’re
a sentimental people, and at bottom very cruel;
we’re not sentimental. You are as sentimental
as any yourself; but you’ve at least got your
mentality clear of it, and so for the first time
you can see things as they are. The worst
of it is that, dealing with a sentimental people,
you are making us superficially sentimental
too, and that’s distracting us from our work.
I only wish that more of you would talk as you
do, instead of slobbering. And shoot away;
as long as you say why, without using words
that convey nothing to us and that only mean
sloppy thinking on your part.”
“But I thought you objected to the shootings
in Dublin.”
“Certainly. Those men were my brothers.
But they weren’t shot as you said you’d shoot
me, because you were out to smash an opposed
thing as the only logical alternative to giving
it the run of its own life, but, if you please,
because they didn’t accept certain standards
which none of us can ever accept until we make
and endorse them in terms of ourselves—or,
rather, which we now do and must for ever
act upon in that sense, because it’s the first
principle of life so to do. And then, when you
have them shot, you turn round and praise their
noble ideals! In the name of heaven, what
ideals?”
“I think I should certainly shoot you now.”
“To smash me. Good man! We’d understand
that in Ireland, where your Liberal sentiments
bore us, and your Tory hectoring irritates
us. We’re a kindly people—human and hospitable;
but you, because you can escape into
words and hide realities from yourselves, are
cruel and inhospitable.”
And I believe he would have shot me. Many
were the conversations we had; many were the
kindly, thoughtful acts he did for us; and he was
courtesy itself to the ladies who spent their
days at the prison gate taking rebuffs from
everyone in the prison, in the determination
to see that each man of us received what he
had need of, food or clothing. But he would
have reasoned the thing out and shot me,
without the least ill-will or high-falutin. And
I would have borne him no ill-will, for the fight
would have continued long past the two of us.
XVI.
These more fortunate times soon came to an
end—for me at least. So long as they lasted
they were not intolerable; and the various
funds in aid of prisoners, and the companies of
our fellow-countrymen and women (chiefly
women!) who came to visit us, made captivity
as amenable as it could be made. But one
morning I was summoned to the Commandant’s
office, and informed that I and some
fifty others were to be sent that day to an
internment camp at Frongoch in Wales. We
were to be the first to arrive, and we were to
take charge of the camp and order and regulate
it for the remainder of the Irish Prisoners of
War, who would arrive in detachments from
Stafford, from Knutsford, from Perth, from
Glasgow, from Wakefield, from Wandsworth,
and from Lewes.
Such were the orders, and we were to be ready
to leave in an hour’s time. But I had what
H. P. afterwards chaffingly alluded to as my
“strategic illness.” Never till then did I
admire the amazing insight and foresight of
Dublin Castle.
I was in fact covered from head to foot with
the proof of their perspicuity. And as a result
all the detachments to Frongoch from Stafford
were held back for three weeks to cover the
period of infection.
Thus I spent nearly a fortnight in hospital
in the company of an R.A.M.C. corporal who was
isolated with me. He had been a Northumberland
mines inspector, and we discussed the
working of mines, their proprietorship and
profits, and the virtues of Trades Unions. Sometimes
my friend the sergeant came and stood
out of sight, and beyond infection, behind the
door. He informed me that it had been discovered
that I had written a book on Shakespeare,
and that I was to be treated with respect
accordingly. He seemed to be somewhat
amused at this. But my corporal snorted with
northern scorn, and declared that if I could not
be treated with respect as a man, I should not
be treated with respect as a man who had
written books. So, with one hand, one touched
both ends of English society.
When I rose I was informed by the Commandant
that I was not to rejoin the others. Since
I had been ill, it appeared, instructions had been
received that I and another were to be isolated.
That other (H. P.) was already in a cell in the
Crescent, where I was to be taken. He and I
would be allowed to speak to one another whenever
the staff arrangements permitted of it;
but never, under any circumstances, were we to
be allowed to communicate with the others.
And, at the same time, he handed me my official
order of internment, stating that according to
regulations drafted for dealing with “aliens,”
I was to be interned because I was “reasonably
suspected of having favoured, promoted or
assisted an armed insurrection against His
Majesty.”
It was easy to see a craftier hand than that of
the War Office at work in this. Yet, by isolating
us they magnified us: a result, indeed, that the
smallest wit could have foreseen. We were
exercised together in the afternoon; and when,
the first day, we passed within sight of the
others they hailed us unitedly from the distance.
Thereafter we were not permitted to pass within
sight of them.
The rooms into which we had been put
had been designed for consumptive prisoners,
and contained bracket beds attached to the wall.
The walls were plastered and smooth, and
painted in a pleasing combination of two greens.
Little things; but what they meant to anyone
who had to spend his day sitting in a small
cell! What chiefly delighted me, however, was
the blanket on my bed. It would have given
joy to a Red Indian chief. Its colours were
green, claret, and yellow. It lay on my bed
like a spread cockatoo. Life could not be drab
with that to look upon. Moreover, I had books,
and I was allowed foolscap on which to write.
So with books, pen and blanket, the days passed
with as much ease as a prison could give. For,
strangely enough, though the severity of our
condition had been much relaxed, the presence
and the effect of the system remained. Books
that demanded any thought in the reading
were avoided; the mind seemed incapable of
the effort they demanded; as soon as a page
were read it passed from the memory, and the
mind became once again a blank. One rebelled
against this at first, and sought to conquer it;
but when the will demanded an effort, the brain
replied that such efforts were for another, not
for this world, that the soul could not realise
itself in a world that had been wrought as nearly
as possible to resemble a vacuum.
A sergeant had been placed in charge of the
two of us, a grown child of a man, with all a
child’s shrewdness and sharpness, and from him
we received many friendly acts in spite of the
fact that he seemed constantly to live in fear of
some judgment that would alight on him. He
would take me into H. P.’s cell for conversation,
and he came to the tolling of the gong without
a murmur or complaint. And for twenty
minutes each day I saw my wife at the iron
gate—who, in truth, lived her days at that
gate.
Then one day Father Moore came into my
room and sat on my bed, with the tears in his
eyes. “They’re taking the men away from
me,” he said. The dear man was heart-sore
at the parting that now began. Every few
days saw the men leaving in batches of fifty
to a hundred on their way to Frongoch. Sometimes
from a distance we could see them going.
More often we had to rely on news brought
us from our sergeant. The final stage of our
journey was to begin; for we nothing doubted
that our destination was to be the same as
theirs—Frongoch, from which place no good
reports came.
It was not till they had all gone, and we had
had the long desolate prison to ourselves for
over a week that we were informed that we
were not to go to Frongoch, but were to be
removed to Reading Jail. The others having
gone, and the fear of our contamination removed,
we had been permitted the run of the prison;
and quite probably we were the only prisoners
in all time who paced alone a long prison that
echoed to our steps. The effluence of many
thousands of prisoners was about us; and we
entered the cells to find the names they had
scratched and to reconstruct their history.
Then one morning, July 10th, we were
marched out under yet another sergeant’s guard
for Reading Jail.
XVIII.
Reading Jail that day was a mustering of the
clans. All the isolation men from the various
prisons, Wakefield, Knutsford, and Wandsworth,
including many who had been to Frongoch,
were gathered together at Reading. It
was meant as an elect company; but it was not
at all as elect as the selectors imagined. We
ourselves entertained no delusions on that head.
One of the most distinguished of our company
had been wildly hailed on his arrival months
before at Wandsworth, as the man who “’ad
been a-hinciting of ’em”; and apparently the
net had been thrown to sweep into Reading all
those who “’ad been a-hinciting of ’em”; but
the net had had a singularly faulty mesh. Even
the original net that had swept through
the country during the month of May,
carefully though it had been wrought, and
thoroughly though it had been cast, had had a
mesh none too perfect. There were but twenty-eight
of us gathered together that day; and we
had, as it were, a double crown pressed on our
heads; but we made haste to disown the title
to wear it.
Yet we were glad to meet. National work
necessarily intersects at many points, and so
most of us who foregathered that day for our
months of association had met before in differing
combinations, and at different times, in differing
groups of work that were but part of the one
great work. Yet we had never met in that
particular combination before. Some came
representing the leadership of large districts,
counties or cities, and some represented national
leadership from some more central focus. The
provinces were indeed as nearly represented
as they could well be: eight came from Connacht,
seven from Leinster, seven from Munster,
and six from Ulster; or, fourteen from Leth
Chuinn and fourteen from Leth Mhogha. It
was exceedingly well arranged. Though we were
not as complete as we might have been, though
we did not venture to conceive of ourselves as
an assembly either inclusive or exclusive of
anything, yet the general representation was very
evenly matched. And it was yet more evenly
when, two days later, another Ulster representative
arrived; for, as it so fell out, a
Connacht man had been elected as Ceannphort,
and so the provinces were left matched with a
perfect seven apiece.
Such was the skill the Government of England
had taken to see, not only that we had an
opportunity of meeting and understanding one
another such as we never could have hoped for,
but that we should meet as a well-balanced and
proportionate whole. The care with which this
was wrought must have been considerable.
The only drawback to our assembly was the
uncertainty of date when we discontinue it, and
the building in which we met.
XVIII.
Reading, being set deep in a valley at the
confluence of two rivers, is an unhealthy town,
close and sultry by summer, and damp and
misty by winter. The gaol is a handsome
building, erected in red brick after the manner
of an old castle, with battlements and towers.
One almost expected a portcullis to be lowered
at the great gate; and when we were within
the double gates we certainly felt as though a
portcullis had been drawn after us. We stood
in a small cobbled yard. Behind us was the
broad wall in which the double gates were set,
flanked on each side by the Governor’s and the
Steward’s houses. Before us a flight of stone
steps arose, leading to the offices, behind which
was the large male prison. To the right a wall
arose dividing us from the work yard; and on
the left a high blind wall arose, pierced only by
a single door near the wall round the jail. This
was the female prison—ordinarily so, but for
the time being our habitation.
Yet what astonished me most was the sight of
flowers. Their presence made the cobbled yard
and the precincts seem almost collegiate. In
neatly kept beds about the walls they lifted their
heads with a happy gaiety very strange to some
of us who had known so human a touch banished
from buildings more appropriately given over
to the possession of flints and cinders. A few
days after we were taken through the work
yard behind the main prison. Here in the work
hall a canteen was opened on three days in the
week for the interned prisoners who now
occupied the prison, but here also was the large
exercise yard, and it was covered with an abundance
of flowers. The familiar asphalt paths
could not be seen where they threaded their
way amid blossoms. In beds beneath the walls
tall flowers lifted their heads, and even the graves
of hanged men could not be seen beneath the
blooms that covered them.
It was an amazing sight. There were not
merely flowers, a sight astonishing enough in
itself; there was a prodigality of flowers. Then
some of us remembered the cause. One of the
graves unlocked the secret. It was marked
with the letters C. T. W., and the date, 1896,
to whom Oscar Wilde’s “Ballad of Reading
Jail” had been inscribed, and in celebration of
whose passing the poem had been penned.
But neither milk-white rose nor red
May bloom in prison-air;
The shard, the pebble, and the flint
Are what they give us there:
For flowers have been known to heal
A common man’s despair.
So never will wine-red rose or white
Petal by petal, fall
On that stretch of mud and sand that lies
By the hideous prison-wall,
To tell the men who tramp the yard
That God’s Son died for all.
So Wilde had sung, not in protest, but in bitter
acceptance, never dreaming that a poet’s song
could change the flint, the pebble, and the
shard of the yard he trod. But for us who
came after him with the memory of his song in
our minds, the miracle had been wrought.
Miracle it was, and it had been wrought in no
common sort, for the great yard was a lake
of leaf and bloom, and the hideous prison wall
was transformed by gay figures decked in
raiment that not Solomon in all his glory could
outvie.
Already in the pebbled entrance yard the hand
of this “unacknowledged legislator” was in
evidence. We were first taken across to the
office, as we arrived in batches, and our money
taken from us, and our kit examined. Then
we were led back through the door in the blind
wall into the female prison, that had been
allocated to Irish Prisoners of War. The main
prison was occupied by the nations of Europe:
Belgians, Germans, French, Rumanians, Russians,
and indeed every degree and variety of
European to the number of fourteen.
The prison actually held only twenty-two
cells. There were in addition a hospital, a
maternity ward, and two padded cells, one
permanent and one temporary. The hospital
and maternity ward consisted of two cells each,
with the intervening wall removed. In each of
these three men were placed (there being some
little rivalry for the maternity ward), which
with the use of the temporary padded cell
provided for all of us. In addition to this, there
was also an observation ward, on the ground
floor, similarly constructed of two cells converted
into one, and this was given to us as a recreation
room. All these cells were on one side of the
building, the other side being a blank wall,
and the only light that came to the passage
struggled down through skylights.
Such was the place that was to be our habitation
for nearly six months, and in which we
erected the structure of our communal life.
XIX.
We had all come with experience of prison
life, and were not easily perturbed. We had
become accustomed to taking things as we found
them, and making them the basis of improvement,
not in the mood of those who sought
privileges, but as those who demanded rights.
Our first act was to elect a Ceann-Phort, through
whom to formulate our demands, and by whom
to lay out the lines of our life together. Our
next act was to put together the tables that
stood in the passage in order that we might
have our meals together. From the very first
during the time we were permitted together
we at once took the control of our affairs into
our own hands, and it became a recognised
principle that any dealings of officials with us
were with us as a whole and not with individuals.
For instance, the prison had to be scrubbed
through twice a week, and in addition there was
orderly work to be appointed, such as daily
sweeping, polishing of rails, cleaning of dishes,
and, as we had elected to take our meals together,
the preparation and clearance of tables. For
this work it was proposed, as in the usual way,
to select the required men, and to pay them at
the prison rate of ten pence a day. Instead of
that we desired that the payment should be
made to the Ceann-Phort, saying that the work
would be done under his arrangements. We
were then drawn out into eight teams who took
it in turns for orderly work. The fatigues on
Wednesday and Saturday were taken by each
half-company of four teams. All questions concerning
our life were arranged between our
Ceann-Phort and the prison Governor.
The moneys that were paid over to us were
expended by us, together with contributions
made from time to time from among us, on the
canteen that was open three days in the week.
For the food that we received was the same
as we had received in other prisons, except
that at first its quality was improved. While
our exchequers lasted we were able to enrich
our dietary to some extent by extra doles of
bread, margarine and sugar. This canteen was
in the hands of one of the grocers in the town
for the use of all the prisoners in the jail.
The first night we were locked up at eight
o’clock, with lights out at nine. This was one
of the first matters to which we turned our
attention. We were not successful in approximating
this to the conditions that had prevailed
elsewhere with us, such as at Stafford, but we
were finally able to have the time altered to
ten. The gravest hardships, however, in the
conditions as at first announced to us were that
we were only suffered one visit every three
months and one letter each month. These were
the ordinary conditions imposed on penal servitude
convicts,
Finally we were permitted one visit a month and
two letters each week, the letters to be written
on little slips of paper provided for us. At first
also we were refused the right to receive parcels
of food sent in by friends. This was clearly
contrary to the code prevailing for Prisoners ...;
and this also we had annulled.
Therefore our life, as finally adjusted, was
on this wise. We were aroused at seven o’clock,
and the orderlies for the day at once laid the
breakfast, which was taken at a quarter to
eight. At half-past ten we were taken out by
the warders to the work yard for exercise.
There we disported ourselves as we pleased
until we were brought in for dinner at twelve.
In the afternoon we went out, not to the work
yard, but to the small exercise yard at the back
of our prison. This was separated by a wall
from the Debtors’ Yard, of which Wilde had
sung:
In Debtors’ Yard the stones are hard,
And the dripping wall is high.
Then tea at five—
And the bitter bread they weigh in scales
Is full of chalk and lime.
After tea, during the summer months, we were
allowed out into the yard again till it was
dark, and at ten the key grated against us once
more in our cell doors.
Each narrow cell in which we dwell
Is a foul and dark latrine,
And the fetid breath of living death
Chokes up each grated screen,
And all, but Lust, is turned to dust
In Humanity’s machine.
XX. — FOOTNOTE:
We were treading a path that had already
been sung (for even bitterness has its song)
but we trod it in greater comfort. Above all
we had one another’s company. The boon of
this might conceivably have been blurred a
little, as with the passage of months it became
difficult in our cramped space to avoid treading
on one another’s toes. And certainly it was
impossible for each man not to know each other
at his best and worst. The knowledge so gained
had its value for future days. For at bottom
the solidity with which we began was only
cemented with the passage of time.
Yet our company was first to be revised, by
a process of addition and subtraction, before
it took its final shape. One Friday in August
we were informed that on the Monday and
Tuesday following we were to be taken in two
parties before the Advisory Committee. We
were asked to give our word that we would
make no attempt to escape. If we gave that
pledge we would be sent to London with warders
in plain clothes; otherwise it would be necessary
to send us handcuffed together. On this a
keen discussion took place; for while the
majority was content to give the undertaking
there were some who would give no pledge, who
would leave it to the authorities to decide for
themselves on any action they pleased. Finally
the Governor, who was very anxious to avoid
handcuffs, assumed an undertaking, and so
the issue was muffled. Two warders in
plain clothes accompanied each party to
Wormwood Scrubbs Jail; and nothing was
done to advertise the fact that we were prisoners
travelling. Had the question arisen
a few months later hardly a man would have
given the undertaking, or even have suffered
it to be implied. The public display of handcuffs
would have been coveted rather than
avoided; for it was certainly not to comfort
us that the offer was made, whatever the
Governor’s personal inclinations might have
been. For jails but straighten the back and
harden the mind.
We also differed in our attitude towards the
Advisory Committee. None of us differed in
our opinion of its function. It sat, so the
purport ran, to decide which of us might be
liberated; or rather, more technically, in respect
of which of us our internment orders should
be confirmed; but these things, as we know,
would be decided by political considerations
quite outside the review of the Committee.
None of us doubted that its main function was
to check and complete our Leabhrain, as far as
possible, by question and cross reference. But
we differed in our attitude. Some refused to
recognise the Committee in any way, as being
a body set up by a foreign government, having
no authority over Irishmen. These, when
brought before the Committee, firmly defined
their attitude, and were promptly escorted
again into the outside air. Others answered
the brief interrogatory to which they were submitted,
and went their way in a matter of
minutes. My own attitude was somewhat different.
In the first place, I had now been in prison
for some months, without much chance of
enlivenment. The opportunity of a debate
through the labyrinth of the Defence of the
Realm Regulations seemed too good a thing
to be lightly put by. Moreover, I was anxious
to discover some of the items that furnished
my leabhran. I was not disappointed. As I
had expected, deftly mixed among the questions
put to me about my own doings were a number
of questions that involved others. Also, as I
had expected, a week’s study of the Regulations
left the rather interesting legal debate not altogether
a one-sided matter; for a number of
points were conceded to me, which, when I
afterwards sought to take advantage of them,
proved to have been made without any deep
knowledge of the possibilities the Regulations
offered. One or two matters of interest emerged,
however.
For instance, the Committee had some little
difficulty in explaining exactly why, if I as an
Irishman was to be interned as an
This, I was told, was a political matter. Strangely
enough, it was exactly so I had conceived it.
Then I was informed that I was only considered
as an alien for the purposes of that particular
act, that in other matters my citizenship under
the law was not disputed. By which it appeared
that I was an alien when my imprisonment
was desired, but not an alien when my
personal and national freedom was to be consulted.
Then, among other questions, I was asked
if I had or had not endeavoured to get Irish
farm labourers into touch with Irish farmers
in order to stay their migrating to England,
where they could be taken under the Military
Service Act. On my asking on what authority
the question was put, I was answered that it
was so alleged in the local police report. My
answer was an admission of the charge. I
suggested that it might have a bearing that the
assurance had been made in Parliament that
farm labourers from Ireland could not be taken
under the Military Service Act. But it was
interesting to discover that a benefit intended
to Ireland was made the basis of a charge;
and it was interesting to discover the furniture
that found its way into police reports.[A]
When I came out and explained how it was
I had remained so long, when all the others had
been dispatched in two minutes or three, I was
told that I had at least ensured continued internment.
The price was not exhorbitant.
[A] It seems worthy of note that as I write in the year 1917
the Department of Agriculture and Technical Education have
adopted this scheme, and are being assisted in its prosecution
by the police. It took a Clown to refer to Time as a whirligig.
XXI.
The week after our excursion to Wormwood
Scrubbs, seven men were sent down to us from
Frongoch, where trouble had already begun.
There were no cells to hold them in our prison,
and so they were lodged in the reception-cells
under the offices, where neither light nor air
was bold enough to venture. They were brought
over to us for breakfast, and lived during the
day with us until they were taken back to bed.
Shortly afterwards five of our number were
summoned to the Governor’s office, and returned
saying they were to be released that day. We
already had had that joke played on us several
times, and so we gave no heed to them. But
when in a short time we saw them industriously
packing their kit, the joke wore a more earnest
expression. It was no jest, however. Although
no man changed his mien yet none but felt
what a jewel freedom was when it became within
the grasp of his neighbour, and when that
neighbour rose up and went forth proudly
wearing it. We sang them home, however,
gaily enough. In a week two more were sent
home. These seven comprised all the releases
from Reading at the same time that two thousand
and more were released from Frongoch.
It was not very difficult to discover the reasons
prompting most of these releases, and it need
hardly be said that they had little relation to
the events of Easter Week. The internments
covered a much wider ground, which was chosen
for much subtler reasons. The soldier’s hand
might rule in Ireland, but the politician’s hand
indexed the internments. And as usual the
politician over-reached himself. For the men
who were released found on their return that
the country judged them unworthy to remain;
and the Home Office officials were finally convinced
that Ireland was inhabited by the mad
when they received shoals of letters from
released men pitifully arguing that their releases
must have been in error, and giving proofs of
their part in the Rising-Out.
We, however, settled down to the honour
of imprisonment with fortitude. Already,
when we had learned that the celebrations of
the 12th of July had been forbidden in Ulster
we had filled the gap with a procession and a
meeting in which excellent Orange speeches had
been made. Now we held a Hibernian meeting.
Such things enlivened our days.
We suffered greatly from lack of exercise,
and the closeness of our confinement began to
tell upon us as the autumn approached. We
had given up going out to the work-yard for
our morning exercise, and kept to the little yard.
This yard was beset on three sides by the
buildings of the jail, and on the fourth side,
beyond the high wall, Huntley & Palmer’s
chimneys belched black smoke that blotted the
sky. In a corner of this yard we made a
hand-ball alley. No stranger alley was ever
devised. Two windows, a drain-pipe, a railing
across steps leading to the basement, and a
ventilator grating, gave opportunity for chance
and skill. And the exercise saved us.
Nevertheless, with the coming of winter the
effects of our confinement could be seen on most
of us. The food, also, had become bad. The
margarine was often rancid. On two occasions
the meat made several of us ill; and for three
months I lived only on bread and porridge, both
of which were, at least, clean and wholesome.
Prisons are not built as health resorts, yet
precautions are supposed to be taken that a
mean of temperature is maintained. During
a week of frost, however, the temperature in
my room was 46° to 48° Fahrenheit. This was
inside the cells: outside, the passage was full
of draughts. Yet the prison was never ventilated,
for the only place where air could come or
go was the door. The result was that when one
of the warders came in once with influenza,
every man in the prison in time fell to it.
Yet we kept our backs straight. P. J. D. was
informed by the Governor, on the authority of
the Home Office, that if he would sign an
undertaking to be of good behaviour for the
future he would at once be liberated. He replied
that the offer was adding insult to injury, and
he declared that if his liberation depended on
his signature of any manner of undertaking, he
was destined to remain long in prison. The Chief
Warder approached others of us, thinking to
try the ground before any other offers were
made; but he left matters as he found them.
In Frongoch at this time the same attitude
was being taken. Matters there were also
complicated by the attempt of the military to
search out Irishmen who had returned home
from England on the passage of the Military
Service Act—to search them out, not for the
Army, but for the pleasure of thrusting them
into jails. And the result of the ensuing
resistance was that seven of the leaders there
were brought to Reading and put into the
reception-cells, making our number thirty-five
once again.
XXII. — Transcriber’s Note
So the winter days passed. The prison was
wrapt continually in an unpleasant amalgam
of winter fog and Huntley & Palmer’s smoke.
We never saw the sun, though occasionally,
when the fog cleared, we could make a guess
at it where it strode the sky.
Little wonder if we occasionally got upon one
another’s nerves. None of our nerves were of
the best, and we all felt the deathly system of
prison life like an oppression on us, blotting out
all intellectual life and making a blank of mind
and soul. Yet no outsider saw cleavage among
us. That was a principle we never let down.
Of an evening we met together and discussed
different aspects of national affairs, partly with
the intention of defining our future action, and
partly with a view to defining our points of
view in their relation to one another. The two
things were really one; for satisfactorily to
outline the second was already largely to complete
the first; and we were determined not to
lose the chance with which we had been so
admirably furnished. Moreover, when birthdays
arrived we had modest supper-parties, in
which song and good will supplied the lack of
viands.
Yet towards the end, with illness and depression
settling on most of us, we kept largely
to our own cells, despite their icy temperature.
We were suffered books—carefully selected. It
became part of our business carefully to test the
selection by arranging for a variety of books
to be sent in to us by friends. Especially was
this so when a happy accident gave us the name
of our censor; and it was deeply interesting to
see his path among the classics of Irish literature.
In this we were assisted by our friends outside.
Indeed, not the least value of our months of
imprisonment was the revelation of friendship,
and its spontaneity and strength and unity in
those of our race. We had but to express a need
and it was at once met by leagues and committees
that had been gathered together, both
at home and in England, to befriend and serve
us. If our state was like that of an island it
was at least an island washed by a great sea of
friendship.
The gifts cast up by the tides of that sea
became embarrassing as Christmas approached.
We had altogether to dispense with prison fare;
and our thrills of excitement were not the less
because we were so remote from the outer
world. But the full bounty of that sea was
never to be experienced by us.
Shut away though we were, we watched
political affairs closely—watched not merely
the surface that appeared, but watched for
indications of the hidden streams that ran—and
when John Dillon brought forward his
motion for the discussion of the Irish Prisoners
of War we guessed that he had learned some hint
that we were to be released. This came soon
after the failure to get us to sign pledges of
good behaviour. When, however, the threatened
motion was never taken, it was clear that
we were not to be released. We were not greatly
affected; but we watched that pending motion
with interest. It became a theme of daily jest
with us. When, after the change of government,
the motion at last was discussed, the sign was
clear to us; and we were not surprised when,
the following day, we learned that Irish interned
prisoners were to be released. In a noncommittal
way some of us began to pack—like
men who were content, the next moment, to
unpack, and take whatever came without perturbation.
On Friday, the 22nd of December,
we heard that the Frongoch men were going, and
during that day we learned that a courier was
expected during the afternoon with papers for
our release. No courier, however, arrived;
and Sunday saw us content again to continue
as we were without complaint. It appeared,
as I afterwards learnt, that the Home Office
had actually arranged for our release together
with the men at Frongoch, but that the Irish
Office had intervened. It was not till the
Sunday afternoon that the Home Office won its
way. For on that day, Christmas Eve, at half-past
two, the Governor came into the prison
to tell us that we were to be ready to go out in
two hours’ time. It seemed indeed that our
maximum of inconvenience had been sought;
for it was impossible then for many of us to reach
home for Christmas, and such men had need to
lodge where they could with the more fortunate.
So at half-past four we passed out through the
streets of Reading, singing our songs as we went.
Each man went to take up his duty as he had
always conceived it, but with the added hardness
inevitably begotten of a jail. And each
man remembered his fellows who still were in
jail, the men who, for the same duty and for
the same high cause, were serving sentences at
Lewes, beside whom our sufferings were a light
thing lightly endured.
New Plays and Poems.
PLAYS OF GODS & MEN. Containing “The
Laughter of the Gods,” “The Queen’s Enemies,”
“The Tents of the Arabs” and “A Night at an
Inn.” By Lord Dunsany. Crown 8vo, 3/6 net.
A NEW PLAY BY EDWARD MARTYN.
THE DREAM PHYSICIAN. A Play in three
acts. Cloth, 2/- net.
OTHER PLAYS BY EDWARD MARTYN.
MAEVE. A psychological Play in two acts.
Cloth, 2/- net.
THE HEATHER FIELD. A Play in three
acts. Cloth, 2/- net.
These Plays, first issued in one volume in 1899, are now
reissued in popular form.
AN IRISH PLAY BY A NEW DRAMATIST.
THE KINGDOM-MAKER. A Play in five acts.
By Seosamh O’Neill. Cloth, 2/- net.
BY THE AUTHOR OF “BIRTHRIGHT.”
SPRING, AND OTHER PLAYS. Including
“The Briery Gap,” and “Sovereign Love.”
By T. C. Murray. Cloth, 2/6 net.
A POET OF THE INSURRECTION.
THE POEMS OF JOHN FRANCIS MacENTEE.
Imperial 16mo. cloth 2/6.
A NEW VOLUME BY PADRIC GREGORY.
IRELAND: A SONG OF HOPE, and other
Poems and Ballads. Cr. 8vo, cloth, 2/6 net.
ROADSIDE FANCIES. Verses by H. C.
Huggins. Paper cover, 1/- net.